The seedy underbelly of yield: how measuring verrrrrry slow grain motion changes our view of landscapes

It is now well established that many lansdcapes are organized to be close to the threshold of sediment motion: rivers, wind-blown dunes and hillslopes. 

Whether explicitly or implicitly, this threshold is almost universally treated as a Mohr-Coulomb failure criterion, which is an opaque barrier that prevents us from viewing and understanding motion beneath the yield point. Below-threshold motion is creep, and the dynamics are creepy indeed: typical continuum descriptions break down, and observed behaviors can be counterintuitive. 

In this talk I present two experiments, using two different optical techniques, that study very slow particle motions below the threshold of motion. Experiments in a scaled-down river use refractive-index matched scanning to image the interior of a sediment bed sheared by a fluid, and track particles over many orders of magnitude in velocity to show that creep is activated deep into the sediment bed. This creep hardens the bed and drives segregation. Tracking creeping grains becomes impractical, however, as it takes several months to measure the slowest particle motions. 

To overcome these simplifications and expand our study of creep, we examine an apparently static sandpile that is isolated from external disturbance. Instead of particle tracking, we use an optical interferometry technique called Diffusive Wave Spectroscopy (DWS) that allows us to measure creep rates as low as nanometers/second. Viewed through the lens of DWS, the model hillslope is alive with motion as internal avalanches of grain rearrangements flicker throughout the pile. We observe similar dynamics to those observed in the river experiment -- albeit over much shorter timescales -- even though the only significant stress is gravity. What causes these grains to creep below their angle of repose? Observations suggest that minute mechanical noise may play a role, but reducing the noise floor beyond our fairly quiescent conditions is very challenging. Instead, we raise the driving stresses through heating, tapping and flow. 

The observations lead to new view of sediment creep as relaxation and rejuvenation of a glassy material, where mechanical noise plays a role akin to thermal fluctuations in traditional glass materials. Sub-yield deformation is a new world to explore, for those patient enough to look for it.