Residual-chlorine concentration impacts the ecology of biofilms in drinking water pipes and their water quality response

Drinking water distribution systems (DWDS) are an engineered system designed to protect water quality during delivery from treatment works to consumers’ taps. Biofilms form on the vast internal surfaces of DWDS, impacting water quality by their activity and/or mobilisation into the bulk-water. Disinfection-residuals are often maintained in drinking water to mitigate planktonic microbial contamination (and associated water quality/health risks). However, the impact of residual-disinfection upon biofilms, and the subsequent unintended risk they may present to water quality, is unclear.

To address this, an internationally-unique, temperature-controlled, full-scale DWDS test facility, fed with water from the local DWDS, was used to grow biofilms (for 28 days). The facility enables three simultaneous conditions to be run in replicate pipe loops (each ~200m long, 79mm internal diameter, PE100 pipe). Conditions studied were Low-, Medium- and High-chlorine regimes. Various water quality parameters were monitored throughout, biofilms were sampled every two weeks (n=5). Physical, chemical and molecular analyses were applied to characterise the matrix (structure and composition) and microbial communities (via analysis of bacterial 16S rRNA and fungal ITS genes) of biofilms developed under the different chlorine regimes. After growth, a “mobilisation” test was conducted simulating hydraulic changes that occur in DWDS. Biofilms from each chlorine regime were exposed to increasing shear stresses to determine any water quality degradation as a consequence of biofilm mobilisation.

High-chlorine residual concentration during development reduced biofilm bacterial concentrations but increased inorganics and selected for unique bacterial and fungal communities. Ultimately the biofilms developed under a High-chlorine residual resulted in the greatest decrease in water quality, in response to mobilisation, and the Low-chlorine regime resulted in biofilms which had the lowest impact on water quality. These unanticipated findings suggest chlorine-boosting should be considered carefully and may actually exacerbate water quality issues. The derived understanding could impact the long-term management of DWDS water quality and biofilm, whilst challenging the current mind-set of continuous residual-disinfection control strategies.