Erosion and Weathering of the Himalaya and Tibetan Plateau is not the Cause of Neogene Global Cooling

Does uplift and erosion of the Himalaya-Tibetan Plateau drive Cenozoic global cooling? We tested this classic hypothesis put forward by Raymo and Ruddiman (1992) that suggests enhanced erosion in the Himalaya-Tibetan Plateau drove long-term Cenozoic global cooling through the chemical weathering of siliciclastic sediment. Here we examine three Asian marginal drainage systems (the Indus, Mekong and Pearl) where marine scientific drilling has yielded detailed seismic surveys and geochemical datasets that critically permit sediment mass flux and therefore chemical weathering flux budgets to be made. By compiling suitable bedrock endmember compositions for the fresh bedrock sources and proximal modern river sediments, it is possible to calculate the chemical weathering flux and relative CO₂ consumption rates for each drainage system into the early Miocene. We correct for evolving provenance of sediment delivered to the offshore and test the sensitivity of our calculations to selected bedrock endmembers, in light of the abundant mafic bedrock exposed Indus and Mekong systems. The Indus shows a progressive shift away from erosion of the Karakoram to the Himalaya. Appropriate Upper Continental Crust endmembers were further validated using data compiled from the GEOROC database. Regardless of which endmembers were used, calculations demonstrate that the total rate of CO₂consumption decreased by 50% between ~16 and 5.3 Ma, especially within the NW Himalaya as erosion slowed and provenance shifted away from mafic arc units in the suture zone. This direct test of the uplift-erosion-weathering hypothesis establishes that chemical weathering fluxes in this region did not increase during the Neogene and cannot be responsible for the drawdown of atmospheric CO₂ during that time period. Either additional mechanisms have been driving global cooling since 16 Ma or CO₂ consumption via chemical weathering is taking place in other areas outside the Himalaya-Tibetan Plateau.