Not every large glacial episode lowers valley bottoms: inisghts from the cave systems of the Tatra Mts (the Western Carpathians)

The Tatra mountains, the northernmost portion of the Central Western Carpathians, host a stunning alpine landscape despite an average elevation that rises 1.4 km above the surrounding lowlands. Regional geomorphology studies on both sides of the range correlate various landforms interpreted to be glacial in origin with all each of the eight major Alpine glacial  events based largely landscape position, and in some cases geochronologic constraints. This regional relative chronology assumes that wet-based mountain glaciers are efficient agents of erosion and each successive glaciation lowered the valleys within the Tatra. While the tendency of subsequent glaciations to obscure evidence of previous events makes it difficult to study the work done by past glacial episodes, the cave networks on the northern side of the Tatra offer a way to evaluate the amount and timing of valley lowering with U-series dating of speleothems. Epiphreatic and paleophreatic caves that developed near the water table and dried out as valley deepening occurred can serve as excellent recorders of the valley incision history.

Speleothems were collected from a number of cave levels present throughout the northern Tatra, of which only a subset were suitable for U-series geochronology. The oldest speleothems collected in active epiphreatic passages on the valley bottom level from each valley are consistently between 284-325 ka (MIS 8-9). This shows that the modern karst drainage system of the Tatra was established prior to the late Middle Pleistocene, and the cave conduits changed to epiphreatic or vadose conditions between 280 and 330 ka. Since the lowest cave level is at or below the modern valley floor, we can conclude that no valley incision occurred after ~330 ka, which includes both the penultimate and last glaciations periods. Clearly, the regional glacial chronologies in the Tatra must be reassessed. The implications of our findings demonstrate that the assumption of successive valley lowering should not be assumed and that even the extensive MIS2 glaciation did not result in valley lowering despite its size.