An attempt to understand corn and winter wheat temporal behavior by means of Sentinel-1 and Sentinel-2 data and its relation with phonological stages.

Crops are of the fundamental food sources for humanity. Due to the population growth as well as climate change, monitoring of the crops is important to sustain agriculture and conserve natural resources. Development of the remote sensing techniques especially in terms of revisiting time opens new avenues to study crops temporal behaviors from space. Moreover, thanks to the Copernicus program, which guarantees optical as well as radar data to be freely available, there are opportunities to utilize them in an operative way. Additionally, utilization of spectral as well as radar data allows for the synergetic application of both datasets. However, to utilize this data in the operational crop monitoring, it is very important to understand the temporal variations of the remote sensing signal. Therefore, we make an attempt to understand spectral as well as radar remote sensing temporal behavior and its relation with phonological stages.

For the analysis, 14 cloud-free Sentinel-2 (S-2) acquisitions as well as 34 Sentinel-1 (S-1) acquisitions are utilized. S-2 data were collected with 2A-level while S-1 data was captured in the format of Single Look Complex (SLC) in the Interferometric Wide (IW) swath mode. SLC products consist of complex SAR data preserving phase information which allows studying polarimetric indicators. All remote sensing (spectral as well as SAR) data cover the time period from 04/05/2020 to 07/11/2020. During this time, also 14 field visits were carried out to capture information about phonological stages of corn and wheat according to the BBCH scale (Biologische Bundesanstalt, Bundessortenamt und CHemische Industrie). Additionally, to better understand the temporal behavior of S-1/S-2 signal, weather information from the Institute of Meteorology and Water Management (IMGW) was captured.

Based on various spectral bands of S-2 data, 12 spectral indices were calculated e.g., GNDVI (Green Normalized Vegetation Index), IRECI (Inverted Red-Edge Chlorophyll Index), MCARI (Modified Chlorophyll Absorption in Reflectance Index), MSAVI (Modified Soil-Adjusted Vegetation Index), MTCI (MERIS Terrestrial Chlorophyll Index), NDVI (Normalized Difference Vegetation Index), PSSRa (Pigment Specific Simple Ratio) and others. After radiometric calibration and the Lee speckle filtering, backscattering coefficients (σ_VV^o ,σ_VH^o) of S-1 images were calculated as well as its backscattering ratio (σ_VH^o/ σ_VV^o).  All images were then converted from linear to decibel (dB). Additionally, 2 × 2 covariance matrix delivered from S-1 was extracted from the scattering matrix of each SLC image using PolSARpro version 6.0.2 software. After speckle filtration, total scattered power was derived which allows calculating the Shannon Entropy. This value measures the randomness of the scattering within a pixel.

Time series of many S-2 indices reveal the strong correlation between the development of phenology stages of corn and wheat and the increase of S2 delivered values of spectral indices. However, such a strong correlation cannot be observed within many of S-1 indices. Some of them very poorly indicate the correlation between the development of phenology stages of corn and wheat and increase of S-1 indices values. Additionally, it was observed that values of S1/S2 indices for the same phenology stage very between corn and winter wheat.