TS4.2 | Deciphering tectonic evolution, exhumation and weathering: advancements in thermochronology and interdisciplinary approaches
EDI
Deciphering tectonic evolution, exhumation and weathering: advancements in thermochronology and interdisciplinary approaches
Co-organized by GM8
Convener: Alejandro PiraquiveECSECS | Co-conveners: Marie GengeECSECS, Maxime BernardECSECS, Kristian Drivenes, Lingxiao GongECSECS, Jon Engström, Marek Szczerba
Orals
| Mon, 15 Apr, 08:30–10:10 (CEST)
 
Room D1
Posters on site
| Attendance Mon, 15 Apr, 16:15–18:00 (CEST) | Display Mon, 15 Apr, 14:00–18:00
 
Hall X2
Orals |
Mon, 08:30
Mon, 16:15
Earth's landscape evolution is shaped by the dynamic interplay of tectonics, climate, and surface processes, with added complexity due to differences between cratonic and orogenic lithospheres. Additionally, the properties of the crystalline basement are greatly affected by fault activity, hydrothermal alteration, and long-term exposure to superficial conditions.
Thermochronology is essential for understanding thermal evolution and paleogeography by quantifying cooling, exhumation, and weathering trends in various crustal environments. Recent developments in thermochronology, including 40Ar/39Ar, fission tracks, Raman dating, (U-Th)/He, 4He/3He, trapped charge systems, as well as complementary isotopic methods like K-Ar dating of clay weathering products and U-Pb carbonate dating, have provided additional constraints. Computational tools and remote sensing methods further contribute to this interdisciplinary approach. While this integrated approach enables the development of robust tectonic and landscape-evolution models, these advancements also underscore the existing limitations in our understanding of these systems and their quantification, emphasizing the need for thorough comprehension.
We invite contributions that: (1) present theoretical and experimental work establishing new thermochronometers, developing novel quantification and modeling approaches, or enhancing our understanding of current systems' abilities and limitations for reliable geological interpretation; and (2) address bedrock deep-time evolution, elucidate the timing and rates of processes shaping Earth's surface (e.g., burial/exhumation, faulting, hydrothermalism, weathering), and the interplay of cooling, exhumation, and alteration events using interdisciplinary approaches such as thermochronology, geochronology, geomorphology, tectonics, geochemistry, and mineralogy.

Orals: Mon, 15 Apr | Room D1

Chairpersons: Alejandro Piraquive, Marie Genge, Marek Szczerba
08:30–08:40
|
EGU24-8170
|
On-site presentation
Vincent Regard, Sébastien Carretier, Moquet Jean-Sébastien, Sandrine Choy, Pierre-Henri Blard, Sakaros Bogning, Auguste Paulin Mbonda, Emmanuel Mambela, Marie Claire Paiz, Michel Séranne, Julien Charreau, Delphine Rouby, Julien Bouchez, Jérôme Gaillardet, and Jean-Jacques Braun

We measured the long term physical denudation of the Ogooué River catchment using 10Be. These measurements are averaged over 25-200 ka (average 40 ka), depending on the physical denudation rate. The denudation rate of the Ogooué River catchment is slow (38 t/km2/a, 15 m/Ma), slightly higher than the Equatorial West Africa (from Senegal to Angola, 26 t/km2/a, 10 m/Ma). Physical denudation and chemical weathering fall within the same order of magnitude. Thus, although low, chemical weathering, is substantial compared to physical denudation, its contribution is likely over 30% of the total denudation.

Denudation rates are spatially variable (from 10 to 60 t/km2/a) within this large Ogooué River catchment. Over the long term, this variability exhibits a fairly close match of physical denudation/chemical weathering, except in the Batéké Plateaux area, because they are made up of already weathered detrital material and their modern flux of solutes is therefore very low (~9.5 t/km2/a). The spatial distribution is similar to the one described in Moquet et al. (2021)'s work, i.e. the southern part of the catchment is denuding twice as fast as the northern part. We show here that the whole picture did not vary much since 100 ka, as shown by both methods giving consistent results. Faster denudation in the south of the catchment may be related to some more uplift than in the north caused by the south African superswell.

 

How to cite: Regard, V., Carretier, S., Jean-Sébastien, M., Choy, S., Blard, P.-H., Bogning, S., Mbonda, A. P., Mambela, E., Paiz, M. C., Séranne, M., Charreau, J., Rouby, D., Bouchez, J., Gaillardet, J., and Braun, J.-J.: Physical erosion rates in Ogooué and Mbei Rivers (Gabon, Western Central Africa): insights for Cratonic Catchments., EGU General Assembly 2024, Vienna, Austria, 14–19 Apr 2024, EGU24-8170, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu24-8170, 2024.

08:40–08:50
|
EGU24-17264
|
ECS
|
On-site presentation
Joffrey Bertaz, Pascale Huyghe, Christian France-Lanord, Albert Galy, Mara Limonta, and Aswin Tachambalath

The Ganga-Brahmaputra river system transports up to 600 million tons of sediment annually from the Himalayan range to the Bengal Fan. The catchment of the Ganga-Brahmaputra river system is characterized by highly contrasting lithologies and exhumation rates which strongly influence erosion and chemical weathering processes. Recent studies have emphasized the importance and role of floodplains for the chemical weathering of sediments eroded from Himalayan mountains. Changes in sediment chemical weathering are controlled by climatic changes, such as variations in Indian summer monsoon precipitation and glacial interglacial cycles. However, further exploration is needed to understand the impact of anthropic changes and long-term climatic and tectonic forcings on the chemical weathering regime of the Ganga-Brahmaputra system. We present the bulk and clay mineralogy, obtained with XRD, of turbiditic sediments collected from the Bengal Fan in the Indian Ocean during the IODP Expedition 354. The clay mineralogical assemblages of IODP Expedition 354 present a dominance of illite and chlorite throughout the record with a relative increase of smectite and kaolinite content during the Miocene. Such clay mineralogy is consistent with the clay mineralogy of sediments from Leg 22 site 218 from DSDP (which was reoccupied for  IODP Expedition 354). Miocene bulk sediments are relatively enriched in smectite, kaolinite, goethite, and terrigenous carbonates (calcite and dolomite). Therefore, our mineralogy results are showing a change in chemical weathering regime affecting the Himalaya system between the Miocene and Quaternary.  The Quaternary is characterized by a lower content of smectite, kaolinite and carbonates, the presence of amphiboles and an enrichment in micaceous minerals (muscovite/illite, biotite, chlorite) and plagioclases as also inferred from Raman spectroscopy (Limonta et al., 2023). This indicates that during the Miocene the chemical weathering of ferro-magnesian minerals and calco-sodic feldspars was more efficient as shown by geochemical data (Tachambalath, 2023). The decrease in chemical weathering intensity from Late Miocene is consistent with the concurrent Late Cenozoic global cooling and drying of Himalayan front associated with the decrease in Indian monsoon seasonality and/or precipitation after 10-8 Ma (Clift and Webb, 2019). Here, we show that the change in the Indian monsoon system from 10-8 Ma is marked in the Bengal Fan turbiditic sediments mineralogy.

How to cite: Bertaz, J., Huyghe, P., France-Lanord, C., Galy, A., Limonta, M., and Tachambalath, A.: Chemical weathering processes of Himalaya-river systems since Miocene recorded by bulk and clay mineralogy of deep-sea sediments from IODP Expedition 354  , EGU General Assembly 2024, Vienna, Austria, 14–19 Apr 2024, EGU24-17264, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu24-17264, 2024.

08:50–09:00
|
EGU24-14281
|
On-site presentation
Sabin Zahirovic, Tom Schmaltz, Addison Tu, Rafael Pinto Cherene Viana, Kevin Hao, Jonathon Leonard, Claire Mallard, and Tristan Salles

Collisional settings that terminate subduction are most often associated with orogenesis, and in many cases are also associated with the obduction of oceanic crust into the suture zone. These events are key components of the planetary carbon cycle, where the subduction-related volcanic outgassing is generally shut down, and instead dominated by processes of erosion and silicate weathering and carbon dioxide drawdown. This is particularly intense where silicate rocks are being exhumed, and especially where fresh ophiolitic crust is exposed, to intense weathering in the near-equatorial humid belts.

Here we use a new compilation of Phanerozoic orogens and ophiolites in a (py)GPlates workflow to analyse the distribution of these orogenic and obduction events in time and space. We test different tectonic reference frames, as well as explore different assumptions of the distribution of the near-equatorial humid belt through time. We compare our datasets and analysis with previously published models, and link the time series to the COPSE biogeochemical cycling model. In addition, we evaluate the implications of erosion and weathering from recent global landscape evolution models to explore the role of the near-equatorial humid belt precipitation and mountain areas.

The analysis suggests that large areas of mountains resided in the near-equatorial regions in the late Cambrian to Ordovician, late Carboniferous, the Cretaceous, and in the Neogene. One obvious challenge that emerges is the need to designate actively-uplifting versus inactive orogens, as the paleogeographic reconstructions do not yet discriminate between these categories. However, using our (py)GPlates workflows and other geological data (such as magmatic zircons), we can use the plate tectonic reconstructions to infer which orogens are proximal to plate boundaries and more likely to be actively uplifting, in contrast to mountains that are passively being denuded.

Although this approach sees an improvement to the constraints on the areas of elevated crust for the use in biogeochemical cycling, it remains challenging to infer the paleo-altimetry of these orogens in deep time. In addition, other geological time series inputs require further work (e.g., volcanic and orogenic/metamorphic degassing). Ongoing work is quantifying self-consistent tectonic parameters that can be incorporated into the biogeochemical cycling models to help improve the constraints on these models. More broadly, this approach provides a pathway towards more robust and geologically-constrained Earth Systems Models that have implications for our understanding of paleo-climate and carbon cycling in deep time.

How to cite: Zahirovic, S., Schmaltz, T., Tu, A., Pinto Cherene Viana, R., Hao, K., Leonard, J., Mallard, C., and Salles, T.: Silicate weathering estimates from paleogeographic and biogeochemical cycling models of orogens and ophiolite obduction during the Phanerozoic, EGU General Assembly 2024, Vienna, Austria, 14–19 Apr 2024, EGU24-14281, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu24-14281, 2024.

09:00–09:10
|
EGU24-7700
|
On-site presentation
Nicklas Nordbäck, Pietari Skyttä, and Nikolas Ovaskainen

The bedrock of Central Fennoscandia has been shaped by a long and complex geological history involving ductile deformation and metamorphism which dates back at least to the 1.9–1.8 Ga Svecofennian orogeny. Subsequent geological processes including Precambrian brittle faulting and fracturing, younger fault reactivations and several stages of hydrothermal activity and alteration processes, provided further contribution to defining the present-day bedrock structure and mechanical properties. Eventually, extensive glaciation affected the exposed upper part of the bedrock through structurally selective erosion, which is largely responsible for the morphology of the bedrock erosion surface. As such, the brittle tectonic history, involving faulting and fracturing near the Earth’s surface, has played a significant role in shaping the current bedrock topography. However, also the preceding ductile structures played a role as they caused the localisation of the brittle deformation through the process of structural inheritance.

Based on previously published results the brittle tectonic development within Central Fennoscandia initiated in response to N–S compression at around 1.75 Ga. Based on our new datasets, consisting of isotopically dated fault gouge samples and brittle structural observations (Nordbäck et al., 2022), N–S extension at around 1.65 Ga and a E–W extension at around 1.6 Ga were associated with 1) reactivations of previously formed major structures of the bedrock, 2) rapakivi magmatism and 3) the development of a (failed) continental rift between Finland and Sweden. Our structural data from within the 1.58 Ga rapakivi granites indicate that strike-slip tectonics prevailed during Mesoproterozoic times. According to isotopic and structural data from Olkiluoto in southwestern Finland, thrust faults were generated in response to E–W compression during the Sveconorwegian orogeny between 1.1–1.0 Ga. The younger stress changes that induced faulting activity, have been found to cause merely reactivations of the fault systems that were formed already by late Mesoproterozoic times. Based on our structural datasets from the 1.58 Ga rapakivi granites, paleostress analysis and observed relative age relationships between faults and joints, Neoproterozoic exhumation of the bedrock appears to have resulted in extensional bedrock stresses and the development of Precambrian bedrock joints.        

Erosional processes during the Quaternay glaciations interacted strongly with the existing brittle structures which were preferably eroded during the glacial advances and retreats. Especially the intensely fractured major fault zones greatly impacted the current bedrock morphology while smaller structures, such as individual joints or shear fractures, only have a local impact (Skyttä et al., 2023).

References:

Nordbäck, N., Mattila, J., Zwingmann, H., Viola, G., 2022. Precambrian fault reactivation revealed by structural and K-Ar geochronological data from the spent nuclear fuel repository in Olkiluoto, southwestern Finland. Tectonophysics 824, 229208. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.tecto.2022.229208

Skyttä, P., Nordbäck, N., Ojala, A., Putkinen, N., Aaltonen, I., Engström, J., Mattila, J., Ovaskainen, N., 2023. The interplay of bedrock fractures and glacial erosion in defining the present-day land surface topography in mesoscopically isotropic crystalline rocks. Earth Surface Processes and Landforms. https://doi.org/10.1002/esp.5596

How to cite: Nordbäck, N., Skyttä, P., and Ovaskainen, N.: The relationship between brittle tectonics and bedrock morphology of Central Fennoscandia, EGU General Assembly 2024, Vienna, Austria, 14–19 Apr 2024, EGU24-7700, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu24-7700, 2024.

09:10–09:20
|
EGU24-4676
|
solicited
|
On-site presentation
Giulio Viola

Understanding how the interplay between tectonics, climate, and surface processes reflects the Earth’s endo- and exogenic dynamic behaviour, inevitably requires studying the nucleation, growth and development of faults. Faults shape the plumbing system of the Earth’s crust, promoting mass and heat transfer and steering fluid migration, storage and mineralizations. They control landscape evolution and impact society because, although they only occupy a small volume of the crust, they govern its modes of deformation by localizing earthquake slip, thus being sources of seismic hazard. To improve our understanding of faulting and produce time-constrained models firmly based on physical and chemical constraints, a deep knowledge of the structural, mechanical, hydrogeological and petrophysical properties of faults is thus required.

Long-lived, multiply reactivated faults can be architecturally complex, with every new deformation episode adding to this complexity by forming new brittle structural facies, altering the bulk and local permeability and steering the rheology of the deforming rock volume. This complicates the interpretation of the brittle archive of fault zones, which impacts on the interpretation of the local and regional deformation history. It also impacts on the seismogenic style associated with faulting (with coseismic rupturing and aseismic creep variably occurring in time and space), on modes of fluid ingress and circulation and formation of geofluid reservoirs. Recent studies have documented that this complexity is the norm rather than the exception and that it may result from deformation histories lasting many millions of years. The outcrops we study, therefore, only represent snapshots of this long history and rushed interpretations of their complexity and/or its downplaying may be grossly misleading.

To better understand the architecturally complex geometry and evolution in time and space of mature fault zones, the methodological approach to- and the first results from an ongoing study of the Carboneras Fault (CF) in the Betic Cordilleras of Spain are discussed. The CF is a NE-SW striking, 100 km long, upper crustal sinistral strike-slip fault that is described as accommodating c. 40 km offset with still ongoing distributed seismicity. It exhibits a complex architecture defined by strands of phyllosilicate-rich fault gouge enveloping domains of variably reworked host rock. Up to 14 brittle structural facies have been identified at four key outcrops. Structural analysis, X-ray diffraction and isotopic analysis of fault rocks have been systematically carried out. Sampling of each facies made it possible to define their mineralogical composition, the maximum temperature they were subjected to during faulting, their isotopic signature and the deformation mechanisms responsible for their formation. In-situ outcrop air-permeametry helped constrain the present-day permeability and its heterogeneity at the scale of the fault zone. K-Ar illite dating of eight gouge samples shows that faulting has been ongoing for >20 Myrs, and provides a comprehensive timeline for deformation localization down to the microscopic scale. Results from this high-resolution approach offer a comprehensive work protocol to untangle the spatiotemporal evolution of long-lived mature fault zones elsewhere.

How to cite: Viola, G.: High-resolution multidisciplinary studies of fault zone architecture: Insights into deformation histories, fault mechanics, fluid circulation, weathering and…, EGU General Assembly 2024, Vienna, Austria, 14–19 Apr 2024, EGU24-4676, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu24-4676, 2024.

09:20–09:30
|
EGU24-16717
|
ECS
|
On-site presentation
Alina Lucia Ludat, Anke M. Friedrich, Florian Hofmann, Robert Bolhar, and Torsten Hahn

Deformation in the Earth’s upper crust is typically accommodated by faults, which can range from microscopic displacements to regional tectonic features. Despite being located in the continental interior of the Eurasian plate, Central Europe displays notable evidence for recent activity, including active faulting, even along fault lines previously presumed inactive. This intraplate region has experienced multiple phases of fault reactivation, which provide the basis for debate regarding the underlying causative deformation mechanisms and driving forces. Determining the timing of episodic fault activity and their deformation rates is crucial to investigating the mechanisms behind Cretaceous to Paleocene exhumation and its relationship to more recent fault activity.

An excellent region for this purpose is the Bohemian Massif, which is characterized by a complex structural and lithological architecture recording a long history of deformation. This area hosts significant fault zones, such as the NW–SE-striking Pfahl and Danube faults. Despite being one of the largest faults in Central Europe with a prominent scarp and young morphology, the ages of inception and reactivation of the Danube fault remain poorly constrained. Furthermore, therefore, seismic risks associated with these significant intraplate faults are difficult to include in earthquake hazard catalogs.

To determine the timing of fault-slip and re-activation of the intracontinental Danube fault system in the Bavarian forest, we designed a sampling strategy involving multiple radiometric geochronometers and judiciously sampled transects across minor faults exposed in numerous quarries. We are currently dating authigenic and synkinematically recrystallized minerals, including U-Pb dating of slickenfiber calcite and K-Ar dating of illite. We also employ 40Ar/39Ar thermochronology and multi-domain diffusion modeling of potassium-bearing minerals of the granitoid host rocks to determine the timing of exhumation and re-setting of this system due to fault activity.

The earliest time constraint for the initiation of the Danube fault was established by using published U-Pb zircon ages of deformed granites (310 to 342 Ma) (Klein et al. 2008 Lithos 102). We anticipate the K–Ar ages of illite and U–Pb ages of calcite to be significantly younger, which would confirm potential phases of reactivation accompanied by fluid alteration during cataclastic deformation. These fluid-infiltration events could potentially serve as markers for dating various phases of fault reactivation, which, along with information from frictional resetting, offer insights into the dynamic evolution of the Danube fault over time.

How to cite: Ludat, A. L., Friedrich, A. M., Hofmann, F., Bolhar, R., and Hahn, T.: Unravelling the Tectonic History of an Intraplate Region: A Geochronological Study of the Danube Fault, Bavarian Forest, Germany, EGU General Assembly 2024, Vienna, Austria, 14–19 Apr 2024, EGU24-16717, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu24-16717, 2024.

09:30–09:40
|
EGU24-1495
|
On-site presentation
Kyra Hölzer, Reinhard Wolff, Ralf Hetzel, and István Dunkl

The Eastern European Alps formed during two orogenic cycles, which took place in the Cretaceous and Cenozoic, respectively. In the Ötztal-Stubai Complex – a thrust sheet of Variscan basement and Permo-Mesozoic cover rocks – the record of the first (Eoalpine) orogeny is well preserved, because during the second (Alpine) orogeny the complex remained largely undeformed. We use new zircon (U-Th)/He (ZHe) ages and thermo-kinematic modeling to constrain the cooling and exhumation history of the central part of the Ötztal-Stubai Complex since the Late Cretaceous. The ZHe ages from two elevation profiles increase over a vertical distance of 1500 m from 56±3 to 69±3 Ma (Stubaital) and from 50±2 to 71±4 Ma (Kaunertal), respectively (Hölzer et al., accepted by Lithosphere). These ZHe ages and few published zircon and apatite fission track ages were used for inverse thermo-kinematic modeling. The modeling results show that the age data are well reproduced with a three-phase exhumation history. A first phase with relatively fast exhumation (~250 m/Myr) during the Late Cretaceous ended at ~70 Ma and is interpreted to reflect the erosion of the Eoalpine mountain belt. As Late Cretaceous normal faults occur at the margins of the Ötztal-Stubai Complex, normal faulting may have also contributed to the exhumation of the study area. Subsequently, a long period with slow exhumation (<10 m/Myr) prevailed until ~16 Ma. This long-lasting phase of slow exhumation suggests a rather low topography with little relief in the Ötztal-Stubai Complex until the mid-Miocene, even though the Alpine orogeny had already begun in the Eocene with the subduction of the European continental margin. Accelerated exhumation since the mid-Miocene (~230 m/Myr) is interpreted to reflect the erosion of the mountain belt, due to the development of high topography in front of the Adriatic indenter and repeated glaciations during the Quaternary.

How to cite: Hölzer, K., Wolff, R., Hetzel, R., and Dunkl, I.: The long-lasting exhumation history of the Ötztal-Stubai Complex (Eastern European Alps): New constraints from zircon (U-Th)/He age-elevation profiles and thermo-kinematic modeling, EGU General Assembly 2024, Vienna, Austria, 14–19 Apr 2024, EGU24-1495, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu24-1495, 2024.

09:40–09:50
|
EGU24-9333
|
ECS
|
On-site presentation
Fanfan Zhao and Junping Cui

The distribution of oil and gas resources in the Upper Paleozoic of the Ordos basin is extensive, with well-developed source rocks. However, there is currently a lack of systematic research on source rocks in the Wuqi area, which greatly limits the oil and gas exploration work in this area. This study aims to restore the burial and thermal evolution history of the region, clarify the accumulation periods of source rocks, and promote the fine exploration and development process of oil and gas. It provides a basis for understanding and improving the oil and gas accumulation laws of the Upper Paleozoic in the entire basin. Research suggests that the Wuqi area has undergone four periods of erosion since the Upper Paleozoic, including the end of the Triassic, middle Jurassic, end of the Jurassic, and end of the Cretaceous. The first three periods of erosion were relatively small, mainly distributed between 100-200m, and the end of the Cretaceous period was characterized by significant erosion, which was the main erosion event. The interval transit time method was used to recover the erosion thickness at the end of the Cretaceous period in this study, mainly distributed in the range of 600-1500 m, and the overall erosion amount gradually decreased from east to west. We used vitrinite reflectance to restore palaeogeotherm and PetroMod software combined with parameters such as stratigraphy, lithology, erosion thickness, and boundary condition to reconstruct the burial history and thermal evolution history of the Wuqi area by basin simulation methods. Microscopic observation and combined with fluid inclusion homogenization temperature data were used to further determine the oil and gas accumulation period through a combination of forward and reverse analysis. According to the inclusions and homogenization temperature, it is reflected that there are mainly early and late inclusions in the Upper Paleozoic mudstone in the Wuqi area. Early fluid inclusions are mainly distributed on the secondary enlargement edge of quartz, with temperatures mainly ranging from 110 to 140 ℃; The late stage fluid inclusions are mainly distributed in quartz particle fractures, with temperatures mainly ranging from 100 to 160 ℃, which is the main charging period. The temperature distribution of the two phases of inclusions is continuous process. In conclusion, there were two consecutive oil and gas changes in the Upper Paleozoic in the Wuqi area of the Ordos basin: the first oil and gas charging period was in the Middle Jurassic; The second oil and gas charging period was in the Early Cretaceous.

How to cite: Zhao, F. and Cui, J.: Analysis of Thermal Evolution History of Source Rocks and Natural Gas Accumulation Periods of Upper Paleozoic in the Wuqi Area of the Ordos Basin,China, EGU General Assembly 2024, Vienna, Austria, 14–19 Apr 2024, EGU24-9333, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu24-9333, 2024.

09:50–10:00
|
EGU24-4635
|
ECS
|
On-site presentation
Jianzhang Pang, Dewen Zheng, and Yan Ma

The Qilian Shan, located at the northeastern edge of the Tibetan Plateau, plays a crucial role in understanding the Plateau's uplift and expansion processes. There are two classical models, one proposes a progressive expansion of the thickened crust, while the other suggest that the northern extent of the Plateau was established soon after the collision between India and Eurasia around 50 Ma ago. Nevertheless, a recent study introduces a more complex scenario, proposing a pulsed uplift of the northern Tibetan Plateau starting around 30 Ma (Wang et al., 2022). These models heavily rely on the spatial and temporal evolution of the Qilian Shan. Nevertheless, the exact timing and mechanisms of its evolution remain elusive.

To delve into the growth history of the southern Qilian Shan, we have obtained apatite fission track data from the Dachaidan Shan and the northern Qaidam basin. Notably, AFT ages from the Dachaidan Shan transect (ranging from 35 Ma to 10 Ma) vary significantly with elevation. An intriguing observation is a possible break in slope at 18±2 Ma, which is interpreted as indicating the onset of intense exhumation in the southern Qilian Shan. Furthermore, within the Qaidam basin, a total reset AFT age group of 14.8±3.8 Ma was found in Jurassic strata but not in Cretaceous and Cenozoic strata. This suggests a rapid cooling event occurred at that time, which we interpret as marking the initial deformation of the northern margin of the Qaidam basin.

In combination with previous studies on the deformation time of the Qilian Shan, our findings suggest that the initial deformation of the Qilian Shan occurred in the Middle Miocene, followed by a multi-step outward expansion. This synchronized expansion might have been triggered by the removal of mantle beneath northern Tibet.

Wang, W., Zhang, P., Garzione, C.N., et al., 2022. Pulsed rise and growth of the Tibetan Plateau to its northern margin since ca. 30 Ma. Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences 119, e2120364119.

This research was supported by the State Key Laboratory of Earthquake Dynamics (LED2021A05) and the National Natural Science Foundation of China (42272269).

How to cite: Pang, J., Zheng, D., and Ma, Y.: Starting of Qilianshan’s uplift since Cenozoic and its implications for Tibetan mantle dynamics, EGU General Assembly 2024, Vienna, Austria, 14–19 Apr 2024, EGU24-4635, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu24-4635, 2024.

10:00–10:10
|
EGU24-6716
|
ECS
|
solicited
|
Virtual presentation
Hongcheng Guo, Peter Zeitler, Bruce Idleman, and Marissa Tremblay

There is now a growing body of literature that reports over-dispersed (U-Th)/He ages from apatites. To address this challenge, we have performed continuous ramped heating (CRH) experiments on apatites from various geologic settings to characterize grain-specific helium (4He) diffusion behavior. Several first-order results emerge from our CRH analyses. (1) It became clear that simple volume diffusion, even accounting for radiation damage, cannot completely describe the diffusion of 4He in apatite. Two major types of 4He degassing behavior were broadly observed. Apatites with good (U-Th)/He age reproducibility show simple and unimodal incremental degassing curves that are similar to those predicted by volume diffusion, whereas samples exhibiting greater age dispersion, often accompanied by anomalously old ages, have complex gas-release curves that feature secondary gas-release peaks deferred to higher temperatures. (2) In practice, CRH can serve as a screening tool to reduce the dispersion of apatite (U-Th)/He ages, especially for those obtained from samples that have experienced slow-cooling. (3) Even among apatites in which 4He does show broad volume diffusion behavior (i.e., size and radiation-damage modulated volume diffusion), CRH analysis reveals kinetic variability of 4He diffusion. (4) Diffusion sinks, which are capable of trapping radiogenic 4He during both geologic processes and laboratory heating, can explain the observed high-temperature gas release during CRH analyses. CRH results of a sample suite from an active helium partial retention zone demonstrate that the release of sink-trapped 4He is temperature dependent rather than being controlled by a threshold mechanism. The results from our CRH analyses carry two critical implications. First, CRH is suitable for routine implementation that enables thermochronology practitioners to focus their measurement and interpretation on apatites in which 4He diffusion obeys volume diffusion. Second, diffusion sinks provide opportunities to extract additional thermal-history information providing a description of grain-specific trapping dynamics. Work in this area is ongoing via 4He/3He diffusion experiments, through which degassing of proton-irradiated 3He in a sample provides information trapping dynamics and degassing of radiogenic 4He constrains the sample’s thermal history.

How to cite: Guo, H., Zeitler, P., Idleman, B., and Tremblay, M.: Helium diffusion systematics in apatites: lessons from Continuous Ramped Heating analysis, EGU General Assembly 2024, Vienna, Austria, 14–19 Apr 2024, EGU24-6716, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu24-6716, 2024.

Posters on site: Mon, 15 Apr, 16:15–18:00 | Hall X2

Display time: Mon, 15 Apr 14:00–Mon, 15 Apr 18:00
Chairpersons: Kristian Drivenes, Jon Engström, Maxime Bernard
X2.55
|
EGU24-3024
Jochen Knies

Constraints on the continental weathering feedback on carbon-cycle perturbations on northern Pangea during the end Triassic extinction (ETE) are sparse. Here, we use hyperspectral core imaging (HSI) applied to conglomeratic beds offshore central Norway which shows that enhanced degassing of basalt flows from the Central Atlantic magmatic province (CAMP) was concurrent with intense continental transformation during the ETE. We use well-constrained mercury pulses emitted in gaseous form during volcanism, and subsequently deposited in near-coastal sediments, to identify the ETE. Parallel to mercury pulses, HSI derived smectite was immediately replaced by kaolinite at the extinction level corroborating increased radiogenic run-off from the hinterland as inferred from osmium isotopes. Our new results suggest that, parallel with CAMP activity and with atmospheric carbon dioxide (pCO2) up to four times the pre-extinction level, continental weathering instantaneously intensified, providing novel empirical knowledge that can be integrated in carbon-cycle models to underpin future warming assessments.

How to cite: Knies, J.: Instant weathering response to carbon-cycle perturbations during the end-Triassic extinction , EGU General Assembly 2024, Vienna, Austria, 14–19 Apr 2024, EGU24-3024, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu24-3024, 2024.

X2.56
|
EGU24-20432
Brenhin Keller and Kalin McDannell

Time-temperature inversion is a critical step in the interpretation and application of thermochronologic data. However, the computational source code for such programs has typically not been freely available, limiting reproducibility. Here we present a new fully open-source (GPL-3.0) time-temperature inversion program, Thermochron.jl, developed in the Julia programming language. This program initially aims to invert zircon helium and apatite helium data via a Markov chain Monte Carlo approach, and allow for the propagation of uncertainty in diffusion parameters. Here we will present the testing and validation of this model, and consider the implications for some open problems in thermochronology, including the limits of resolution for deep-time thermochronology.

How to cite: Keller, B. and McDannell, K.: Development and implications of a new open-source time-temperature inversion program, EGU General Assembly 2024, Vienna, Austria, 14–19 Apr 2024, EGU24-20432, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu24-20432, 2024.

X2.57
|
EGU24-4821
|
ECS
Che Shen and Youlu Jiang

In sedimentary basins, the basement typically exhibits non-conformable contact with the overlying sedimentary strata. The basement surface undergoes a complex history of uplift, weathering, erosion, and sediment burial, all of which contribute to its reservoir structural composition. This study integrates microscopic observations, macroscopic well logging data, and seismic data to analyze the physical and weathering effects on the basement reservoirs with different lithologies and distinct structural features within the Erlian Basin. The basement rock types in the study area mainly include tuff, limestone, granite, cataclastic rock, and the basement has been affected by weathering, denudation, dissolution and structural transformation during the evolution of the basin. The basement has been subjected to long-term tectonic modification, forming network cracks on the macro scale and micro-fractures on the micro scale. Weathering and underground fluids along the fractures dissolve the matrix of tuff rock, feldspar in granite and limestone, thus forming dissolution fractures and dissolution pore in the basement rocks. These fractures and dissolution pores make the porosity and permeability of the basement rocks surface show obvious heterogeneity. According to the microstructure and physical property changes, the structure of different lithology basement surface is analyzed. Among them, the surface of the tuff basement rock has undergone multi-stage volcanic eruptions and weathering leaching, with a structure of multi-stage ancient weathering crust reservoir superposition, and the porosity and permeability of the gentle slope at the structural high part is large. The surface of granite and cataclastic rock basement is controlled by tectonic activity, weathering leaching, and formation fluid action. The double-layer structure comprises the top paleo-wind crust reservoir and the middle and lower fracture dissolution reservoirs, exhibiting high porosity and permeability in the elevated structural positions and the region proximate to the fault zone. Controlled by karstification, tectonic activity, and ancient landform, the limestone basement rock surface displays longitudinal variations in reservoir storage space types, featuring a structure with multiple sets of vertically arranged reservoirs, particularly characterized by high porosity and permeability in elevated structural positions and near fault zones. The concept and results of this work can be used for future studies on unconventional basement reservoirs in other regions.

How to cite: Shen, C. and Jiang, Y.: The reservoir development model of different lithology basement rocks in Erlian Basin,Northeast China., EGU General Assembly 2024, Vienna, Austria, 14–19 Apr 2024, EGU24-4821, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu24-4821, 2024.

X2.58
|
EGU24-2674
|
ECS
Effect of chemical composition on zircon radiation damage dating: Implications for low-temperature thermochronology 
(withdrawn)
Mingpu Fan, Xiaoming Liu, Shengsi Sun, Yunpeng Dong, John C. Ayers, and M. Warrier Santosh
X2.59
|
EGU24-3322
|
ECS
Wei-Chang Hsu, Yuan-Hsi Lee, Kenn-Ming Yang, Kuan-Wei Lin, and Sung-Ping Chang

In this study, we employed low-temperature thermochronology to investigate the depositional source and exhumation rates of the mountain belt in central Taiwan. We collected four sedimentary rock samples from the Chiunkongliao River and one sample from Wuxi. Utilizing zircon fission-track (ZFT) dating and uranium-lead (U-Pb) dating, we observed an increase in the percentage of partially reset zircon from the Chinshui Shale to the Toukoshan Formation. Additionally, we identified total reset zircon in the Toukoshan Formation. Furthermore, the probability density of U-Pb dating in the Toukoshan Formation leans more towards the Oligocene than the Miocene.

Through double-dating, we determined that ZFT ages less than 65 Ma are not the result of Cenozoic volcanic activity. These findings suggest a change in the origin of the depositional source from the Cholan Formation to the Toukoshan Formation. According to the lag time curve, the exhumation rate accelerated during the time period from 1.1 Ma to 0.5 Ma.

Comparing our results with previous studies in the Western Foothills of central Taiwan, we observed that the annealing zone was exposed earliest in the middle part than in the southern one. This may indicate that, in central Taiwan, the exhumation rate in the middle part was the fastest.

 

How to cite: Hsu, W.-C., Lee, Y.-H., Yang, K.-M., Lin, K.-W., and Chang, S.-P.: Study of Plio-Pleistocene Foreland Basin Provenance and Orogenic Exhumation History in Central Taiwan: Fission-Track and U-Pb Dating Analyses of Detrital Zircon from Western Foothills, EGU General Assembly 2024, Vienna, Austria, 14–19 Apr 2024, EGU24-3322, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu24-3322, 2024.

X2.60
|
EGU24-3969
Odleiv Olesen, Håkon Gunnar Rueslåtten, Jasmin Schönenberger, Morten Smelror, Roelant van der Lelij, Bjørn Eskil Larsen, Lars Olsen, and Arne Bjørlykke

The age and formation of the Scandinavian mountains and the western coastal areas (the ‘strandflat’)  have long been the subject of debate. Some suggest that the present-day mountains are remains of the Caledonian orogen while others claim that the Caledonian nappes after denudation were covered by Mesozoic sediments and subsequently exhumed. We have tried to clarify these issues by studying remains of chemically weathered rocks (saprolites) along two profiles from the coast to the interior of central Norway. This multidisciplinary study includes the following data: digital topography, electrical resistivity tomography (ERT), XRD, XRF, palynological analyses and K–Ar dating of samples from outcrops, trenches and core drilling. The coastal areas are dominated by an outer ‘strandflat’ and an inner ‘joint-valley’ landscape, while the interior and mountainous areas are  characterised by smoother landscapes referred to as ‘palaeo-surfaces’. Remnants of pre–Tertiary weathering occur in the joint-valley landscape as well as on the palaeo-surfaces. The deep saprolites are found within fault- and fracture-zones and at depths exceeding 50 m in drillholes. It is suggested that the old saprolites were strongly eroded along the coast and in the fjords and valleys like Orkdalen and Sunndalen. K–Ar dating of clay from saprolites on the mainland commonly show Jurassic ages, seen along a profile that stretches from the coast to the Dovrefjell (approx. 1400 m a.s.l.).The age of the smectite- and kaolinite-containing saprolites seems to be almost contemporaneous along this profile, implying that the entire area was subject to weathering in a warm and humid climate, such as prevailed during the Late Triassic and Jurassic. Palynological remains in the clayey saprolites contain thermally altered pollen and spores from the Triassic and Jurassic, which supports the interpretation and dating of the saprolites.  It is therefore suggested that the Mesozoic landscape in central Norway was shaped by uplift and deep weathering in the Jurassic. However, saprolites occurring along a second profile south of the Trondheimsfjord show Carboniferous and Permian K-Ar ages, indicating that this area constitute a Permian or Triassic sediment basin that was eroded during the late Cenozoic. Thus, it is likely that the entire Trøndelag county was covered by Mesozoic sedimentary rocks, right up to the start of the Cenozoic erosion. Important processes that governed the shaping of the landscape were tectonic uplift and erosion throughout the Cenozoic, followed by extensive abrasion and erosion by glaciers and meltwater during Pleistocene. We therefore conclude that both the studied saprolites and the shape of the present-day landscape in central Norway are characterized by the landscape formed during the Jurassic. This includes the deep profiles of chemical weathering and a drainage pattern that changed in the Pleistocene.

How to cite: Olesen, O., Rueslåtten, H. G., Schönenberger, J., Smelror, M., van der Lelij, R., Larsen, B. E., Olsen, L., and Bjørlykke, A.: Jurassic heritance of the geomorphology in Mid Norway, EGU General Assembly 2024, Vienna, Austria, 14–19 Apr 2024, EGU24-3969, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu24-3969, 2024.

X2.61
|
EGU24-10436
|
ECS
Tiago Miranda, Daniel Barbosa, Osvaldo Correia Filho, Acaua Silva, Gustavo Viegas, Sergio Pacheco, and Bruno Carvalho

The Borborema Province in northeastern Brazil is an ideal location for investigating the tectonic evolution of crustal-scale strike-slip shear zones. These structures exhibit an anastomosing network with numerous well-exposed mylonitic belts linked to the Neoproterozoic Brasiliano-Pan-African Orogeny. However, there is a gap in information on fluid-rock interaction related to both brittle-ductile and brittle deformation. This work aims to describe the control of brittle-ductile structures on the development of brittle fault zones with significant fluid interaction associated with the Cruzeiro do Nordeste shear zone, which limits the northern border of the Jatobá Basin. Our study is based on multiscale structural analyses, integrating aeromagnetic data, UAV images, outcrop-based measurements and microstructural characterization. We documented that the mylonitic foliation is represented by ENE-WSW magnetic positive anomalies (~14 nT/m) and is characterized by S-C fabrics indicating dextral kinematics. Brittle-ductile deformation is marked by dextral C'-type shear bands (WNW-ESE) and mesoscopic strike-slip faults (NW-SE and N-S). These structures exhibit bulges defined by fine-grained, peripheric quartz grains. C’ shear bands evolve into brittle fault zones composed of mosaic and chaotic breccias, veins filled by epidote, epidote+calcite, and calcite, which are associated with hydraulic brecciation. Cathodoluminescence analysis revealed variations in luminescence along the calcite-filled veins, suggesting at least two phases of fluid interaction. The older phase exhibits higher luminescence and is brecciated by the younger calcite fluid, which displays lower luminescence activation. This fluid-rock interaction can modify the permoporous system of analog reservoirs, which can be observed through the variation in cementation intensity in the Tacaratu Formation, sandstones of the Paleozoic sequence of the Jatobá Basin. Our results indicate that the Cruzeiro do Nordeste shear zone is an excellent example that preserves the record of ductile, brittle-ductile and brittle deformation due to exhumation. Furthermore, enhancing our knowledge of brittle deformation associated with the late stages of the Brasiliano-Pan-African cycle (Cambrian?) at shallow crustal levels may be the key to understanding the tectonic evolution of Paleozoic and Cretaceous sedimentary basins in northeastern Brazil. 

How to cite: Miranda, T., Barbosa, D., Correia Filho, O., Silva, A., Viegas, G., Pacheco, S., and Carvalho, B.: Evolution of brittle-ductile deformation to brittle fault zones and the role of fluid migration in Cruzeiro do Nordeste shear zone, Borborema Province, NE Brazil, EGU General Assembly 2024, Vienna, Austria, 14–19 Apr 2024, EGU24-10436, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu24-10436, 2024.

X2.62
|
EGU24-11185
|
ECS
Fujun Wang, Edward R. Sobel, Peter van der Beek, Wenbin Zhu, Cody Colleps, Lingxiao Gong, Johannes Rembe, Guangwei Li, and Johannes Glodny

Cenozoic collision between the Indian and Eurasian plates instigated significant intracontinental deformation in Central Asia, giving rise to the Tibetan Plateau and the Himalayan orogen. Simultaneously, it compelled the Pamir to undergo extensive northward movement, accompanied by tens to hundreds of kilometers of crustal shortening. Ultimately, this geological activity culminated in the collision of the Pamir with the South Tianshan. This collision may be a key factor influencing topography and climate change in Central Asia, yet comparatively little is known about the details of the tectonic evolution of the collision zone. In particular, precise determination of the timing of activation of different thrusts in the Main Pamir thrust (MPT), Pamir fold-and-thrust (PFT), and South Tianshan thrust (STT) system remains lacking. Here, we report new apatite (U-Th-Sm)/He (AHe) dates from fourteen samples collected from the hanging walls of these thrusts, situated at the westernmost tip of the Tarim Basin, NW China. Samples collected from the MPT record rapid cooling at ~ 11 ± 1 Ma, samples from the PFT show rapid cooling at ~ 7 ± 2 Ma and ~4-3 Ma, while samples from the STT reveal accelerated cooling at ~11 ± 1 Ma, ~7-6 Ma and ~3-2 Ma. We propose that the observed rapid cooling was caused by thrust-induced exhumation in this region, thus the rapid cooling represents the activity time of thrusts. Combined with previous studies on the onset deformation in the MPT and STT, we develop a model of the convergence between the North Pamir and South Tianshan in our study region since the late Oligocene. Late Oligocene to early Miocene (~20 ± 5 Ma) cooling ages from the MPT and STT hanging walls date the onset of thrusting, indicating the initiation of this convergence. Afterward, the MPT and STT experienced northward and southward propagation during the late Miocene (~11 ± 1 Ma), respectively. Subsequently, during the latest Miocene (~7 ± 2 Ma), the PFT started to form, while simultaneously, the STT propagated southward, resulting in the contact of these two thrusts at the Wuheshalu section. We suggest that the timing of contact of PFT with the STT represents the surface expression of the onset of collision between the Pamir and South Tianshan in the western Tarim basin. Following the initial collision, the PFT gradually propagated northward while the STT propagated southward during the Pliocene to Pleistocene (~3 ± 1 Ma), establishing the present-day superimposed and imbricated thrust system in the Pamir-South Tianshan convergence zone.

How to cite: Wang, F., R. Sobel, E., van der Beek, P., Zhu, W., Colleps, C., Gong, L., Rembe, J., Li, G., and Glodny, J.: New Constraints on Late Cenozoic Convergence between the Pamir and South Tianshan from Apatite (U-Th-Sm)/He Thermochronology, EGU General Assembly 2024, Vienna, Austria, 14–19 Apr 2024, EGU24-11185, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu24-11185, 2024.

X2.63
|
EGU24-13936
Takahiro Tagami, Noriko Hasebe, and Shigeru Sueoka

Recent progress of low-temperature thermochronology enables to analyze uplift-exhumation-cooling histories of the island-arc mountains with good confidence. This is particularly fruitful for studying the topographic evolution of the Japan Arc, because many of the Japanese mountains are started to uplift in recent time (e.g., late Pliocene to Quaternary) after an extended period of tectonic quiescence, and hence the resultant amount of total denudation is relatively small. The utility of the approach was first demonstrated by elucidating the uplift-exhumation-cooling process for some of the Japan Alps, in which average topographic changes of the tilted mountain block were quantitatively reconstructed by low-temperature thermochronology (Ref. 1-2). Such analyses also allow to estimate the background paleo-depth of neo-tectonic faulting episodes.

In this presentation, we highlight recent and ongoing important thermochronological research in and around the Japan Arc (Ref. 3-5). In addition, we will promote the Thermo2025 conference and introduce its preliminary plans. The International Conference on Thermochronology has been held biyearly around the world and the International Standing Committee on Thermochronology (ISCT) determined that the 19th conference (Thermo2025) will be held in Kanazawa, Japan, on September 14-20th, 2025 (https://isct.sedoo.fr/meetings-2/). Then, the local organizing committee, including the authors, have promoted the preparation of the conference in partnership with the domestic geoscience societies and international thermochronological communities. Pre-registration of Thermo2025 is now being accepted at the website (https://smartconf.jp/content/thermo2025). Those who are interested in the conference can soon receive the announcements by pre-registration.

References

1. Sueoka, S. et al. Island Arc 21, 32-52 (2012).

2. Sueoka, S. et al. Journal of Geophysical Research: Solid Earth 122, 6787-6810 (2017).

3. Sueoka, S. and Tagami, T., Island Arc 28, 1-8 (2019).

4. Fukuda, S. et al. Earth Planet Space, 72, 1-19 (2020).

5. King, G.E. et al. Geology, doi.org/10.1130/G50599.1 (2022).

How to cite: Tagami, T., Hasebe, N., and Sueoka, S.: Overview of thermochronological studies in and around the Japan Arc; towards Thermo2025 Conference in Kanazawa, Japan, EGU General Assembly 2024, Vienna, Austria, 14–19 Apr 2024, EGU24-13936, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu24-13936, 2024.

X2.64
|
EGU24-14975
|
ECS
Silvia Favaro, Alberto Resentini, Massimo Tiepolo, Marco Giovanni Malusà, and Stefano Zanchetta

The impact of a magmatic polyphasic intrusion on the empirical relationship between zircon metamict state as revealed by Raman spectroscopy (Zhang et al., 2000) and α-damage accumulation of the same grains is investigated in the eastern Adamello batholith (Central Italian Alps). Eighteen samples, spanning the contact between the Val di Genova pluton, the Sostino-Corno Alto pluton, and their host rocks – including Permian intrusives, were examined.

Zircons were analysed with a 100mW Nd:YAG solid state laser emitting at 532 nm Raman spectrometer to assess their metamict state based on the position and full width at half maximum of different Raman bands. For each zircon, on the same spot, LA-ICP-MS analyses were performed to determine the crystallization age and U, Th, and Pb concentrations. Crystallization ages and actinides content were used to calculate α-damage since zircon crystallization.

Magmatic zircon ages display a south to north younging trend from the Sostino pluton (44.79±0.35 Ma) to the Val di Genova pluton (34.18±0.20 Ma), consistent with literature data (Schaltegger et al, 2009 and 2019; Ji et al., 2019 and references therein). Moreover, magmatic zircons from the Adamello batholith exhibit a metamict state roughly consistent with calculated α-doses, indicating nearly full retention of decay-related damage. In contrast, zircons from the Paleozoic country rocks and Permian plutons show a nearly crystalline state conflicting with calculated high α-doses, thus suggesting a thermal overprint that annealed their crystalline structure, here identified with the thermal aureole of the Adamello magmatic intrusions. In fact, the measured metamict state of zircons in the host rocks is in overall agreement with α-damage accumulation calculated since intrusion rather than crystallization ages.

Raman analysis of radiation damage in zircon is being currently investigated as a new thermochronological method (Pidgeon, 2014; Nasdala et al., 2001; Nasdala et al., 2002; Hartel, 2021) with particular emphasis on unannealed zircons to test its feasibility. With this study, we present an application of Raman analysis of radiation damage in annealed zircons to trace their thermal history, thus providing independent validation of contact-metamorphic overprints.

How to cite: Favaro, S., Resentini, A., Tiepolo, M., Malusà, M. G., and Zanchetta, S.: Impact of magmatic intrusions on metamict zircon annealing as constrained by Raman spectroscopy in the eastern Adamello batholith (Central Alps), EGU General Assembly 2024, Vienna, Austria, 14–19 Apr 2024, EGU24-14975, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu24-14975, 2024.

X2.65
|
EGU24-15953
Thomas F. Redfield, Espen Torgersen, Anna K. Svendby, Karl Fabian, Anna M. Dichiarante, and Volker Øye

“Of what use at all is a lineament map?” constitutes a fair question posed with positively indecent irregularity, if ever at all. Here we suggest that because topographically derived lineament maps depict landscape elements that form under physically differing processes at different rates and times, they have historically conflated time-transgressive morphological evolution of the region at hand with a simplistic message, stated or implied, akin to “this map, then, represents the structural framework underlying such-and-such geological province.” This slippery slide down the razor presupposes two essential conditions: That incision occurs only where the substrate is most easily eroded and that all faults, fractures, and shear zones are less resistant than undeformed rock. It is a demonstrable fact that neither condition is necessarily true. Yet lineament mapping persists, from Earth to Mars and by now, presumably, on even more distant planets. What can we do with these things, and why do we bother?

Whilst quantifiable linearity does convey information that may be useful for landscape classification, abstracting topographic surfaces into lineaments does not, a priori, expose the structural template of the underlying bits of any given planet. Analyses of azimuth, density, length, or any other quantity provide little benefit unless one can constrain exactly what it was that one measured. Digital vectorization of modern DTM data does offer hope. Furthermore, linearity can be expressed in topographically positive features such as ridgelines. Individual vectors can (must!) be given local attributes (depth… width… sinuosity… slope…) that may be coupled to a postulated (theoretical, probably optimistic, and in most cases surely a relative) morphologically dependent ‘age’ of incision. Regional (‘environmental’) attributes pertaining to bulk properties of the area traversed by that very same vector (flat… inclined… U or V shape… carbonate… granite…) can be collected to provide external context. Equally important is a careful inventory of bias such that the mapping method generates reproducible vectors with representative and homogeneous coverage from the upper left-hand corner of the dataset to both the penultimate and ultimate pixels at the (assume southeastern) End Of File. Absent these, a lineament map is not dissimilar to a basket of tropical fruits plucked from one’s local Arctic haberdashery at or around Christmastime.

Because she exhibits a wide range of topographic styles, human-generated lineament maps have struggled to extract unbiased, homogeneous signals from Baltica’s tired old bones. Having experimented for some years with algorithms designed to map lineaments automatically from (x, y, z) data we feel inclined to present a few observations, interpretations, confessions of bias, and recommendations for how we might possibly do better. We will briefly describe one successful algorithm for computerized lineament mapping, present results that purportedly describe distinctly different Norwegian landscapes, illustrate some connections to certain known structures and disconnections with others, and attempt a sort of general, undoubtably conflicted synthesis of the potential use of lineament maps in assessing the landscape evolution of certain small parts of the Norwegian rifted margin.

“There are more things in heaven and Earth than are dreamt of in our Science….”

How to cite: Redfield, T. F., Torgersen, E., Svendby, A. K., Fabian, K., Dichiarante, A. M., and Øye, V.: Some thoughts on the usefulness of Lineament Maps, EGU General Assembly 2024, Vienna, Austria, 14–19 Apr 2024, EGU24-15953, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu24-15953, 2024.

X2.66
|
EGU24-16090
Anne Kathrine Svendby, Espen Torgersen, Tim Redfield, Anna Maria Dichiarante, and Karoline Arctander

Lineament analysis from topographic maps is a well-known method to identify regional fracture systems and the potential for weakness zones, but the significance of lineaments can easily be misinterpreted. A topographic lineament (topolineament) is just an elongated depression, which may or may not contain important structural information. In which case lineaments represent faults or fractures, and do all brittle structures appear as a lineaments? This is the focus of our project.

In this study, we investigate the applicability of lineament analysis to characterize the fracture system in the Oslo region, Norway. Topolineaments, derived by automatic detection using an in house-developed algorithm (OttoDetect) on a 10x10m digital elevation model, are combined with field structural observations and measurements. Special emphasis was placed on comparing the orientation of brittle structures from field data with that of the detected topolineaments.

The fieldwork was carried out by measuring fractures at selected locations both along and away from larger topolineaments. In some areas, data collection also included measuring scanlines parallel and orthogonal to selected topolineaments. Structural measurements were split into different geographical areas of Oslo and plotted on stereonets. The topolineaments were analyzed and classified by parameters such as orientation, length, density (number of lineaments over a given distance) and width-depth ratio (within the lineament), etc. Rose diagrams of all lineaments within a given radius from a geographical center point were used to show the dominant lineament orientations in the studied area. We pay especially close attention to lineaments in regions dominated by bedrock, in order to represent only bedrock-incised topolineaments, so that the rose diagrams could be used to compare with fracture orientations.

Preliminary results show that both field data and topolineaments are dominated by two orthogonal sets: E-W and N-S. However, the relative dominance of either set in the two datasets seems less correlated. Further analysis is ongoing to also constrain the relationship between fracture and lineament densities.

How to cite: Svendby, A. K., Torgersen, E., Redfield, T., Dichiarante, A. M., and Arctander, K.: Lineament analysis for characterizing regional fracture system – A case study from the Oslo region, Norway, EGU General Assembly 2024, Vienna, Austria, 14–19 Apr 2024, EGU24-16090, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu24-16090, 2024.

X2.67
|
EGU24-16413
Per Terje Osmundsen and Thomas F. Redfield

Formation of the Norwegian rifted margin in the Mesozoic and Early Cenozoic and denudation of adjacent onshore areas resulted in preferential reactivation of regionally important Paleozoic faults and shear zones as indicated by a variety of published geochronological data. Lithospheric-scale necking impacted the later topographic evolution of the present onshore areas, including an escarpment topography and incision pattern that correlates with the seawards taper of the crystalline crust. The density of large, mapped landslides in turn reflects topographic and structural signals and tend to cluster inboard of sharply tapered areas. Margin formation also resulted in the impregnation of crystalline basement by swarms of smaller structures around multiply reactivated structures that made the bedrock prone for coastal erosion as well as onshore slope instability, with apparent maxima in glacially incised topography in areas inboard of sharply tapered margin segments in North- and Mid Norway as well as inboard of parts of the northern North Sea. Offshore, the sharply tapered Møre segment contains stacked submarine slide deposits in an anomaleously short progradational Quaternary wedge, illustrated spectacularly by the Holocene Storegga slide.  An important part of the geohazards distribution onshore and offshore Norway can thus be viewed as long-term responses to the rifting process through an interplay between crustal-scale inheritance, structural reactivation and saturation and mass redistribution by erosion, especially glacial transport. Other rifted margins that evolved by multiphase extension may display similar relationahips between ancient structural templates and the modern distributiion of geohazards.    

How to cite: Osmundsen, P. T. and Redfield, T. F.: From Margin to Menace: the role of structural inheritance in the geohazards distribution in Norway  , EGU General Assembly 2024, Vienna, Austria, 14–19 Apr 2024, EGU24-16413, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu24-16413, 2024.

X2.68
|
EGU24-19708
Incorporating RSCM temperature data into inverse thermal models of low-temperature thermochronometric data
(withdrawn)
Nathan Niemi, Kerry Gallagher, and Chloe Marks
X2.69
|
EGU24-19032
|
ECS
|
Florian Trilsch, Hongyang Fu, Raymond Jonckheere, Bastian Wauschkuhn, Carolin Aslanian, and Lothar Ratschbacher

Apatite fission-track modelling reconstructs the low-temperature histories of geological samples based on measurements of the lengths of etched confined fission tracks and counted surface tracks. We investigate the influence of the chemical composition of apatite on the etching of fossil confined fission tracks, and its consequences for the apatite fission-track method, to optimize the track-length distribution for modelling apatites with varying chemical compositions. The duration for which each confined track was etched can be calculated given the apatite etch-rate νR. We conducted step-etch experiments on samples with etch pit diameters (Dpar) spanning most of the range for natural apatites (1.4–4.6 μm), including four gem-quality apatites (Panasqueira, Slyudyanka, Brazil, Bamble) and fourteen samples from the igneous and metasedimentary basement of the Tian Shan, Central Asia, in or­der to determine the apatite etch rate vR as a function of crystallographic orientation for each. To a first order, νR correlates with the size of the track intersections with the mineral sur­face for all hexagonal apatites. For the gem-quality apatites we fitted three-parameter exponential functions (vR = a 𝜙’ × e b𝜙 + c); a and b both exhibit a linear correlation with Dpar. Combin­ing these results gives one equation (vR = a(Dpar) 𝜙’ × e b(Dpar)𝜙 + c) giving the apatite etch rate vR in a giv­en orientation (ϕ’) for hexagonal apatites with a specified chemical com­position (Dpar). Bamble exhibits a different - bimodal - relationship between vR and ϕ’. In all cases, including Bamble, there is a striking parallelity between the angular frequencies of horizontal con­fined tracks and the magnitude of the apatite etch rate vR per­pendicular to the track axes. This shows that the sample of confined tracks selected for measurement and modelling is to a much greater degree de­termined by the etching properties of the apatite sample than by geometrical or subjective biases. The mean track-etch-rate vT correlates with Dpar, so that tracks etch to their full lengths in a shorter time in faster etching apatites. The mean rate of length increase between etch steps, vL, also correlates with Dpar. For the Tian Shan samples we use νR for calculating the effective etch time tE of confined tracks measured after 20 to 60 s immersion in 5.5 M HNO3 at 21 °C. Considering only tracks within a predetermined etch-time window for length measurement improves the reproducibility of the track-length distributions. Because an etch-time window allows excluding under- and over-etched tracks, sample immersion times can be optimized to increase the number of confined tracks suitable for modelling. If vT correlates with Dpar as our data indicate, future studies need to investigate how such an effective etch time window should be scaled by chemical composition as well. An alternative approach for selecting an appropriate etch time for each sample is to look on the track length anisotropy. We finally compare thermal histories obtained with a conventional 20 s immersion protocol, without tE selection, with those using the length of tracks within the range tE = 15–30 s.

How to cite: Trilsch, F., Fu, H., Jonckheere, R., Wauschkuhn, B., Aslanian, C., and Ratschbacher, L.: Effective Etch Times and compositional effects on the etching of Fossil Fission Tracks in Geological Apatite Samples, EGU General Assembly 2024, Vienna, Austria, 14–19 Apr 2024, EGU24-19032, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu24-19032, 2024.

X2.70
|
EGU24-10890
|
ECS
Cody Colleps, Peter van der Beek, and Julien Amalberti

The late Oligocene Fish Canyon Tuff (FCT)—preserved within the San Juan volcanic field of southern Colorado—has long served as a reliable source of multiple accessory minerals for geochronology and thermochronology age standards. Whereas the ‘classic’ FCT sampling locality preserves near consistent ages of ~28–29 Ma across the sanidine 40Ar/39Ar, zircon U-Pb, zircon fission track, zircon (U-Th)/He, and apatite fission track systems, the average single-grain apatite (U-Th)/He (AHe) age at this site is notably younger at 20.8 ± 0.4 Ma. Considering that the classic sampling site is positioned at the bottom of a deeply incised valley with ~800 m of local relief, this AHe age has been proposed to record burial of the basal tuff to depths exceeding ~1000 m, with subsequent Early Miocene cooling reflecting valley incision. In contrast, an average single-grain AHe age of 28.5 ± 0.1 Ma was previously recorded from a newly proposed distal FCT locality where the upper-most tuffs are freshly preserved within a quarry. This AHe age is consistent with higher temperature geochronological ages from the same locality, which suggests that the distal FCT experienced no post-emplacement thermal disturbance. The observed, locality-specific difference in AHe ages provides a unique opportunity to calibrate and assess the potential of apatite 4He/3He thermochronology to (1) quantify the degree of post-emplacement burial and the rate of subsequent cooling at the classic FCT locality, and (2) record rapid late Oligocene cooling at the distal FCT locality. We respectively test the hypothesis that the classic FCT apatite will yield a comparatively diffusive 4He/3He degassing spectra, whereas the distal FCT apatite will preserve a near-uniform 4He/3He spectra that is solely affected by alpha-ejection. We consider and discuss newly derived 4He/3He results in light of (1) the geological history and landscape evolution of southern Colorado, (2) the potential use of distal FCT apatite as a coupled AHe and 4He/3He thermochronology reference material, and (3) the reproducibility of FCT apatite 4He/3He spectra using differing proton-irradiation procedures. 

How to cite: Colleps, C., van der Beek, P., and Amalberti, J.: Evaluating the classic and distal Fish Canyon Tuff localities with apatite 4He/3He thermochronology, EGU General Assembly 2024, Vienna, Austria, 14–19 Apr 2024, EGU24-10890, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu24-10890, 2024.

X2.71
|
EGU24-9976
|
ECS
The Paleozoic subduction-splicing-extension process of the North China and South China Blocks: Constraints from sedimentary provenance of the Devonian Liuling Group and surrounding strata in the South Qinling Belt, China
(withdrawn)
Leigang Zhang, Hongjun Qu, and Peng Li
X2.72
|
EGU24-12215
|
ECS
Chao Guo, Zhiyong Zhang, Richard Lease, Marco Malusà, David Chew, Bernhard Grasemann, and Wenjiao Xiao

Understanding the geodynamics of plateau evolution necessitates careful consideration of the spatial and temporal constraints associated with mountain building on the northeastern Tibetan Plateau. However, when and how the northeastern Tibetan Plateau grew remains highly debatable. Here we integrate apatite U-Pb, fission-track, and rare-earth element provenance indicators from the Oligocene-Miocene continental succession of the Xunhua Basin to establish a framework of drainage reorganization and topographic evolution of the Xunhua region. The results suggest three provenance changes at ca. 28 Ma, ca. 20 Ma, and ca. 12 Ma, that not only indicate topographic growth of the West Qinling, Laji Shan, and Jishi Shan, respectively, but emphasize the significance of apatite for provenance analysis. The compilation of our findings and deformations within the northeastern Tibetan Plateau reveals the Oligocene-Miocene stepwise expansion and the Middle Miocene stress reorganization within the northeastern Tibetan Plateau. Combined with regional evidences, we propose that the Early Cenozoic northward compression of the Indian continent shortened and thickened Tibetan lithosphere, and subsequently triggered the removal of thickened lithosphere beneath south-central Tibet in the Oligocene. This process not only induced Oligocene-Miocene progressive expansion across the northeastern Tibetan Plateau, but also facilitated the continuous northward injection of the Indian lithosphere. Simultaneously, accompanied by the southward insertion of the North China craton, the underthrusting of both the India and North China initiated sinistral strike-slip faults in the middle Miocene, driving a change in stress directions. The results of this study underline the contribution of both the lithospheric removal and continental underthrusting geodynamic processes in driving outward growth of plateau. 

How to cite: Guo, C., Zhang, Z., Lease, R., Malusà, M., Chew, D., Grasemann, B., and Xiao, W.: Apatite U-Pb, fission-track, and trace element provenance constraints on Oligocene-Miocene northeastern Tibetan Plateau growth and dynamics, EGU General Assembly 2024, Vienna, Austria, 14–19 Apr 2024, EGU24-12215, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu24-12215, 2024.

X2.73
|
EGU24-13898
Liyun Zhou and Yu Wang

How did the continent-oceanic plate interact, and when did the initial west paleo-Pacific plate subduction beneath Eurasian continent occur, are still unknown. NE China deformation, volcanic eruptions and magmatic intrusions can give some constraints. Muling located in the Dunhua-Mishan fault zone in NE China, is a key area where the E-W-trending Eurasian domain changed to NE-trending west Pacific Plate domain in NE China. During the Mesozoic time, at least three stages of deformation occurred, including: (1) E-W-trending structures with extensive ductile shear deformation and south-verging folds which result from thrusting towards the south, followed the emplacement of granitic rocks. (2) NE- or NNE-trending thrust faults and strike-slip movement, accompanied by the formation of west-verging inclined and recumbent folds. This phase deformation changed the whole tectonic framework of eastern China from an E-W-trending Eurasian domain to a NE-trending west Pacific Plate domain. (3) NE-trending strike-slip faults and E-W-trending strike-slip motion. Field investigations of Mesozoic ductile shear zone and faults, granitic intrusions and dykes, combined with zircon U-Pb dating and muscovite 40Ar/39Ar plateau ages, reveal the age of the E-W-trending structures as ~254-209Ma, and NE–SW-trending tectonic belts as ~182–170 Ma. The tectonic transformation of the eastern China continent involved a change from E-W to NE-SW-trending structures was a response to the initial subduction of paleo-Pacific plate.

How to cite: Zhou, L. and Wang, Y.: Middle-late Mesozoic tectonic evolution of the NE China—corresponding to westward subduction of the paleo-Pacific plate, EGU General Assembly 2024, Vienna, Austria, 14–19 Apr 2024, EGU24-13898, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu24-13898, 2024.