Initial aggregate formation: Disentangling the effects of soil texture, OM properties and microbial community using artificial model soils

The interaction between mineral particles and organic matter (OM) is an important and complex process in the course of soil structure formation. For a better understanding it is necessary to disentangle the texture-dependent interplay of individual OM types and mineral particles. We developed an experimental set-up to study early aggregate formation within a controlled lab environment. Artificial soil microcosms with a mineral mixture resembling arable soils of three different textures (clay loam, loam and sandy loam) were used in a short-term, 30-day incubation experiment under constant water-tension. OM was added individually either as plant litter (POM) of two different sizes (0.63-2 mm and < 63 µm, respectively) or bacterial necromass (Bacillus subtilis). The mechanisms of soil structure formation were investigated by isolating water-stable aggregates after the incubation, analyzing their mechanical stability and organic carbon allocation, and measuring the specific surface area and OM covers of the mineral surface, microbial activity, and community structure.

The dry mixing process and incubation of the mineral mixtures led to particle-particle interactions and fine particle coatings of the sand grains as shown by a reduction of the specific surface area. The OM input of all types caused between 3 to 17% of the mineral surfaces to be covered by OM, with larger covered areas in the clay-rich mixtures. The added OM was quickly accessed and degraded by microbes, as shown by the peak in CO₂-release within the first 10 days of the incubation. The POM of both sizes induced the predominant formation of water-stable macroaggregates (0.63-30 mm) with a mass contribution of 72 to 91% (irrespective of texture) and fostered the development of a microbial community with a high relative abundance of fungi. The bacterial necromass induced the formation of macroaggregates, but also microaggregates (63-200 µm), while the microbial community was dominated by bacteria. The mechanical stability analysis showed that very small forces < 4 N were sufficient for aggregate failure and breakdown to 80% of the original aggregate size.

We propose that the microbial degradation of all OM types leads to small, distinct OM clusters consisting of OM substrate, microbes, and extracellular polymeric substances. These interact with mineral particles, resulting in the cross-linking of particles and formation of water-stable aggregates in all textures. The OM can thereby act both as microbial substrate and as structural building block. The initially formed aggregates are a loosely connected scaffold with a very low mechanical stability. Differences in the developed microbial community may lead to additional stabilization mechanisms, like fungal hyphae enmeshing and stabilizing larger aggregates also in sandy texture.