Model evaluation of compound precipitation and wind extremes over Europe

Extreme precipitation and winds can have a severe impact on society, particularly when they occur at the same place and time. Studies have investigated the frequency of co-occurring extreme precipitation and wind using observational data. However, due to the rarity of very extreme events, these results are limited, since a large number of samples is needed to get robust estimates. Additionally, it is very difficult for estimates based on observations alone to help us understand the risk of future unprecedented events. Using the UNSEEN method (UNprecedented Simulated Extremes using ENsembles) this risk can be estimated from large ensembles of climate simulations. The Met Office's Global Seasonal forecast system version 5 (GloSea5) model ensembles are evaluated against ERA5 reanalysis data to find out how well they represent extreme precipitation, extreme wind and extreme co-occurring events over Europe. This model has not been evaluated in such a way before and this is needed before the model can be used to estimate the likelihood of unprecedented events using the UNSEEN method. We find that although the intensity of precipitation and wind extremes differ between the model and observations (by up to 12 mm and 9 m/s), the frequency of co-occurring events is well represented. The extremal dependency measure, χ, which measures co-occurrence, compares well spatially over Europe between GloSea5 and ERA5. However, significant differences in χ are found over areas of high topography, over the North Atlantic, Western Europe and the Norwegian Sea. Generally, GloSea5 underestimates χ over the ocean, and performs better over land. Mean sea level pressure anomaly composites for co-occurring extreme events show that at a number of selected locations, the co-occurring extremes are produced by very similar synoptic situations in the model and reanalysis. This gives increased confidence in the model. The model ensembles can then be used to assess the present day likelihood of unprecedented 3 hourly compound precipitation and wind extremes for winter over Europe, and to find out how the NAO index influences the frequency of co-occurring events over Europe.