Paleoelevation Reconstruction of Subduction Zones in Eastern Pacific Continental Margins Quantitatively with Igneous Geochemistry

Reconstructing past episodes of mountain building from the geological rock record is one of the main challenges for unravelling the ancient physical geography of Earth’s surface. Mountains and mountain ranges, often situated at convergent plate margins, play a pivotal role in many fields of the Earth, climate, and biological sciences. Established methods for quantifying past elevations traditionally relied on sedimentary rocks, but in recent years, alternative approaches have emerged on the basis that geochemical signatures of magmatic rocks formed in convergent settings correlate with crustal thickness or elevation. These correlations allow for empirical relations of igneous whole-rock ratios such as La/Yb and Sr/Y with Moho depth for modern convergent settings, which can then be used to estimate ancient crustal thickness or paleoelevation. Since a relatively large number of igneous samples are available for pre-Cenozoic times compared to other paleoelevation proxies, these methods have the potential to allow quantitative mapping of past topographic change for times where existing maps are largely based on a qualitative approach.

Here, we investigate the application of paleoelevation estimates derived from geochemistry using the Pacific margin of South America as a case study. We investigate their consistency with independent indicators of past elevations such as stratigraphy, stable isotopes, fossils etc. for Cenozoic samples along the Andean margin. For older times, we compare the estimated paleoelevations with other aspects of the geological record, as well as equivalent values from global paleogeography models widely used in climate modelling studies, to evaluate the extent to which these models are consistent with the igneous geochemical proxies. We derive paleoelevation estimates according to different data filtering schemes, showing that a major consequence of the choice of geochemistry filter is the number of data points left after the filtering. We find that the igneous geochemical proxies yield elevations broadly consistent with traditional results for the Cenozoic, though our results do not resolve some of the rapid uplifts recorded by other proxies. In deeper time, we show that igneous geochemistry quantifies changes in elevation related to documented phases of crustal thickening and thinning, and is thus likely to allow improvements to existing maps of paleotopography.