S14 | Urban shade quantification and evaluation
Urban shade quantification and evaluation
Conveners: David Pearlmutter, Or Aleksandrowicz
Orals
| Fri, 11 Jul, 11:00–13:00 (CEST)|Room Leeuwen 2
Posters
| Attendance Thu, 10 Jul, 18:00–19:00 (CEST) | Display Thu, 10 Jul, 13:30–Fri, 11 Jul, 16:00|Exchange Hall
Orals |
Fri, 11:00
Thu, 18:00
Scientifically speaking, “urban shade” is an ill-defined concept. While it is commonly thought of as the interception of direct solar radiation by some solid element above the urban terrain, we still lack widely accepted methods for quantifying and evaluating the quality of its presence in urban settings. To what extent does shade quality decline when shading elements allow some penetration of sunlight? How much solar blocking is required to create well-shaded conditions? Is there a qualitative difference between the shade of trees and non-vegetative canopies? How much shade do we need in an urban setting, and what area should it cover? When calculating the availability of shade, what is the most important time period to consider and design for? In recent years, as concerns over urban heat have been growing, much attention has been shifting from the general concept of urban heat island mitigation to the specific issue of pedestrian heat stress reduction. Shade has thus emerged as the most effective method to significantly reduce thermal stress under hot daytime weather conditions, not only because of the significant contribution of solar radiation to heat stress but also because the provision of shade, unlike other climatic factors, totally relies on design decisions. Nevertheless, this belated interest has only exposed the many blind spots and uncharted territories that call for our attention if we want to support a more efficient and effective integration of shade into cities.

The session will, therefore, be open to contributions that relate to methods and tools for quantifying and evaluating shade and shading elements in urban areas, focusing on their potential translation into urban design practices and policies. Case studies in which such methods and tools are implemented, and in which their effectiveness is evaluated, are also welcome. Sub-topics of interest include, but are not limited to: * the quantification and evaluation of shading effects from urban trees and other vegetation, including the physiological properties and functioning of plant canopies; * the design and optimization of non-vegetative shading devices and built elements; * the impact of shade on pedestrian biophysical stress, perceived thermal sensation and climate-related behavior; * the reduction of surface and/or air temperature at micro-, meso- and city scale; and * the development of design and planning guidelines for urban shade provision.

Orals: Fri, 11 Jul, 11:00–13:00 | Room Leeuwen 2

Chairpersons: Or Aleksandrowicz, David Pearlmutter
11:00–11:15
|
ICUC12-955
|
Onsite presentation
Ariane Middel, Gisel Guzman, and Waqar Hassan Khan

Shade is a critical urban design feature for mitigating heat stress, particularly in hot, arid cities. Its impact on pedestrians is highly localized, site-specific, and dependent on multiple factors, including shade type, orientation, and ground cover. As cities strive to address "shade deserts"—urban areas lacking adequate shade infrastructure—decision-support tools are needed to inform optimal shade placement and design. We developed a web-based decision-support tool that generates shade performance curves to evaluate the cooling efficacy of various shade types. Users can customize parameters such as shade type, size, location, and date to assess their effectiveness in reducing heat load. The tool displays a rendered hemispherical view of the shade structure and a graph illustrating the hourly reduction in mean radiant temperature (ΔMRT) compared to a sun-exposed location. We validated the tool using MaRTy, a human-biometeorological cart, for hot, sunny summer days in Phoenix, Arizona. Sun-exposed locations had an RMSE of 5.9°C and an MBE of -4.2°C. Umbrella shade was underestimated systematically (MBE = -4.39°C) with an RMSE of 6.0°C. Tree shade was modeled with an RMSE of 5.1°C and a lower bias (-2.0°C). Shade performance varied by ground type, with concrete yielding the best accuracy (RMSE = 4.0°C, d = 0.86), while grass exhibited greater variability. A sensitivity analysis was conducted to investigate shade performance across shade types, seasons, and times of day. The web-based decision-making tool will allow users to assess the heat load impacts of customized, site-specific shade interventions for active shade management, offering planners and designers a robust tool for strategic shade implementation.

How to cite: Middel, A., Guzman, G., and Khan, W. H.: Online Decision-Making Tool for Active Shade Management, 12th International Conference on Urban Climate, Rotterdam, The Netherlands, 7–11 Jul 2025, ICUC12-955, https://doi.org/10.5194/icuc12-955, 2025.

11:15–11:30
|
ICUC12-372
|
Onsite presentation
Adi Elmaliah and Or Aleksandrowicz

Tree planting is often regarded as the main urban strategy that can provide extensive distribution of outdoor shade. However, the physical constraints that limit the provision of adequate underground soil volume alongside the slow development of shade-providing tree crowns sometimes make artificial shading elements the only viable option for effective shading. Despite their importance for outdoor climatic design, few studies have assessed the magnitude and quality of heat stress relief provided by common artificial shading systems compared to tree shade, and a widely accepted methodology for evaluating the efficacy of different types of artificial shading systems is still missing. 

In this study, we attempted to develop a systematic analytical method for artificial shading performance based on the geometry and material properties of the elements and the resulting solar transmittance, heat emittance, and overall heat comfort provision in the shade they produce. For this purpose, we monitored the performance of common artificial shading systems under summer, clear-sky conditions in Tel Aviv-Yafo. Monitoring was done using an on-site compact weather station and Chaosense units measuring Mean Radiant Temperature, which enabled us to calculate the degree of thermal stress mitigation using the PET and UTCI indices. The data was collected under a wide variety of artificial shading elements simultaneously with monitoring the conditions at adjacent non-shaded, tree-shaded, and building-shaded locations. 

The monitoring results showed that the performance of non-uniform opaque shading surfaces, such as louvred structures, depended on their geometry and orientation, with optimal performance occurring when the openings in the shading surface are minimal. With uniform shading surfaces, primarily textile-based, we found a large variance in cooling efficacy that mainly resulted from the degree of direct solar transmittance through the shading surface. However, even the least effective uniform artificial elements still demonstrated a considerable reduction in heat stress compared to non-shaded locations.

How to cite: Elmaliah, A. and Aleksandrowicz, O.: Performance-based evaluation of artificial shading systems for heat-stress relief in outdoor environments, 12th International Conference on Urban Climate, Rotterdam, The Netherlands, 7–11 Jul 2025, ICUC12-372, https://doi.org/10.5194/icuc12-372, 2025.

11:30–11:45
|
ICUC12-145
|
Onsite presentation
Tzu-Ping Lin and Yi-Chen Wu

Assessing shading benefits in urban environments has often been a complex task. This study proposes a simplified method for evaluating outdoor thermal comfort using the RayMan regression model to calculate Physiologically Equivalent Temperature (PET) and Mean Radiant Temperature (Tmrt).

By comparing Solar Radiation Transmissivity (SRT) with the Leaf Area Index (LAI) of common tree species in Taiwan, the study identifies an average SRT value of 0.3 (range: 0.2–0.5). This value is incorporated into ArcGIS solar radiation simulations to adjust sub-canopy radiation, enabling the construction of urban shading maps and PET-based thermal comfort maps for sidewalks. Additionally, the study analyzes PET along selected pedestrian pathways to assess heat stress conditions.

The results reveal a strong correlation between PET values derived from the simplified model and those obtained using the RayMan model. Radiation, wind speed, and air temperature are identified as the primary climatic factors influencing thermal comfort in Taiwan. Furthermore, the strong relationship between SRT and LAI significantly enhances the accuracy of thermal comfort mapping.

This GIS-integrated approach effectively identifies shading deficiencies, evaluates shading benefits, and recommends comfortable walking routes. The findings demonstrate that strategic shading can lower PET by 1–2°C in urban outdoor spaces, highlighting the crucial role of shading in enhancing outdoor thermal comfort.

How to cite: Lin, T.-P. and Wu, Y.-C.: Simplified Outdoor Thermal Comfort Assessment Using Urban Shade Maps, 12th International Conference on Urban Climate, Rotterdam, The Netherlands, 7–11 Jul 2025, ICUC12-145, https://doi.org/10.5194/icuc12-145, 2025.

11:45–12:00
|
ICUC12-654
|
Onsite presentation
Agnese Salvati, Nicola Colaninno, Judit Lopez-Besora, and Michele Morganti

Shade provision by buildings and trees is very beneficial in reducing pedestrian heat stress in hot climate regions, such as the Mediterranean. However, shade is not constant in time and space, which makes difficult to understand its actual potential to reduce pedestrian heat stress depending on the geometry and orientation of each urban space and the time of the day.

In this work we present a framework to generate district-scale heat stress frequency maps based on the spatiotemporal variability of mean radiant temperature at the street level. This allows understanding the beneficial effect of a district urban geometry and vegetation on the thermal conditions of its urban spaces, as well as to identify where and when more shade is needed to reduce pedestrian heat stress.

The approach is applied to the Gràcia district of Barcelona. First, we carried out high-resolution simulations of the radiation fluxes across the urban area using the SOLWEIG model. Then we correlated the Mean Radiant Temperature (Tmrt) to the PET values in the same points, to identify threshold values corresponding to different heat stress levels. Finally, we cross compared the spatial (maps) and frequency (histogram) distribution of Tmrt values across the whole district over different times of the day.

The results indicate that shade provision by urban geometry reduces pedestrian heat stress from extreme to moderate levels in the morning (until 12:00 local time) and afternoon (starting from 16:00). In the time window from 13:00 to 15:00, urban geometry has negligible impact due to high solar elevations, while trees shades significantly reduce heat stress from beyond extreme to moderate levels.

Based on the results, we generated a cumulative heat stress frequency map that can be used as a practical tool to plan district-scale shading interventions enabling acceptable thermal conditions across the whole urban area.

How to cite: Salvati, A., Colaninno, N., Lopez-Besora, J., and Morganti, M.: How much shade do we need to reduce pedestrian heat stress? Understanding the spatiotemporal variation of the urban thermal environment at the district-scale, 12th International Conference on Urban Climate, Rotterdam, The Netherlands, 7–11 Jul 2025, ICUC12-654, https://doi.org/10.5194/icuc12-654, 2025.

12:00–12:15
|
ICUC12-345
|
Onsite presentation
|
Jessica Monahan, Victoria Tsalapati, Haohua Gan, Yan Gao, Citra Andinasari, Hugo Ledoux, and Lukas Beuster

By providing shade for residents in urban areas, cool spaces have been shown to be essential for mitigating the effects of heat stress. In response, the Municipality of Amsterdam developed a map showing walking distances to these spaces. However, the map lacks key information on capacity, accessibility, and precise distance measurements. This project addresses these gaps by identifying quality indicators for cool places and mapping their locations and quality scores across Amsterdam. Additionally, it establishes methods for computing the shortest and shadiest pedestrian routes to these spaces, enabling efficient routing to and from any given location.

To address the research questions, the following procedures were conducted. First, shade maps of Amsterdam were created for each warm month using the Daily Shadow Pattern tool of the Urban Multi-scale Environmental Predictor (UMEP). Second, cool spaces were identified and evaluated based on accessibility, shading, usability, capacity, heat risk, and Physiological Equivalent Temperature (PET) indicators. Lastly, after obtaining and processing the pedestrian network from the Open Street Map database, shade weight was calculated for each street segment, and cool spaces were incorporated into the network, allowing users to generate datasets of the shortest and shadiest distances to cool spaces, and an algorithm that performs four different routing options: the shortest, the shadiest, and two combinations of the shortest and shadiest paths with different weighting ratios either between two locations or from a starting point to its nearest cool space.

The project produced several datasets (8.3GB in total; they are openly available: <https://doi.org/10.4121/8b65d25b-c68f-4e88-b239-27ea90eaf149.v1>) which provide insights into Amsterdam's cool spaces, their quality, and the shadiest and shortest routes to these locations. Additionally, the code to create these datasets is open-source: <https://github.com/jsscmnhn/shady_amsterdam>.

How to cite: Monahan, J., Tsalapati, V., Gan, H., Gao, Y., Andinasari, C., Ledoux, H., and Beuster, L.: Shady Amsterdam: Identifying the shady places and routes of Amsterdam, 12th International Conference on Urban Climate, Rotterdam, The Netherlands, 7–11 Jul 2025, ICUC12-345, https://doi.org/10.5194/icuc12-345, 2025.

12:15–12:30
|
ICUC12-793
|
Onsite presentation
Lukas Beuster, Titus Venverloo, Clara García-Sánchez, Fábio Duarte, and Hugo Ledoux

Urban environments are increasingly shaped by the need to mitigate heat stress, yet the role of shade in this context remains understudied. While it is well understood that shade can significantly reduce thermal exposure, cities lack standardized methods to assess how shade is distributed and whether it aligns with public need. This study investigates the extent to which Amsterdam provides meaningful shade in areas of high social and functional importance, combining geospatial analysis with socio-demographic and network-based approaches.

Recognizing that people engage with urban spaces in different ways, we distinguish between shade for movers (pedestrians, cyclists, commuters) and dwellers (those using public seating, plazas, and gathering spaces), as each requires different forms of shade provision. We analyze shade availability across various public spaces, distinguishing between green (tree) and grey (building) shade, and examine how access varies based on socio-economic and demographic factors. Using a graph network model, we identify key pedestrian routes and public areas where shade provision is most critical.

By integrating spatial, environmental, and social data, this research advances methodologies for evaluating shade distribution and its role in urban climate adaptation. The findings will inform strategic municipal planning, supporting targeted interventions to enhance shade equity and ensure urban infrastructure prioritizes thermal comfort for all residents in Amsterdam and beyond.

How to cite: Beuster, L., Venverloo, T., García-Sánchez, C., Duarte, F., and Ledoux, H.: Shady Politics: Mapping Inequalities in Urban Shade Distribution, 12th International Conference on Urban Climate, Rotterdam, The Netherlands, 7–11 Jul 2025, ICUC12-793, https://doi.org/10.5194/icuc12-793, 2025.

12:30–12:45
|
ICUC12-213
|
Onsite presentation
Huihui Zhao, Genyu Xu, Yan Xu, Lihua Zhao, and Qinglin Meng

Urban shade is critical for mitigating pedestrian heat stress and improving thermal comfort, particularly in hot urban environments with intense solar radiation during summer. Traditional urban design practices often focus on overall shadow coverage ratios, which evaluate shading at the site scale rather than along specific pedestrian pathways. However, these approaches fail to adequately address the dynamic shading needs of pedestrians, whose thermal comfort is influenced by exposure patterns along their whole-trip. Based on the thermal comfort requirements of pedestrians during their trips, this study introduces two shade design control metrics: Pathway Shading Ratio and Maximum Allowable Continuous Sunlit Distance. Pathway Shading Ratio quantifies the proportion of shaded segments along a specified walking path, providing a baseline for the minimum shading quantity required across the entire route. Maximum Allowable Continuous Sunlit Distance defines an upper limit for the uninterrupted distance pedestrians can be exposed to direct sunlight, reflecting the temporal and spatial thresholds necessary to maintain acceptable thermal comfort during walking trips. By integrating field-based thermal comfort experiments with simulation analyses, this study systematically derives and quantifies these metrics. The findings establish a framework for targeted shading interventions, bridging the gap between urban shading design and pedestrian thermal comfort needs. This research refines urban shade evaluation systems, enhancing pedestrian thermal environments and providing actionable guidance for urban planners and policymakers to create thermally comfortable and walkable cities.

How to cite: Zhao, H., Xu, G., Xu, Y., Zhao, L., and Meng, Q.: Path-based Urban Shade Metrics: Integrating Pedestrian Thermal Comfort into Urban Design Guidelines, 12th International Conference on Urban Climate, Rotterdam, The Netherlands, 7–11 Jul 2025, ICUC12-213, https://doi.org/10.5194/icuc12-213, 2025.

12:45–13:00
|
ICUC12-122
|
Onsite presentation
|
Or Aleksandrowicz, Naama Shapira, Michelle C. Levenson, Shachar Zur, and David Pearlmutter

Shade as an urban asset depends entirely on planning and design decisions. To optimise the allocation of shading resources and achieve effective shading, such decisions must follow quantitative methods, which currently hardly exist, for assessing shade quality according to a uniform normative scale. The Shade Availability Index, which quantifies shading conditions on sidewalks and walking paths, was developed with this goal in mind.

The Shade Availability Index is calculated by shading conditions at ten hourly intervals between 08:00 and 17:00 on a typical Northern Hemisphere summer day in early August, which is also indicative of spring shading conditions. At each hour, a walking strip is considered sufficiently shaded if shade covers more than half of its area. This allows for an index that considers time as the main normative criterion for quantifying shade: when the sidewalk is sufficiently shaded for at least 50% of the reference time, we describe the shading level as acceptable; 70% or above of the time means that shading is very good; and 90% and above indicates excellent shading. The Shade Availability Index does not assign different weights to shading at different times since, under hot sunny conditions, the need for shading is continuous throughout the daytime hours.

The applicability of the normative scale of the Shade Availability Index was examined through comprehensive parametric modelling of thousands of design scenarios to assess the difficulty of achieving any of the three shading thresholds. This examination revealed that it is possible to reach the index’s upper threshold in almost any reasonable planning scenario of urban streets. However, to achieve this, it would be necessary to plant shade trees along the walking strips. This is true regardless of a street's orientation, although, in certain directions, the upper shading threshold can be met through clever building massing.

How to cite: Aleksandrowicz, O., Shapira, N., Levenson, M. C., Zur, S., and Pearlmutter, D.: The Shade Availability Index: a new quantitative scale to support the design of shaded sidewalks and walking paths, 12th International Conference on Urban Climate, Rotterdam, The Netherlands, 7–11 Jul 2025, ICUC12-122, https://doi.org/10.5194/icuc12-122, 2025.

Posters: Thu, 10 Jul, 18:00–19:00 | Exchange Hall

Display time: Thu, 10 Jul, 13:30–Fri, 11 Jul, 16:00
Chairpersons: Or Aleksandrowicz, David Pearlmutter
E53
|
ICUC12-462
Julian Raffetseder, Or Aleksandrowicz, and Sascha Roesler

Climate change has made urban heat a source of concern in temperate-climate cities that, until recently, have not viewed heat stress as a major urban challenge. While heat mitigation policies put an emphasis on outdoor shade during summer, its provision can sometimes be in conflict with established regulations on winter solar access indoors and outdoors. Such conflicts are now addressed, if at all, mostly through an ad-hoc intuitive assessment of designers and not by following a clear methodology for resolving contradicting urban climatic goals.

The study addresses this inherent conundrum of solar access by building a framework of distributive justice that differentiates spatial entities for their perceived need for solar governance. We argue that measurable climatic metrics alone cannot resolve this conundrum since an optimal year-long “average” of negative and positive solar exposure would normally produce non-optimal conditions during winter and summer alike. Consequently, the governance of solar access in cities has to rely also on context specific societal interests, considering the subjective preferences of a variety of stakeholders, including city planners and residents. For example, a city may decide that winter solar access is far more important than solar protection in playgrounds and, at the same time, highly prioritise sidewalk summer shade over indoor winter illumination.

Taking Vienna as a case study, we set out to identify the spatial entities that local stakeholders consider to be a relevant reference framework to solar access claims. Using the analysis of official regulatory documents, expert interviews, and open citizen discussions, we were able to identify a set of spatial units that were considered as requiring solar governance, such as residential apartments, key-way connections, transport stops, playgrounds, and public squares. The resulting spatial solar access claims were modelled on a typical site as a negotiation platform for resolving the solar conflicts.

How to cite: Raffetseder, J., Aleksandrowicz, O., and Roesler, S.: The challenges of solar governance in temperate-climate cities: the case of Vienna, 12th International Conference on Urban Climate, Rotterdam, The Netherlands, 7–11 Jul 2025, ICUC12-462, https://doi.org/10.5194/icuc12-462, 2025.

E54
|
ICUC12-797
Dila Ozberkman, Michiel van Selm, Titus Venverloo, and Lukas Beuster

Despite its critical role in urban thermal comfort, shade remains underexplored in large-scale urban studies due to the absence of standardized tools for its integration. Existing urban analysis frameworks often overlook shade coverage when evaluating outdoor thermal conditions, limiting our understanding of its influence. This study addresses this gap by enhancing an existing shade quantification method to process any geolocated dataset with timestamps, generating enriched outputs that incorporate shade data. By leveraging high-resolution spatial data and computational simulations, this open-source tool expands the capabilities of current methodologies for assessing urban shade coverage.

We apply this tool to climate data collected using the Climate Bike in Amsterdam, which records six-directional longwave and shortwave radiation alongside other environmental parameters. By integrating shade metrics, we calculate thermal comfort indices at a city-wide scale and analyze the correlation between building and tree shade and urban thermal comfort, with a focus on mean radiant temperature (MRT). This large-scale study provides new insights into how shade influences outdoor thermal conditions in real-world urban settings.

Our findings provide the following contributions:

  • A flexible and scalable tool for integrating shade data into diverse climate studies.
  • A city-wide quantification of thermal comfort informed by shade.
  • An accessible workflow that enables cities to conduct their own shade-inclusive climate studies.

By bridging the gap between urban studies and climate science, this work establishes a methodological foundation for climate adaptation strategies.

How to cite: Ozberkman, D., van Selm, M., Venverloo, T., and Beuster, L.: Sun Blocked: Integrating Shade into Urban Climate Assessments, 12th International Conference on Urban Climate, Rotterdam, The Netherlands, 7–11 Jul 2025, ICUC12-797, https://doi.org/10.5194/icuc12-797, 2025.

Supporters & sponsors