Controls of microbial N cycling in agricultural grassland soils

Fertilization experiments provide insights into elemental imbalances in soil microbial communities and their consequences for soil nutrient cycling. By addition of selected nutrients, other nutrients become deficient and limiting for soil microorganisms as well as for plants. In this study we focused on microbial nitrogen (N) cycling in a long-term nutrient manipulation experiment. In many soils, the rate-limiting step in N cycling is depolymerization of high-molecular-weight nitrogen compounds (e.g., proteins) to oligomers (e.g., peptides) and monomers (e.g., amino acids) rather than the subsequent steps of mineralization (ammonification) and nitrification. The aim of our study was to determine whether nutrient deficiency directly or indirectly – via changes in plant carbon (C) inputs - affects soil microbial N processing.

We collected soil samples from a fertilization experiment, established in 1946 on a hay meadow close to Admont (Styria, Austria). The field experiment consisted of a full factorial combination of inorganic N, P, and K fertilization and a control with no fertilizers. Furthermore, liming (Ca-addition) and organic fertilizer application treatments (solid manure and liquid slurry) were established. In the experiment, plant biomass is harvested three times per year, inducing strong nutrient limitation in plots that have not received nutrient additions (fully deficient or deficient in a single element). We determined gross rates of microbial protein depolymerization, N-mineralization and nitrification via isotope pool dilution assays with ¹⁵N-labeled amino acids, NH₄⁺, and NO₃^-. We hypothesized that N deficiency (lack of N fertilization) would stimulate microbial N mining (depolymerization), and reduce subsequent N mineralization and nitrification. In contrast, we expected that organic fertilization would alleviate microbial C and N limitations, reducing N depolymerization rates and increasing mineralization and nitrification.

Our results show that organically fertilized and limed soils have significantly lower gross protein depolymerization rates than plots receiving inorganic N. No significant differences were found comparing gross N-mineralization and gross nitrification rates across the different treatments. Given the higher rates of protein depolymerization in inorganically fertilized soils as compared to organically fertilized and limed soils, microbial N processes seem to be controlled by plant C input and/or soil pH rather than by direct soil nutrient availability. However, depolymerization of macromolecular N does not only supply N to the soil microbial community but also organic C. Thus, the reduced plant C input compared to fully fertilized soils may have caused microorganisms to increase their mining for a C-containing energy source, thereby increasing protein depolymerization rates. In summary, this study suggests that long term nutrient deficiency or nutrient imbalances may affect soil nutrient cycling indirectly by changing plant C inputs (via reduced primary production) and/or changing soil pH, rather than directly, by nutrient availability. This further indicates that soil microbial communities are rather C than nutrient limited.