Is silicon a double-edged sword against insect herbivores?

In recent years, silicon (Si) has been increasingly linked to biotic stress management in plants including insect herbivory. The effectiveness of Si against chewing insects is now well recognized. Silicification of plant tissues makes them abrasive and tougher, reducing their masticability and digestibility to insect herbivores. This can cause mandibular wearing of chewers and affect their growth and feeding. Although there has been extensive research on the effects of Si on plant defences (i.e. antixenosis and antibiosis), it remains unclear how feeding on silicified plants affects insect defences to their natural enemies. Insect herbivores show morphological and behavioural defences when encountering predators and parasitoids. For example, lepidopteran larvae can regurgitate, twist the body, or even drop off the plants when attacked by natural enemies. Moreover, insects possess innate immunity (physiological defence) against the attackers, demonstrating cellular and humoral responses upon attack. Notably, there could be potential trade-offs between different defence and immunity traits. Given that feeding on Si-rich plants affects insect growth rates, this could impact their relative investment in different defences, thereby making insects more susceptible to their enemies. We are investigating the effects of Si on plant resistance and tolerance to herbivory and its cascading effects on insect defences to their enemies. We have been growing the model grass, Brachypodium distachyon, a high Si-accumulator, hydroponically with or without Si and examining the effects of Si against the global insect herbivore, Helicoverpa armigera. Our preliminary results suggest that Si supplementation enhances plant antixenotic and antibiotic traits and increases plant tolerance to herbivory. We are currently exploring insect defence and immunity traits when fed on silicified versus non-silicified plants. Our study would shed light on the impacts of Si on insects’ susceptibility to biocontrol agents and provide a better understanding of the effects of Si on insect-plant-natural enemy interactions.