Autogenic progradation of Bayhead deltas during sea-level rise wIthin incised valleys : theory, experiment and field examples

The evolution of sedimentary landscapes is primary driven by the interplay between the rate of accommodation creation A, controlled by sea-level and subsidence, and the rate of sediment supply S, controlled by erosion and sediment transport. In simple terms, the balance between A and S can be used to predict periods of progradation (when sediment supply exceeds accommodation) and periods of retrogradation (when accommodation exceeds sediment supply). However, a growing list of observations show that internal feedbacks within the sediment transport system can generate large-scale, autogenic stratigraphic patterns that are not anticipated by the A/S theory. These observations call for a reanalysis of several sequence stratigraphic precepts that assume a deterministic relationship between external forcings and stratigraphic products. Here, we focus on the filling of incised valleys during constant sea-level rise, and by a constant sediment flux. We develop a simple conceptual model of valley filling and we show that the classic sequence stratigraphic phenomenon of bayhead deltaic systems can be generated by purely autogenic progradation during the late stage of valley flooding. This transient “auto-advance” event results from a strong decrease of in-valley accommodation as base-level rises towards the valley apex. To test this model, we build a laboratory experiment that successfully reproduces the dynamics predicted by the model. Finally, we apply our model to two similar field examples, the Trinity and Brazos rivers incised valleys (Texas, USA). There systems are broadly similar in dimension and sea-level history but were filled at different sediment rates. We propose that this led to auto-advance event in the Trinity River valley while no advance is observed in the Brazos system. We thus show by conceptual, experimental and natural examples that auto-advance can produce out-of-sequence regressive bayhead diastems during highstands similar to a transient change in allogenic forcing. Combined with other recent studies, our findings support the idea that meso-scale autogenic patterns are ubiquitous in the fluvio-deltaic record, and need to be more extensively incorporated into reconstructions of Earth surface evolution and reservoir models.