Soil organic matter dynamics in changing forests: linking ecosystem manipulation experiments with soil inventories across Switzerland

Forest soils are storing large quantities of carbon, but their quantitative role in sequestering C is less certain. In principal, soils developed over millennia are assumed to be ‘in equilibrium’ with minimal C stock changes. This concept is challenged by forest soil inventories (in Germany and France) indicate a substantial increase in soil C storage. However, soil organic matter (SOM) storage is susceptible to recent changes in forests - climate warming and droughts, increasing forest disturbances, and a more intensive forest management are all potentially increasing SOM turnover which may turn forest soils into C sources. Here, I will critically discuss the role in Swiss forest soils as C sinks by presenting data from 1000 soil profiles across environmental gradients and from flux measurements in large scale ecosystem manipulation experiments.

Swiss forests soils are among the C-richest soils in Europe storing on average 140 t C/ha. Analysis of 1000 forest soils show that these SOM stocks are caused by their high contents in potential SOM sorbents (pH, Al+Fe-oxides, Ca, clay), but also by the cool temperatures and high amounts of precipitation. Climate manipulation experiments suggest Swiss forest soils are vulnerable to loose C with expected climatic changes. A six year long soil warming experiment at treeline revealed soil C losses, while a 15 year long irrigation experiment in a dry forest induced C gains in the mineral soil, implying that a warmer and more frequent droughts will lead to C losses.

Switzerland - as other European mountainous areas – is currently experiencing a major change in land-use due to land abandonment, with the forests expanding by 3 to 4% per decade. Forest expansion affects a multitude of factors driving SOM cycling and storage, including the quantity and quality of organic matter inputs above and below the ground, a cooler and drier microclimate, and change in microbial diversity and activity. In contrast to the intuitive assumption that forests expansion leads to C gains in soils, measurements along an afforestation chronosequence of alpine grassland show that forest expansion leads to minimal changes in SOM stocks but a strong change in SOM quality. Soils gains in particulate organic matter with increasing forest age but lose C in mineral-associated organic matter. In support, reconstructing forest cover ages of 850 soil profiles showed that forest age and hence time since conversion into forest (predominantly from grasslands) did not significantly affect total SOM stocks, while other factors, especially physico-chemical soil characteristics and climate were more important. Overall, these results show that the inherently C rich forest soils in Switzerland are unlikely to gain additional C but rather loose it in response to the ongoing changes in climate and land-use.