Dynamics and stability of soil organic matter: climate vs. time

This study aims to investigate the mechanisms of soil organic carbon (SOC) sequestration with depth as a function of time and climate. Two chronosequences located along a climate gradient were investigated. The first chronosequence (ADI) consisted of fluvial terraces, whereas the second (LED) of fluvio-glacial terraces. Four sites (Q2, Q3, Q4 and Q5) located in 3 terraces (T1, T2, and T3), with age ranging from about 125,000 to 2,000 yr, were investigated for ADI, while 3 sites (Q1, Q2, and Q3) in 3 terraces (T1, T2, and T3, respectively), with age range from about 16,000 to 10,000 yr, were selected for LED. All sites were grasslands. Soil samples were collected (1 profile and 2 cores per site) by horizon, and each horizon sub-sampled by depth (each 5 cm). The sub-samples were characterized for pH, EC, total organic C, total N, texture, mineralogy, total and extractable elements, and for soil respiration. Particulate organic matter (POM) and mineral-associated organic matter (MAOM) were isolated and characterized by elemental and thermal analyses.

In ADI, the oldest site (ADIQ2) stocks 2 times more C in the topsoil (15 cm) than the youngest site (ADIQ5) (60 and 27 MgC/ha, respectively). Furthermore, in ADIQ3, 38% of the total SOC accumulated between 30 and 80 cm (48 MgC/ha). In LED, the youngest site (LEDQ3) shows the highest SOC stock to both 15 and 30 cm (86 and 138 MgC/ha, respectively). In LEDQ1, 46% of the total SOC accumulated between 30 and 90 cm (94 MgC/ha). Among sites having same age but different climate, LEDQ3 (the wettest and coldest site) stocks ~2 times more carbon than ADIQ3 (the driest and warmest site) to the first 30 cm of depth.

In LED, the ratio between the organic C in MAOM/POM in the topsoil ranges between 0.6 and 1.8, while in ADI between 1.1 and 3.9. Thermal indices (e.g., WL_{400-550/200-300}, TG-T₅₀) show that the stability of bulk SOM and pools generally increased with depth in ADI sites, whereas remained constant in LED. ADI soils had similar cumulative respiration (RH_CUM), whereas LEDQ3 exhibited the highest RH_CUM along the first 30 cm. Indeed, LEDQ3 had a 3× higher RH_CUM than ADIQ3 in topsoil.

Our data show that significant amounts of organic C were accumulated in deeper soils (>30cm). Moreover, soil organic matter (SOM) stability, and especially that of MAOM, in ADI increased with depth. The relative contribution of POM to C storage was more important in LED than in ADI, especially in the topsoil. Overall, our data suggest that climate has a greater influence on the size of SOC stocks than age, which in turn exerts a major influence on the stability of SOM.