The Tipping Points of the Atlantic Meridional Overturning Circulation in Warm and Cold Climates

In response to abruptly increasing atmospheric CO₂ concentrations, general circulation model experiments typically evidence a rapid reduction or full collapse of the Atlantic Meridional Overturning Circulation (AMOC) from its current, strongly overturning state, into one characterized by weak overturning and reduced northward oceanic heat transport. This tipping point is frequently discussed in the context of present and past global climate changes. Less understood, however, is the evolution of the circulation towards a new equilibrium state, which occurs over many centuries or millennia following the initial AMOC response. To revisit this problem, we have performed multi-millennial simulations of the Community Earth System Model version 1 (CESM1) in a low-resolution configuration (T31 gx3v7), appropriate for paleoclimate studies. We consider a pre-industrial control (284.7ppm) simulation, as well as abrupt 2x, 4x, 8x, 16x, and 0.5x pre-industrial control atmospheric CO₂ concentrations whereby atmospheric concentrations are increased at the start of integration and held constant for the duration of the experiment. In all global warming scenarios, we observe a rapid collapse to the AMOC within the first 250 years, attributed mechanistically to the complex interplay between surface salinity and temperature which inhibits deep-water formation in the sub-polar North Atlantic. Then, in our abrupt doubling and quadrupling of atmospheric CO₂ experiments we observe a recovery to the circulation after some 1,000 years, and 3,500 years, respectively. After initially collapsing, our 8xCO₂ experiment remains in this weakened state even after 10,000 years of integration have been performed, potentially indicating that a new equilibrium may have been met in this very warm climate.

 

We have further observed other intriguing bifurcations which arise stochastically in the forced system. First, in our abrupt 4xCO₂ experiment, with the AMOC in a collapsed state we observe a spontaneous activation of the Pacific Meridional Overturning Circulation (PMOC) some 2,500 years following the initial forcing. The circulation persists for 1,000 years and has a notable effect on climate in the North Pacific region, for instance raising surface temperatures through the associated increase in Pacific Ocean northward heat transport. At 3,500 years the circulation collapses concomitantly with an AMOC recovery in the experiment, demonstrating a AMOC/PMOC seesaw. Secondly, in our abrupt global cooling experiment, we observe a spontaneous collapse of the AMOC after 2,000 years, which precedes a recovery over the next 1,500 years, before a secondary, rapid collapse to the circulation at 3,500 years. The behavior resembles a Dansgaard-Oeschger Event. Overall, our results highlight the rich quasi-equilibrium dynamical behavior of the Global Meridional Overturning Circulation in past climates for which atmospheric CO₂ concentrations were markedly different.