Comparing Life-Cycle Environmental Impacts of Natural Gas-Fired and Renewable Electricity Generation

The mission of the Comparing Electricity Options (CEO) research program at UT Austin is to understand and quantify trade-offs among society’s goals of providing reliable and affordable energy, mitigating climate change, and improving local environments that can sustain a healthy economy for future populations. Our goals are to create tools that support decision makers in the energy and policy sectors with better environmental and economic assessments to manage environmental, social, and governance risks across global supply chains; highlight where innovation can mitigate impacts; and, inform policies that encourage innovation. This is done by conducting a three-phase, data-driven study of natural gas-fired, wind, and solar power plants (including batteries to address intermittencies). We use several methodologies and will develop interactive tools to allow wider audiences to quickly compare alternative scenarios. In Phase 1, which we anticipate will be completed in early 2023, we conduct a life-cycle assessment (LCA) of power plants for 18 impacts covering greenhouse gas and local (PM, SO_X, NO_X) emissions; land and water use and pollution, biodiversity and ecosystem services, etc. The LCA system boundaries encompass extraction of natural resources, manufacturing of generation equipment, power plant operations, and end-of-life. In Phase 2, which will begin in mid-2023, we investigate electric power grids instead of individual power plants, and aggregate environmental impacts and costs associated with transitioning generation mixes over time, including new transmission and distribution infrastructure. In Phase 3, we use results from Phases 1 and 2 to develop a new cost estimate for electricity at the consumer level that includes environmental and system costs. We show early results from Phase 1 and how environmental impacts are manifested along the global supply chains needed to support energy development, at different times during the 30-year lifespan of the facilities.