NH3.13 | Nature-based and bio-based solutions for geohazard mitigation on slopes and streambanks
EDI
Nature-based and bio-based solutions for geohazard mitigation on slopes and streambanks
Convener: Vittoria Capobianco | Co-conveners: Alessandro Fraccica, Grainne El Mountassir, Gerrit MeijerECSECS, Anil YildizECSECS
Orals
| Fri, 28 Apr, 10:45–12:25 (CEST)
 
Room C
Posters on site
| Attendance Fri, 28 Apr, 16:15–18:00 (CEST)
 
Hall X4
Posters virtual
| Attendance Fri, 28 Apr, 16:15–18:00 (CEST)
 
vHall NH
Orals |
Fri, 10:45
Fri, 16:15
Fri, 16:15
Climate-induced or anthropogenically triggered soil-related geohazards may cause damage to buildings, infrastructure and the environment. Climate-induced geohazards, such as landslides, floods or droughts, are known to exacerbate with climate change due to the increased frequency and intensity of rainfall and extreme weather events.

Solutions that mimic natural or biological processes are increasingly being adopted to mitigate the triggering or propagation of such geohazards through improvement of the soil behaviour and its characteristics.

The use of vegetation on potentially unstable slopes and streambanks is an example of a Nature-Based Solution (NBS).
Microbiological activity can also modify soil behaviour. For example, microbially-induced calcite precipitation and biological exudates (such as vegetation mucilage or biopolymers) can change both soil strength and permeability. Furthermore, fungal activity can improve erosion resistance and alter the rheology of the soil.

These NBS must combine ecological approaches with engineering design in order to provide practical solutions, while also maintaining/enhancing biodiversity and ecosystem services.

This session aims to stimulate interdisciplinary knowledge exchange of NBS and bio-based solutions for geohazard mitigation, with a particular focus on the topics of landslides and erosion.

Contributions could originate from the fields of geotechnical engineering, ecological engineering, biodiversity, forestry, hydrogeology and agronomy, among others. Experiences of interactions between research and industry, with involvement of NBS entrepreneurs, are particularly welcome.

Topics of interest include, but are not limited to:
• Experimental (either laboratory or field) or numerical investigation of hydrological and/or mechanical reinforcement due to vegetation or bio-based solutions for slopes or streambanks;
• Theoretical or empirical data-driven design methods used in geotechnical engineering for vegetated and bio-improved soils;
• Tools, practical approaches and frameworks demonstrating how NBS can be used to mitigate geohazards while providing additional co-benefits;
• Upscaling potential of laboratory data to slope and catchment scales;
• Case studies of restoration, stabilization works, or Eco-DRR, especially involving design principles and performance assessment;
• Guidelines, reviews, and data repositories on NBS for risk reduction, with focus on NBS for infrastructure protection.

Orals: Fri, 28 Apr | Room C

Chairpersons: Vittoria Capobianco, Alessandro Fraccica, Grainne El Mountassir
Laboratory - in-situ studies
10:45–10:55
|
EGU23-5759
|
ECS
|
On-site presentation
Eve Roberts-Self and Alessandro Tarantino

The use of vegetation to mitigate rainfall induced landslide hazards is a form of a Nature Based Solution. Rainfall induced landslides occur when the pore-water pressure builds up in the soil in response to infiltrating rainwater. The vegetation can create a stabilising effect by the removal of soil water via transpiration. The removal of water keeps the soil in an unsaturated state and decreases pore-water pressure in the soil, thus reducing hydraulic conductivity. Lowering the hydraulic conductivity before a rainfall event will reduce the downward infiltration of water and, hence, hinder pore-water pressure build-up (drop in suction) that could result in a landslide.

To improve this stabilizing effect the transpiration during a drying period should be maximized. This study looks at implementing biological processes that occur in the root zone with the aim of engineering the transpiration process. A common biotic interaction that occurs in the soil is the symbiotic relationship between mycorrhizal fungi and plant roots. The fungus has been found to improve nutrient and water uptake in plants. This research looks at the effect of mycorrhizal fungi on transpiration induced soil suction.

A controlled laboratory experiment was carried out to determine if the application of arbuscular mycorrhizal (AM) fungi can increase transpiration of the herbaceous plants Medicago sativa and Lolium perenne. The plants were grown in mini-lysimeters with and without AM fungi and then exposed to drying conditions. The evapotranspiration was monitored via measurements of the change in mass of the mini-lysimeter and the soil water content was then back calculated from the final water content. Periodic soil volumetric water content measurements were also carried out using TDR-probes. The suction during drying was determined from the volumetric water content assuming that the water retention in the vegetated soil is the same as the bare soil, whose water retention properties were fully characterised in a separate experiment.

The inoculation with AM fungi in M. sativa plants increased the potential evapotranspiration during soil drying, this is likely due to the increase in the aboveground biomass. There was no significant difference between inoculated and non-inoculated L. perenne plants. The soil suction in the M. sativa plants increased by almost twice when inoculated with AM fungi in the same drying period. Inoculating with AM fungi can increase plant transpiration rates and generates a higher suction in the soil for M. sativa vegetation, although there was little difference with L. perenne plants. This suggests that the effect of AM fungi on plant water uptake can depend on root functional groups.

How to cite: Roberts-Self, E. and Tarantino, A.: Engineering transpiration-induced suction using mycorrhizal fungi with application to slope stability, EGU General Assembly 2023, Vienna, Austria, 23–28 Apr 2023, EGU23-5759, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu23-5759, 2023.

10:55–11:05
|
EGU23-10147
|
Virtual presentation
Anthony Leung, Viroon Kamchoom, Suched Likitlersuang, and David Boldrin

Plant roots provide mechanical reinforcement to soil and improve soil shear strength. How root decay upon mortality may affect the root biomechanical properties and the subsequent changes in root reinforcement to soil have rarely been systematically studied. The aim of this study is to provide new experimental evidence and quantify the influences of root growth and decomposition on the temporary variations in root breakage strength, root Young’s modulus and the shearing behaviour including dilatancy of compacted soils vegetated with a grass species, Cynodon dactylon L. In this study, C. dactylon was cultivated for six months in 33 columns of compacted lateritic soils (90 mm diameter and 115 mm height), and then either burned or treated with herbicide to introduce root mortality and decay. At different durations of plant growth (60, 120 and 180 days), decay after plant burning (30, 60, 120, 180 and 360 days) and after herbicide application (15, 30 and 60 days), each column was split into two parts; the top part was used for direct-shear tests, whilst root samples were collected from the bottom part for the measurements of root diameter as well as root biomechanical and chemical properties (including the cellulose and lignin contents) (n = 303). Our results showed that all the tensile strength-diameter relations of the roots of C. dactylon followed a negative power law relation (R2 > 0.6) regardless of the treatment applied. Growth effects had significant effects on the increase in median tensile strength, which was consistent with the increase in cellulose and lignin contents. As a result, the vegetated soils displayed greater shear strength and larger dilatancy, which were attributable to the growth-induced increase in the root cellulose content and thus the root tensile strength and modulus. The predominant root failure mode at all growth durations was pull-out (rather than breakage); thus, the soil shear strength was better explained by root modulus (36.0%; which defines root extension) than root strength (25.8%; which defines root breakage capacity) and root biomass (1.6%; which defines root content). On the other hand, root decay due to burning or herbicide application caused significant reductions in cellulose and lignin contents, accompanied by a drop in root tensile strength. This explained the significant reductions in soil dilatancy and soil shear strength. The predominant root failure mode switched from pull-out to breakage. Compared with burning, herbicide application introduced a greater and faster degradation of cellulose and lignin con-tents, which explained the more significant and faster root weakening. Reducing the shear strength of the vegetated soils to the level of fallow soil took approximately 2 months of herbicide application and 4 months of burning.

How to cite: Leung, A., Kamchoom, V., Likitlersuang, S., and Boldrin, D.: Losses of biomechanical properties and soil reinforcement upon the decomposition of the roots of Cynodon dactylon, EGU General Assembly 2023, Vienna, Austria, 23–28 Apr 2023, EGU23-10147, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu23-10147, 2023.

11:05–11:15
|
EGU23-14299
|
ECS
|
On-site presentation
Ha My Ngo, Feiko Bernard van Zadelhoff, Ivo Gasparini, Julien Plaschy, Gianluca Flepp, Luuk Dorren, Chris Phillips, Filippo Giadrossich, and Massimiliano Schwarz

Poplar (Populus sp.) is an important species for preventing shallow, rainfall-triggered landslides and hydraulic bank erosion in New Zealand. However, quantifying the spatial root distribution pattern and reinforcement remains challenging. This study aimed to find the Root Bundle Model with the Weibull survival function (RBMw), a root distribution model (RDM), and a root reinforcement model for the implementation in models such as BankforMAP and SlideforMAP. Our study was conducted within a 26-year-old “Tasman” poplar stand at Ballantrae Hill Country Research Station in the North Island of NZ. We measured root distribution at distances of 1.5, 2.5, 3.5, and 4.5 m from the stem of four poplar trees whose diameters ranged from 0.41 to 0.56 m and from eleven soil profiles along a transect located in a sparse to a densely planted poplar stand. This created a unique database of root distribution. 124 laboratory tensile tests and 66 field pullout tests on roots with diameters up to 0.04 m were carried out. The root distribution model well predicted spatial root partition in trenches of single tree root systems with R2 = 0.78 and in the transect with R2 = 0.85. The model tends to overestimate root distribution when planting density was higher than 200 stems per hectare. The maximum lateral root reinforcement model tends to underestimate forces in single tree root systems with R2 = 0.64, but it well performs along the transect within the stand with different planting densities. The basal root reinforcement model performed well in predicting its vertical distribution as a function of soil depth. In conclusion, our study provided a detailed dataset for the quantification of root distribution and reinforcement of poplars on a hillslope for the purpose of increasing slope stability and mitigating hydraulic bank erosion. The implementation of these data in models for the simulation of shallow landslides and hydraulic bank erosion is fundamental for the identification of hazardous zones and the prioritization of bio-engineering measures in NZ catchments. Moreover, the results are used to formulate a general guideline for the planning of bio-engineering measures considering the temporal dynamics of poplar’s growth and their effectiveness in sediment and erosion control.

How to cite: Ngo, H. M., van Zadelhoff, F. B., Gasparini, I., Plaschy, J., Flepp, G., Dorren, L., Phillips, C., Giadrossich, F., and Schwarz, M.: Analysis of “Tasman” poplar’s (Populus deltoides x Populus nigra) root systems for the quantification of bio-engineering services in New Zealand pastoral hill country., EGU General Assembly 2023, Vienna, Austria, 23–28 Apr 2023, EGU23-14299, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu23-14299, 2023.

Case studies - slope stability
11:15–11:25
|
EGU23-14574
|
On-site presentation
Helene Hofmann-Lanter, Martina Prambauer, and Dorota Czerski

High-tensile steel nets have established themselves as a solution for stabilising landslide-prone areas. To return an engineered slope as much as possible back to a natural look, thoughts of revegetation should always accompany such stabilisation projects. Different factors play a role in natural revegetation, such as the inclination and orientation of said slope and the erosion potential through water percolation. Sometimes it is necessary to help revegetation when a combination of unfavourable factors is present. This can be achieved by adding a geotextile.
When vegetation might take several years to grow, a long-term geotextile is required, which does not degrade in the first years. In such a long-term geotextile, 3D mats out of polypropylene were quite successful. Unfortunately, when it comes to its degradation, sometimes after decades, microplastics are released into the environment. This added an essential aspect to the constantly growing need for substituting petrol-based polymers with nature-based materials. This work highlights the different trials with materials to obtain a controlled degradation of the geotextile material into non-hazardous components. By applying biobased, biodegradable polymers for such applications, the need for material recollection is eliminated, and plastic waste’s impact on the environment is significantly reduced. In this work, biopolymer blend fibres were produced and evaluated in terms of mechanical properties and biodegradability. The blends were based on bio-polyester blends, and the properties were tailored by adjusting the composition of the blend fibres to resemble the existing polypropylene product. The degradation rate of the blend fibres was observed by artificial weathering and hydrolytic degradation tests. As a result, a relation between material structure, fibre strength and durability period was obtained and a complete 3D mat could be produced. Once the material was thoroughly tested in the laboratory, a first small-scale field test was set up in 2020, followed last summer with a large-scale 1:1 field test in southern Switzerland, where careful monitoring assesses the stability of the material as well as the stability of the soil beneath it. The development of the material in the laboratory as well as the first results from the large-scale field test will be presented.

How to cite: Hofmann-Lanter, H., Prambauer, M., and Czerski, D.: Development of bio-based, biodegradable geotextiles for the revegetation of stabilized landslide-prone areas, EGU General Assembly 2023, Vienna, Austria, 23–28 Apr 2023, EGU23-14574, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu23-14574, 2023.

11:25–11:35
|
EGU23-14340
|
Highlight
|
Virtual presentation
|
Niels Hollard, Christine von Moos, and Luuk Dorren

Worldwide, landslides and hillslope debris flow cause major infrastructure damage and fatalities. It is widely recognized that forests can prevent the release of a landslide by reinforcing the soil with the roots and positively influence the water balance. However, the question remains whether and how trees affect the runout of hillslope debris flows. The objective of this study was to quantify the potential braking effect of trees and the influence of different forest structures in the runout zone of hillslope debris flows. We therefore combined an analysis of historical hillslope debris flow events in the forest and on open land with laboratory tests.

 

The analysis of the historical events showed a general tendency that forest has a positive effect on the runout, in particular for smaller events (release area < 300 m2). The runout length significantly decreased with an increasing tree density. In addition, significantly more material was deposited behind thicker trees. This suggests that a well-structured stand with a high stem number, but also occasional large diameters, offers ideal protection against hillslope debris flows in the runout zone. The results of the laboratory tests indicate that the braking effect of different forest structures (dense, open, with gaps) is always given in comparison to a situation without forest, and this at lower (16%) and higher (20%) water contents. Generally, the effect of the trees was more pronounced for soils with a lower water content. Although the influence of the forest was always highlighted in comparaison to the situation without forest, no significant influence was showed between the three forest structures.

How to cite: Hollard, N., von Moos, C., and Dorren, L.: Trees as hillslope debris flow brakers, EGU General Assembly 2023, Vienna, Austria, 23–28 Apr 2023, EGU23-14340, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu23-14340, 2023.

11:35–11:45
|
EGU23-1026
|
On-site presentation
Chris Phillips

Harvesting of steepland forests results in a short period where the landscape is particularly susceptible to rainfall-triggered shallow landslides between crop rotations. This is known as the ‘window of vulnerability’ (WoV) and has been considered to occur up to 6-8 years following clearfelling. The WoV represents a period in the forest's rotation where the interplay between declining root strength from the previous crop coincides with changes in soil hydrology creating conditions where soil strength is at its lowest, and the slope is vulnerable to failure.

This project aimed to focus on when maximum susceptibility to rainfall triggered landslides occurs within the WoV. We examined three areas in New Zealand where significant rain events (AEP's  < 1%) had resulted in many landslides on forest land harvested in the years immediately preceding those events.

Using forest company imagery, LiDAR and satellite information we manually discriminated rainfall-triggered landslides for each study area. In all three areas, landslides were 'tagged' to vegetation cover, time since harvesting and whether associated with forest infrastructure such as roads and landings or not.

Maximum landslide number and density occured on land clear-felled 2-4 years prior to the event and was slightly different for each study area. Landslides also occurred in older forest age classes and on areas with different vegetation covers, i.e., mature indigenous forests, pasture, scrub, etc. There were fewer landslides associated with forest infrastructure such as roads and landings than those deemed to be ‘natural’ slope failures.  

Better information on the period of susceptibility to rainfall-triggered landslides following forest removal may help forest managers and regulators better understand the nature of this hazard and what can and can’t be done to mitigate the effects of rain events that result in landslides and in some cases often ‘disastrous’ off-forest impacts.

How to cite: Phillips, C.: Examining the "Window of Vulnerability" following steepland plantation forest removal in New Zealand, EGU General Assembly 2023, Vienna, Austria, 23–28 Apr 2023, EGU23-1026, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu23-1026, 2023.

11:45–11:55
|
EGU23-16844
|
Highlight
|
On-site presentation
Paola Sangalli and Guillermo Tardío

According to the European Federation of Soil and Water Bioengineering ( EFIB ) Soil and Water Bioengineering (SWB) is a specific discipline that combines technology and biology in which native plants and plant communities are used as living building material to solve erosion and conservation problems, contributing to the regeneration of degraded ecosystems due to natural or anthropic causes, toregenerate the dynamics of ecological and geomorphological processes and to the recovery of Biodiversity.

The use of Nature Based Solutions (NBS)  as SWB is becoming more and more widespread in public administrations, for example, looking for specific solutions  for landslide stabilization(SWB )

Due to the orographic, edaphic, and climatological conditions of the Basque Country, landslides occur frequently. In the last decade, several landslide stabilizations projects have been carried out on road slopes using SWB solutions as an alternative to traditional engineering solutions. the Department of Road Infrastructures of the Basque administration  requested a series of technical projects  in which alternatives to traditional engineering solutions are presented using SWB, choosing a series of standard reports. The communication will present several examples realized  in the last fifteen years  in different conditions and the evolution of this work during this period.

The measures taken focused on:

  • The restoration of the slope morphology and its natural gradient and vegetation
  • The stabilization of landslides by using live structures like living cribwall or living
  • Improvement of the drainage of the slope with living drains

More recently , public entities have detected the need to have high quality technical manuals that support them in both the drafting of projects and definition of this type of works. To give answer to this situation, the Provincial Council of Bizkaia has commissioned the companies IDOM and SCIA SL  to form a working group for the definition and development of the technical manual of SWB works applied to the case of linear infrastructures. This manual is including the latest advances in the soil and water bioengineering discipline (description and constructive details of the techniques, root reinforcement models, work design methodologies in the short and long term, deterioration models of the utilized materials, etc.). The full manual will be completed and published throughout 2023.

This paper shows concrete examples realized in the Basque country and the progress and contents developed to date as well as the topics index that will be included throughout this year

.

How to cite: Sangalli, P. and Tardío, G.: Landslide stabilization using Soil and Water Bioengineering  in linear Infrastructures in Basque country  and technical manual   , EGU General Assembly 2023, Vienna, Austria, 23–28 Apr 2023, EGU23-16844, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu23-16844, 2023.

Case studies - streambanks
11:55–12:05
|
EGU23-1695
|
Virtual presentation
André Evette, Eléonore Mira, Marie Robert, Alain Rousteau, Régis Tournebize, Lucie Labbouz, and Pierre Raymond

Within the biodiversity hotspot of the West Indies, Guadeloupe presents a remarkable plant biodiversity. The strong urbanization along its rivers leads to the alarming degradation of their banks through artificialization and proliferation of invasive alien species.

Since 2015, the "PROTEGER" project, led by the Guadeloupe National Park and involving INRAE and the University of the West Indies, and funded by the European Union and the French Biodiversity Agency, has been promoting and developing the use of native species and copying natural models to restore riparian ecosystems using soil bioengineering techniques. The first phase of the project (2016-2018) characterized 12 types of Guadeloupe's riparian forests and identified 80 native species potentially suitable for riparian restoration. The second phase of the project (2019-2022) focused on the control of the multiplication of 26 of these species, and their use on bank protection and restoration sites. An experiment on cuttings was conducted on 21 native species (9 tree 4 shrub species; and 8 herbaceous species), another on the germination and growth of seedlings of 5 species of tree legumes. The first soil water bioengineering demonstration projects was implemented along a riverbank through a training course. The third phase to come aims to disseminate the knowledge to local stakeholders and the development of a local economic sector of nurseries and specialized companies.

This project allows the improvement of scientific knowledge of Guadeloupean riparian environments and the development of innovative techniques for the restoration and protection of these environments using local plant species. This project associates managers and researchers in a global approach for the development of a sustainable sector of ecological engineering on the Guadeloupean territory.

How to cite: Evette, A., Mira, E., Robert, M., Rousteau, A., Tournebize, R., Labbouz, L., and Raymond, P.: “Protéger” an integrated project to promote soil bioengineering to protect riverbanks of Guadeloupe, EGU General Assembly 2023, Vienna, Austria, 23–28 Apr 2023, EGU23-1695, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu23-1695, 2023.

12:05–12:15
|
EGU23-16051
|
On-site presentation
Aldo Freitas, Ana Maria Oliveira, Rita Sousa, Rui Silva Santos, and Sara Francisca Sousa

This project is part of a wider EU-funded investment totalling 5,8 M€, that generally aimed for the sustainable flood control using bioengineering solutions in a total of 32 km. It represents the biggest investment ever made in Portugal regarding river restoration.

For this case, the objectives were to stabilize both river margins of a 250 m stretch of river Póvoa in Loures city and to restore the native vegetation.

The site is located in a highly populated area near Lisbon and is prone to recurring (and severe) floods.

This is due to several reasons: it falls within the floodplain of river Trancão; part of its basin drains water from steep hills located at a distance of less than 1 km; it suffers the influence of the Atlantic Sea tides via river Tagus.

The problems observed were both geotechnical and ecological. In the first case, several mass movements and cracks with more than 20 cm depth and 30 m long where present. The ecological problems were mainly related to the dominance of the giant reed (Arundo donax), an invasive species which the superficial roots do not contribute to in-depth slope stabilization.

The major aim of the latter was to develop a global solution for sustainable water management in the event of floods. During this process, the hydrology and hydraulics of river Loures basin was studied. The interventions included not only several works of civil engineering – culvert widening, installing passive tide gates, etc. – but also soil and water-bioengineering techniques (SWBT). These would promote erosion control, slope stabilization and consolidation as well as the ecological recovery of the site.

Regarding the Póvoa stretch, the hydrological and hydraulic model concluded that a maximum velocity of 1,8 m/s and a maximum shear stress of 17,068 N/m2 was expected for the 100-year flood, this including a high-tide scenario. Taking this into consideration along with the site characteristics and a thorough review of SWBT literature, the solution adopted to stabilize the streambanks was a vegetated crib wall. This structure is able to withstand water velocities between 3 and 6 m/s and 200-300 N/m2 of shear stress, thus suitable for the existing conditions.

The design included a retaining structure in two terraces in both riverbanks and a total height of 2,6 m. The bottom crib wall was to be filled with drain rock and the upper structure with soil and live willow stakes.

The works started in June 2022 and were at a good pace. The contractor was following the Project’s drawings as well as the Project team’s recommendation – a team with several years of experience in implementing SWBT in Portugal and abroad.

A few months later, the site was subject to heavy rainfall that caused 3 major floods, including the nearby area. Although the vegetated crib wall was not totally finished, the structure remained intact.

This Project and specifically the constructed vegetated crib wall showed that a careful conception and design of SWBT allied with a solid construction is vital for a successful outcome.

How to cite: Freitas, A., Oliveira, A. M., Sousa, R., Silva Santos, R., and Sousa, S. F.: Streambank Stabilization in River Póvoa, Loures, Portugal, EGU General Assembly 2023, Vienna, Austria, 23–28 Apr 2023, EGU23-16051, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu23-16051, 2023.

12:15–12:25
|
EGU23-5403
|
ECS
|
On-site presentation
Rousset Juliette, Piton Guillaume, Didier Marie, François Adeline, and Evette André

Due to the steep relief of the mountain massifs, the valleys are strategic locations for the establishment of human activities. Over last decades, the floodplain of alpine rivers has been highly anthropized. However, mountain rivers have a strong erosive power that can threaten human infrastructures. To protect them, riverbanks are regularly protected with civil engineering works. Yet, this environment is home to a high level of biodiversity. Thus, soil water bioengineering techniques appear sustainable by allowing both to protect the anthropogenic assets and to welcome the rich riparian biodiversity and the associated ecological services. To implement these Nature-Based Solutions, it is necessary to draw inspiration from the biotic and abiotic components of natural riverbanks, which are still poorly understood at high altitude due to several pressures (climatic, hydrologic, hydraulic or morphologic). In order to understand the structure and functioning of natural models of alpine riverbanks, a protocol has been implemented on 21 mountain banks with mature vegetation and no signs of erosion. The sites were located in the Vanoise massif (France) on an altitudinal gradient (1331 – 2131 m) ranging from montane to subalpine belts with a wide range of channel slope (0,8 – 28,4 %). By focusing on the bank toe, biotic (vegetation cover and species biological features) and abiotic (altitude and hydrogeomorphology) components have been measured. First observations showed that the grain size distribution of the sediments forming the bank was coarser and more homogeneous than those forming the channel bed. For the step-pool channels, bank grain sizes were coarser than for plane-bed channels. Shields parameters for the 21 banks were well below the thresholds for sediment motion, and were therefore relatively stable. Furthermore, on all the sites the shear stresses were relatively high but according to the literature values, classic bioengineering structures could be implemented on 16 of the sites and would withstand a 100-year return period flood, which is consistent with our observation of mature, stable and healthy vegetation patches. The mineral component of the bank toe is closely linked to the woody plant structure. The vegetation cover was dominated by 12 species of willow and the green alder. Green alder cover increased with the altitude and the bed slope. Willow species cover varied with altitude and was less important for steep river. Thus, the natural models of banks were: (i) for the rivers with steep slope, models mixing mineral and plant units which both took part jointly in the stability of the bank; and (ii) for the rivers with lower slope the stability of the bank was mainly ensured by the vegetation. This work provided additional knowledge on the structure and functioning of the banks of stable and mature high-altitude rivers. Accordingly, these results will allow to design soil water bioengineering techniques more adapted to mountain environments (plant composition and structure, mineral unit size).

How to cite: Juliette, R., Guillaume, P., Marie, D., Adeline, F., and André, E.: Natural streambank structure assessment in mountain rivers: an approach combining ecology and hydromorphology, EGU General Assembly 2023, Vienna, Austria, 23–28 Apr 2023, EGU23-5403, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu23-5403, 2023.

Posters on site: Fri, 28 Apr, 16:15–18:00 | Hall X4

Chairpersons: Vittoria Capobianco, Alessandro Fraccica
Case studies - slope stability
X4.38
|
EGU23-1753
|
ECS
|
Maximilian Kramer, Adrian Ringenbach, and Jürgen Suda

Society has established different mitigation strategies to minimize rockfall impacts on civil infrastructure. Typically, there are two distinct active protection measures to minimize the impact of natural mountain hazards: protection forests as a natural solution and rockfall barriers as a technical solution, which are applied when the protective effect of the natural solution is not sufficient. These measures have usually been implemented separately without the consideration of combined solutions. This study, guided by the approach of nature-based solutions, offers a strategy to permanently implement trees into rockfall barriers. It includes the tree-physiological potential impact forces, the technical design, and the structural dimensioning. We assessed the force-absorption potential of trees based on literature research. The technical design developed during this study is based on pre-existing tree-integrated systems (TIS) and various fixation strategy suggestions. We aimed for our structural engineering dimensioning to be according to the European Guidelines for designing steel and timber structures. The literature shows that there is stem breakage in cases of sudden dynamic impacts like rockfalls, but no uprooting is observed. As a result, the potential impact force was determined solely by the wooden body, which was dimensioned in accordance with European guidelines. This detailed dimensioning strategy results in an innovative TIS design. E.g., in the case of a 50 m long 500 kJ barrier, 6 steel posts, and 11 drilled anchors can be saved, assuming the use of 35 cm thick trees. The designed TIS rockfall protection system would be feasible and structurally sound up to energies of 1000 kJ if thicker trees were used.

How to cite: Kramer, M., Ringenbach, A., and Suda, J.: Tree-integration into flexible rockfall barriers: feasibility, implementation and structural design, EGU General Assembly 2023, Vienna, Austria, 23–28 Apr 2023, EGU23-1753, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu23-1753, 2023.

X4.39
|
EGU23-9214
|
ECS
Amanda DiBiagio, Vittoria Capobianco, Amy Oen, and Lena M. Tallaksen

The use of vegetation as a nature-based solution for shallow landslide risk reduction is receiving increased attention in the scientific community. Vegetation can contribute to slope stability through both hydrological and mechanical root reinforcement, which improves resilience against shallow landslide triggering. In order to quantify the performance of roots as a slope stabilizing measure, slope stability models are valuable tools. Murgia et al. (2022) conducted a thorough review of the existing physically-based models that consider the mechanical effect of roots in the calculation of factor of safety (FoS), suitable for both regional and slope-scale analysis (physically based probabilistic and deterministic models, respectively). This study will build on to the previous review with an in-depth analysis of the equations governing the individuated models that account for the effect of root reinforcement on slope stability. With emphasis also on hydrological effects of vegetation, the governing equations of the different models are analysed and compared, and FoS of an ideal slope case will be assessed by using a selection of the identified models. Finally, this review will serve as a base to develop a guideline which will serve as a tool to ease the decision-making process when deciding which model to use when mitigation measures for a specific slope is to be designed.

Reference: Murgia, I., Giadrossich, F., Mao, Z., Cohen, D., Capra, G. F., & Schwarz, M. (2022). Modeling shallow landslides and root reinforcement: A review. Ecological Engineering181, 106671.

How to cite: DiBiagio, A., Capobianco, V., Oen, A., and Tallaksen, L. M.: Governing equations of slope stability models that consider hydrological and mechanical effect of root reinforcement: A review, EGU General Assembly 2023, Vienna, Austria, 23–28 Apr 2023, EGU23-9214, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu23-9214, 2023.

X4.40
|
EGU23-13225
|
ECS
Parametric analyses to evaluate the hydro-mechanical stabilizing effect of bio-engineering solutions
(withdrawn)
Erica Cernuto, Diana Salciarini, Arianna Lupattelli, Silvia Settembre, and Elisabetta Cattoni
Case studies - streambanks
X4.42
|
EGU23-13109
Solange Leblois, Guillaume Piton, Alain Recking, and André Evette

Willow fascine is the soil bioengineering technique for riverbank stabilization the most frequently used in France. Made up of bundles of living branches fixed between stakes, the fascine presents various possible configurations, adaptable to each site. The structure, with high theoretical resistance, is implemented at the bottom of the riverbank joining the riverbed and the riverbank, which makes it subject to strong constraints. Terrain return of experience showed that 22 % of the fascines did not start or did not stand after few years. Punctual observations in the field do not give the possibility to understand the whole process behind fascines structural failure nor to test various fascine configurations over a short period of time. The study based on physical modelling (scale 1:25) describes how riverbanks with fascines are destabilized and develops which fascine design could better stand. The techniques are replicated on the extrados of three meanders created in the flume. Each bank protection technique undergoes the same flood hydrogram. Three various bank toe protection techniques are tested with and without geotextile to protect the rest of the bank. Bank toe without protection is confronted to designs of (i) fascines with one bundle, (ii) fascines with two bundles and (iii) ripraps with the thickness of the two bundles fascine. Bank pressure is measured continuously, the topography is established by photogrammetry before and after each experiment and direct observations are conducted. As first main result, the process of destabilization of riverbanks with fascines could be descripted. Scour holes, naturally occurring at meanders extrados, develop bellow the fascine level of implementation. The bank material initially stocked behind the fascine is than free to fall in the scour hole. The fascine ends up isolated in the river. Without contact to the substrate, the living material cannot start anymore. Moreover, consecutive to the scour holes development, the fascines stakes fall into the river leading to the fascine structural failure. As second result, between the three bank toe protection techniques tested, the fascine with two bundles and geotextile stabilized the best the bank. However, this strong configuration resulted with deeper scour holes at the bottom of the fascine. Finally as third result, with the sediment material used, the water pressure differential between the riverbank and the running water did not enhance any bank erosion. The destabilization of riverbank with fascines is mainly driven by natural morphologic river adjustment. Consequently, the fascine design could be adjusted as follow. (i) The bank slope must be reduced to its maximum to minimize the scour hole. (ii) The fascine must be deeply anchored by the stakes. (iii) The fascine toe, below the level of vegetation start, is preferentially reinforced by extra bundles, wood pieces or riprap, in order to confined the bank material.

How to cite: Leblois, S., Piton, G., Recking, A., and Evette, A.: Fascines for riverbank stabilization : structural failure processes and design suggestions from physical modelling, EGU General Assembly 2023, Vienna, Austria, 23–28 Apr 2023, EGU23-13109, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu23-13109, 2023.

X4.43
|
EGU23-15154
|
ECS
Anna Briefer and Rosemarie Stangl

Keywords: soil and water bioengineering, neophyte control, nature-based solutions, flood protection project, ecological river planning

Abstract: Dominance-forming communities of neophytes arise primarily alongside rivers and cause nature conservation-, economic-, hydraulic engineering- and health-related problems for society. Nature-based soil and water bioengineering (SWB) techniques offer sustainable and adaptable solutions to enable environment friendly interventions. The modes of action are multifunctional and offer the possibility of counteracting complex problems.

The flood protection project on the Raababach in Gössendorf (Styria, Austria) was launched by the State of Styria and implemented in the years 2017 to 2020. The aim was to create flood protection for the neighboring communities and to restore the river Raababach to a near-natural state. The measures were divided into two sections. Section one is characterised by direct intervention in the discharge area. In section two, measures off the stream course were implemented in the form of dams and retention basins.

This case study investigated SWB measures for bank protection implemented as part of the flood protection project (restoration and stabilisation) on the Raababach in Gössendorf (Styria, Austria) and the occurrence of neophytes in section one. The implemented SWB bank protections were evaluated and deviations from the ecological planning were analysed. The number and type of neophytes were mapped and recommendations for action were derived from a four-color rating system. The development of a willow brush mattress (aged 1 y) was recorded in detail and the emerging species were documented. The results of the construction type evaluation and the neophyte monitoring were superimposed and the connections between the selected bank protection and the neophyte incidence were pointed out.

The results revealed that the choice of bank protection, the type of construction design and adjacent areas with a neophyte infestation have an impact on the incidence of neophytes and that specific maintenance measures are necessary. Surface closing construction designs with high initial coverage (willow brush mattress) proved to be favourable for neophyte suppression, while critical stands were surveyed around the area of the concealed stone protection.

How to cite: Briefer, A. and Stangl, R.: Nature-based soil and water bioengineering solutions for neophyte control on streambanks - Case study on vegetation related reinforcement of the flood protection project Raababach in Gössendorf, Styria, EGU General Assembly 2023, Vienna, Austria, 23–28 Apr 2023, EGU23-15154, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu23-15154, 2023.

X4.44
|
EGU23-15807
|
ECS
|
Highlight
Alessandro Fraccica, Barbara Dessì, Pier Luigi Gallozzi, and Irene Rischia

Hydrogeological risk is a relevant issue in Italy, given its yearly and elevated socio-economic impacts in the country, including loss of lives in case of serious hazards. In the consistent case history of measures for hydrogeological risk mitigation ISPRA has developed the National Repository of hydrogeological risk mitigation measures (ReNDiS http://www.rendis.isprambiente.it/) which is a platform for monitoring measures funded by the Italian Ministry of the Environment and Energy Security (MASE) from 1999 onwards which also aims to managing the evaluation of funding requests coming from Regions.

The ReNDiS project aims at implementing a database, collecting updated information about mitigation measures such as engineering works as well as non- structural measures. Inside the ReNDiS DB, information is organized by single “mitigation works” meaning that for every measure each stage from the financing action to design, work and accounting data are collected and stored. In order to manage heterogeneous data collected for each intervention, the choice of essential information has been restricted to: governmental funding measure, funding amount, local beneficiary authority, affected municipality, title of intervention and location. Other important information regards: geological and hydraulic characterization of the phenomenon, risk mitigation measures adopted, economic accounting for design, works and management, as well as up to date information on the actual progress stage of the intervention.

Among this information, the typology of the works and of the natural hazard to be mitigated are indicated too. From the beginning of the monitoring, in 1999, around 12 thousand measures have been already recorded in the database, amounting to over EUR 29 billion of funds. Among these entries, the 60.8% are related to landslide risk mitigation and the 36.8% to hydraulic risk mitigation, while the remaining ones are related to other risks (Figure 1).

Considering each class of natural hazard, it was observed that measures implementing nature-based solutions are the 17%, the 11.8% and the 28.8% of the total number, within the landslide, hydraulic and other risks mitigation, respectively (Figure 2).

Within the measures on landslide risk mitigation, the NBS works adopted are represented in Figure 3. The highest number of these works mainly involve vegetation cutting, selective deforestation and planting, and structures made by biodegradable materials such as wood (edging, palisades, gutters), bio-mats, bio-nets and bio-felt. Among the measures on hydraulic risk mitigation (Figure 4), the most-used NBS implemented vegetation and the use of timber and stones in structures for water regulation measures. In both cases, a good variability of measure typologies was observed.

The analysis showed that measures implementing NBSs are a conspicuous number, compared to the total, also considering their use often as a complement to more 'traditional' engineering works. 

Within the hydraulic risk mitigation measures, the use of greened weirs and stone and timber materials was preferred. In this case, the erosive forces involved and the frequent need for water regulation implied the choice of more structural materials and measures.

How to cite: Fraccica, A., Dessì, B., Gallozzi, P. L., and Rischia, I.: The use of nature-based solutions for hydrogeological risks mitigation in Italy: insights from ReNDiS, the monitoring database of the Italian Institute for Environmental Protection and Research (ISPRA), EGU General Assembly 2023, Vienna, Austria, 23–28 Apr 2023, EGU23-15807, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu23-15807, 2023.

Posters virtual: Fri, 28 Apr, 16:15–18:00 | vHall NH

Chairpersons: Grainne El Mountassir, Gerrit Meijer, Anil Yildiz
Laboratory studies
vNH.9
|
EGU23-2995
|
ECS
Zhenliang Jiang, Anthony Leung, and Jianbin Liu

Segmentation of X-ray computed tomography (CT) images of four-phase unsaturated rooted soils is challenging yet a crucial step for conducting the subsequent image-based analysis (IBA) for various properties, for instance, volume fraction of each phase, morphologies of pore and roots, pore fluid distributions and some engineering properties such as hydraulic conductivity. The accuracy and efficiency of phase segmentation have been widely investigated, but the segmentation uncertainty (SU), which is a measure of reproductivity or reliability, on IBA and how the uncertainty propagates at different stages of IBA have rarely been studied for rooted soils. In this study, we developed a machine learning (ML)-based technique, called the percentile-based segmentation method, to perform phase segmentation of CT images and quantify the uncertainty and propagation of phase segmentation at different stages of IBA. Two indicators were used: relative value (RE), which has been used in the literature and SU magnification factor (SU-MF), which is newly proposed in this study. X-ray CT images of soil samples with different particle sizes and cultivated with different plant species were taken by a micro-X-ray CT scanner. The images were then segmented using the proposed ML method. In the presentation, a detailed case study and sensitive analysis (e.g., different number of phases, plant species, sampling resolution, and simulation methods) will be presented. We will show that root volume is susceptible to SU yet has a marginal influence on CT-IBA as its fraction is relatively small compared to other phases. However, the volume of soil grains is less SU-sensitive, which could lead to a significant change in the IBA. Root architectures could substantially influence the SU. Increasing the segmentation percentile improves the reliability, but the accuracy reduces at the same time. Moreover, we will show that the newly proposed indicator, SU-MF, can reasonably reflect the SU propagation behaviour. Therefore, SU could significantly impact the CT-IBA of rooted soils, and SU propagation is phase- and parameter-dependent. The explored quantification and propagation of SU provide novel and practical perspectives for increasing the measurement reliability of the X-ray CT-IBA of rooted soils.

How to cite: Jiang, Z., Leung, A., and Liu, J.: Machine learning-enabled quantification of segmentation uncertainty of X-Ray CT image-based analysis for vegetated soils, EGU General Assembly 2023, Vienna, Austria, 23–28 Apr 2023, EGU23-2995, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu23-2995, 2023.

vNH.10
|
EGU23-4632
|
ECS
Ali Akbar Karimzadeh and Anthony Kwan Leung

Plant roots are generally known to increase soil shear strength because of mechanical root reinforcement. Because of the anisotropic root distribution in soil, the shear strength of rooted soils is stress path-dependent, which is crucial to the engineering analysis and design of the stability of vegetated soil slopes. Existing failure criteria of rooted soils, which were mostly established based on direct-shear test results, were unable to account for the strength anisotropy of rooted soils under general loading conditions. In this presentation, we will propose and derive a new generalised 3-D anisotropic failure criterion for rooted soils. The anisotropic effects of root network and soil fabric on the shear strength of rooted soils upon various effective stress paths was captured by employing of the projection of the microstructure fabric tensors of soil and root network on stress tensors. To verify the proposed model, we will present the test results of drained compression and extension triaxial tests of saturated soil samples cultivated with deep-rooted vetiver grass (Chrysopogon zizanioides L.) under different over consolidation ratios (OCR; i.e., 1 and 3) and effective confining pressures (i.e., 50, 100 and 150 kPa). We discovered that upon compression stress path, the presence of roots increased the contractive behaviour of soil in normal consolidated samples, whereas the rooted soils were more dilative than bare soil in over consolidated samples. The presence of roots increased dilative behaviour of rooted soil following extension, irrespective to OCRs, because majority of the vetiver roots were grown vertically in a direction perpendicular to that of the major principal stress, resulting in greater mobilisation of the root tensile strength. Based on the calibrated model, we showed the anisotropies of both the cohesion and friction angle of the rooted soils. We also demonstrated why most of the studies that used the direct shear apparatus as a means of testing reported that roots affected almost exclusively the cohesion but not the friction angle. Indeed, the stress paths that direct shear followed are within section I of the deviatoric plane, where the effects of soil anisotropy on friction angle are not significant.

How to cite: Karimzadeh, A. A. and Leung, A. K.: A generalised failure criterion for rooted soils, EGU General Assembly 2023, Vienna, Austria, 23–28 Apr 2023, EGU23-4632, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu23-4632, 2023.

vNH.11
|
EGU23-6078
|
ECS
Jun Zhu and Anthony Kwan Leung

Abstract: Vegetation improves slope stability through mechanical root reinforcement and root anchorage. As shallow soil slides, plant roots extending beneath a potential shear band would be subjected to either bending or tension, depending on the root orientation with respect to the direction of shearing. The roots thus provide anchorage to stabilise the soil by mobilising the root–soil interfacial properties and the root tensile or/and bending strength until the roots are broken (i.e. breakage failure) or pulled out from the soil (i.e. pull-out failure). Modelling such a complex root–soil interaction mechanism is challenging. In existing modelling techniques of root–soil interaction, the mechanical behaviour of plant roots has been modelled by solid element or embedded beam element (EBE). The former is computationally expensive (thus being rarely and hardly used to model complex root architecture systems with multi-order root components), whereas the latter assumes unrealistic rigid root–soil bonding and thus is unable to capture the root pull–out failure mode (thus typically overestimating the root reinforcement). In this study, a newly modified EBE was derived by incorporating the effects of interfacial shearing and virtually permitting roots to be failed by the pull-out mode, in addition to breakage. The performance of the modified EBE was validated against three selected case studies, and the validated model was then used for subsequent parametric analysis on the effects of root morphology on the uprooting behaviour. Our simulation results show that the root systems whose morphology and branching pattern could gain more interfacial shear resistance (e.g., oblique second-order laterals in contrast to the horizontal case) and mobilise more root internal stresses (e.g., deeper branching point between first- and second-order roots) had higher uprooting resistance. Horizontal laterals mainly mobilised their bending strength to resist the uplift, but the oblique ones mobilised more tensile strength as their orientation was more aligned with the direction of the uplift.

How to cite: Zhu, J. and Leung, A. K.: A modified embedded beam element to improve the modelling of root–soil interfacial behaviour, EGU General Assembly 2023, Vienna, Austria, 23–28 Apr 2023, EGU23-6078, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu23-6078, 2023.

vNH.12
|
EGU23-12075
Grainne El Mountassir, Emmanuel Salifu, Alireza Fathollahi, Qi Zhang, and Alexandra Schellenger

Current research at the university of Strathclyde is investigating the potential for basidiomycota fungi to be deployed as a nature-based technique to improve the stability of soil slopes. Basidiomycota are filamentous fungi which grow in the form of hyphae as they forage for nutrients in their surrounding environment. Hyphae are tubular structures with diameters between 2-7μm. Hyphae branch out and can anastomose forming a complex network, called the mycelium. Mycelial networks have attractive characteristics for use in ground engineering: evidence from natural analogues indicates that they can form massive, durable mycelia and they are resilient; dynamically responding to the environment and to damage/disruption.

A comprehensive experimental campaign has been conducted investigating the influence of the growth of basidiomycota fungi on soil behaviour including: assessment of liquid-solid contact angles, evaluation of water infiltration via instrumented columns, evaluation of saturated permeability and determination of soil water retention behaviour. Mechanical testing has included direct shear testing and jet-erosion testing. Our research shows that the growth of mycelial networks can influence the hydraulic and mechanical behaviour of soils via a number of different mechanisms including: (1) altering soil water repellency and infilling of pore space leading to reduced water infiltration and reduced permeability and (2) binding of soil particles via physical enmeshment within mycelial networks leading to enhanced soil cohesion and improved resistance to water-induced erosion. Furthermore, our results show that different fungal species can exhibit differences in growth behaviour and thus produce soil-mycelial systems with varying architecture which impacts upon the resulting soil behaviour. In summary, basidiomycetes show promise for enhancing slope stability by reducing water infiltration during heavy rainfall events, enhancing soil cohesion and improving soil resistance to erosion.

How to cite: El Mountassir, G., Salifu, E., Fathollahi, A., Zhang, Q., and Schellenger, A.: Exploring the mechanisms through which basidiomycota fungi may influence slope stability, EGU General Assembly 2023, Vienna, Austria, 23–28 Apr 2023, EGU23-12075, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu23-12075, 2023.

Case studies - slope stability
vNH.13
|
EGU23-3154
|
ECS
|
Klaus Peklo

Our motivation is to explain how severe bank slides, such as those following natural disasters, can be sustainably reintegrated into the river ecosystem in a modern, contemporary manner through the application of NbS and combined techniques. Our purpose is to explain the needs of an integrated engineering approach to find out the causes of streambank slides before works start. We point out the workflow of NbS reconstruction process by determining an efficient analysing stage, a construction stage and a monitoring stage. We show three realized examples of steep bank reintegration situated in high flow regime. Our conclusions show that reintegration into the river landscape of violent bank slides near residential areas and infrastructure with NbS techniques is feasible. The prerequisites, however, are a sufficient root cause analysis by an integrated engineering approach, and good training and experience of the hired construction companies during construction stage. In addition, clients need to throw out some of their old ideas of exclusively mineral and similar attachment techniques. This presentation serves as a demonstration of the potential of sustainable NbS steep bank revegetation for infrastructure protection, based on geotechnical analysis using examples since 1999.

How to cite: Peklo, K.: NbS and combined techniques - Case studies of steep bank stabilizations in the Garonne water catchment area in France, EGU General Assembly 2023, Vienna, Austria, 23–28 Apr 2023, EGU23-3154, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu23-3154, 2023.

vNH.14
|
EGU23-14749
|
ECS
Han Bao, Changqing Liu, and Changgen Yan

Ecological materials are increasingly being applied in the loess slope protection, and the time-dependency deterioration of materials is an important criterion in evaluating their protective effects. Taking polypropylene fiber and guar gum as examples, the protection tests of these two ecological materials were carried out for a typical bare cut-slope on the Loess Plateau in this study. We quantified the erosion deterioration based on the approach of LiDAR, and the deterioration processes of both the ecological materials were then comprehensively evaluated. Results showed that both the materials could generate good protective effects on the test slopes, and the guar gum mixed soil (GGS) was slightly better than polypropylene fiber reinforced soil (PFS) at initial time. However, the two materials deteriorated diversely with the increasing service time. The scouring erosion was mainly observed in PFS, which is different to the surface spalling observed in GGS, and the erosion mass presented different stepwise growth along the slope downward. In addition, the protective advantage of GGS was decreasing and even disappearing over time. Revealed by the dry-wet cycle tests, the rapid attenuation of disintegration resistance of PFS and shear strength parameters of GGS were the main reasons leading to the different deterioration of the two materials. For evaluating deterioration behavior of slope protection materials, the time-dependency deterioration model was furthermore established by combining the average intensity of effective rainfall as well as the disintegration rate and shear strength parameters of slope protection materials. Thus, the quantitative prediction on the deterioration process and the protective effect of slope protection materials were realized, with results indicating that the influences of disintegration rate, cohesion, and internal friction angel enhanced successively on the promotion of slope protection materials. This study is of great significance for revealing the deterioration mechanism and promoting continuous improvement of slope protection materials.

How to cite: Bao, H., Liu, C., and Yan, C.: Long-term in situ scientific experiment: Demonstrating the slope protection effects of loess ecological materials, EGU General Assembly 2023, Vienna, Austria, 23–28 Apr 2023, EGU23-14749, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu23-14749, 2023.