EGU21-4152, updated on 04 Mar 2021
EGU General Assembly 2021
© Author(s) 2021. This work is distributed under
the Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 License.

The impact of the vertical discretization scheme on the accuracy of a model of the European north-west shelf

Diego Bruciaferri1, James Harle2, Anthony Wise2, Enda O'Dea1, and Jeff Polton2
Diego Bruciaferri et al.
  • 1Met Office, Exeter, EX1 3PB, United Kingdom of Great Britain – England, Scotland, Wales (
  • 2National Oceanography Centre, Liverpool, L3 5DA, United Kingdom of Great Britain – England, Scotland, Wales

The choice of the vertical coordinate system is the single most important factor affecting the quality of ocean model simulations (e.g. Griffies et al. 2000). This is especially true in regions such as the European North-West Shelf (NWS), where complex ocean dynamics result from the combination of a variety of multi-scale physical processes.

As part of the Copernicus Marine Environment Monitoring Service, the Met Office runs an operational coupled ocean-wave forecasting system of the NWS. The ocean model employed is a regional implementation of NEMO hydrodynamic code (Madec 2017), further developed by both the Met Office and the National Oceanography Centre under the umbrella of the Joint Marine Modelling Programme (JMMP). Here we describe the work of the JMMP group in assessing the impact of different vertical coordinate systems on the accuracy of the solution of the free-running NWS ocean model. 

Five different vertical discretization schemes are compared: i) geopotential z-levels with partial steps, ii) s-levels following a smooth version of the bottom topography using either the Song & Haidvogel (1994) or iii) the Siddorn & Furner (2013) stretching functions, iv) the hybrid Harle et al. (2013) s-z with partial step scheme, and v) the multi-envelope s-coordinate system of Bruciaferri et al. (2018). Three different type of numerical experiments with increasing level of complexity are conducted: i) an idealised test for horizontal pressure gradient errors (HPGE), ii) a barotropic simulation forced only by the astronomical tides (TIDE) and iii) a fully baroclinic simulation using realistic initial condition and external forcing (REAL).      

Numerical results of the HPGE test show that s-levels models develop the highest spurious currents (order of cm/s),  the multi-enveloping method allows relatively reduction of the error of pure s-levels grids while z-levels with partial steps or the hybrid s-z scheme are affected by the smallest error (order of mm/s).  The TIDE experiment reveals some differences between the models for amplitude and phase of the major tidal components. Preliminary results of the REAL experiment show that models differing only in the vertical discretization schemes broadly represent the same general ocean dynamics, although presenting non-trivial differences in the active tracers and flow fields especially in the proximity of the shelf-break.        

Song, Y. & Haidvogel, D.B., 1994. A semi-implicit ocean circulation model using a generalized topography-following coordinate system. Journal of Computational Physics 115, 228–244

Griffies, S.M. et al. 2000. Developments in ocean climate modelling. Ocean Modelling 2, 123–192, 10.1016/S1463-5003(00)00014-7

Siddorn, J.R. & Furner, R., 2013. An analytical stretching function that combines the best attributes of geopotential and terrain-following vertical coordinates. Ocean Modelling 66, 1–13, 10.1016/j.ocemod.2013.02.001

Harle, J.D. et al. 2013. Report on role of biophysical interactions on basin-scale C and N budgets. Deliverable 6.5, European Basin-scale Analysis, Synthesis and Integration (EURO-BASIN) Project,

Madec G. et al. (2017). NEMO ocean engine. Notes Du Pôle De Modélisation De L'institut Pierre-simon Laplace (IPSL).

Bruciaferri, D. et al. 2018. A multi-envelope vertical coordinate system for numerical ocean modelling. Ocean Dynamics, 68 (10), 1239-1258, 10.1007/s10236-018-1189-x

How to cite: Bruciaferri, D., Harle, J., Wise, A., O'Dea, E., and Polton, J.: The impact of the vertical discretization scheme on the accuracy of a model of the European north-west shelf, EGU General Assembly 2021, online, 19–30 Apr 2021, EGU21-4152,, 2021.

Display materials

Display file

Comments on the display material

to access the discussion