Experimental constraints on the controlling mechanisms of tectonic tremors

Tectonic (or non-volcanic) tremors have been extensively documented at subduction zones and are considered as the signature of transport processes of dehydration-related fluids in subduction zones, often recorded in close association with geodetically observed shear induced slow-slip events. However, to the best of our knowledge, they have not yet been reproduced in the laboratory at subduction zones P–T conditions in such way that their first-order controlling mechanisms remain enigmatic.  

This work investigates the mechanism of these seismic events by performing dehydration-deformation experiments combined with detailed investigations of mineral reactions and acoustic emissions. Experiments were carried out on chlorite-peridotite powders (Balmuccia peridotite with synthetically added chlorite, a mineral that is typically found in subduction zone lithologies), following a subduction zone geothermal gradient using a high-pressure apparatus (Griggs-type). The experiments were conducted from ambient conditions to maximum pressures of 1.5-3.0 GPa and temperatures of 750-800 °C. Experiments were executed under hydrostatic conditions and an additional one with deformation. An ultrasonic transducer (0.5-10MHz dynamic range) was employed to monitor and detect the micro-seismic events. High-resolution electron beam techniques (EMPA, SEM and TEM) have been applied for analyzing the sample material.

Dehydration of ~15 vol.% of the initial chlorite suffices to trigger acoustic emissions, which display waveforms reminiscent of those of tectonic tremors. The moment distribution statistics of these laboratory tremor-like signals follows the Gutenberg-Richter relationship and a scaling between moment vs. event duration. Finally, we observe a match between the ratios of size and typical frequency of natural over laboratory tremors. Microstructural observations document metamorphic olivine and pyroxene growth in the decomposing chlorite and demonstrate that an almost isochemical dehydration of the chlorite took place. Accordingly, the appearance of the tremor-like acoustic emissions after crossing a temperature of 600 °C can be linked to a dehydration process related to the chlorite breakdown in the sample. Thermodynamic calculations show that a small amount of released fluids (breakdown of ~1.5 vol.% of a hydrous phase) is enough to trigger seismic signals analogues to tremors. The experiment with additional deformation produced no tremor-like acoustic emission suggesting that the large macroscopic shear stress suppressed the development of the processes that lead to acoustic emissions. We conclude that fluid release during dehydration is the cause of tectonic tremors, whereas shear-stress seems to counteract their development with no occurrence of tremors at high rates of deformation. According to the results from this study, the triggering mechanism can be tentatively interpreted as a fluid propagation front resulting in the vibration of grain boundaries.