GM9.5 | Land Subsidence: Quantifications, Projections, Impacts, and Mitigation in Natural and Urbanized Coastal Environments
EDI
Land Subsidence: Quantifications, Projections, Impacts, and Mitigation in Natural and Urbanized Coastal Environments
Convener: Claudia Zoccarato | Co-conveners: Roberta Bonì, Makan Karegar, Manoochehr Shirzaei, Esther Stouthamer
Orals
| Tue, 16 Apr, 10:45–12:30 (CEST)
 
Room G2
Posters on site
| Attendance Tue, 16 Apr, 16:15–18:00 (CEST) | Display Tue, 16 Apr, 14:00–18:00
 
Hall X3
Orals |
Tue, 10:45
Tue, 16:15
Land subsidence (LS), the loss of land elevation due to various natural and human-induced processes, is a growing concern in coastal plains and deltas worldwide. LS is the cumulative effect of a myriad of subsurface processes, both natural, e.g., tectonics, natural compaction of unconsolidated sediments, glacial and sediment isostatic adjustment, growth fault and anthropogenic-driven, e.g., aquifer over-exploitation, hydrocarbon production, soil drainage, peat oxidation, and urbanization-related loading of the Earth’s surface. In addition, natural mechanisms to gain elevation, i.e., fluvial sedimentation and in-situ organic growth, are decreasing by human-altered river catchments and coastal landscapes.
While global sea level is rising (SLR), contemporary LS rates in many pristine and urbanized coastal environments are often (much) larger, dominating the relative SLR (rSLR). Compared to gradual SLR, LS can be much more spatially and temporally variable, with both accelerations and decelerations occurring over annual to decadal timescales. As such, to improve regional to local quantifications and projections of SLR, it is imperative to thoroughly address the land perspective, for example by considering the various biochemical and physical subsurface processes and their interactions at appropriate spatial and temporal scale. This shifts the focus to the land component of the rSLR, which could be instead referred to as ‘relative land subsidence, rLS’.
This session welcomes contributions from all fields related to land subsidence and coastal land elevation evolution. From studies on quantifying and monitoring contemporary vertical land motion, methodologies to disentangling observations into individual drivers and processes at different spatial and temporal scales, to numerical modelling. From projections of future subsidence to rLS impacts assessments and coastal elevation evolution, and studies on mitigation strategies and the implementation of adaptation measurements. We especially encourage contributions thriving to bridge the gaps between different LS and SLR disciplines towards improving future projections of coastal rLS and rSLR.
This session is part of the International Panel on Land Subsidence (IPLSubsidence.org) initiative to unite subsidence research communities to improve quantifications and projections of coastal LS and relative SLR.

Session assets

Orals: Tue, 16 Apr | Room G2

Chairpersons: Claudia Zoccarato, Manoochehr Shirzaei, Esther Stouthamer
10:45–10:50
10:50–11:00
|
EGU24-15983
|
solicited
|
On-site presentation
Rémi Thiéblemont, Gonéri Le Cozannet, Robert J. Nicholls, Jérémy Rohmer, Guy Wöppelmann, Daniel Raucoules, Marcello de Michele, Alexandra Toimil, and Daniel Lincke

While the understanding and modelling of sea level rise (SLR) due to ocean density and mass changes have greatly improved over the past few decades, relative SLR contributions due to vertical land motions (VLMs) remain a major source of uncertainty. It is critical to downscale global and regional sea-level rise to local relative sea-level change as this is what causes coastal impacts and adaptation needs. In particular, land subsidence can strongly exacerbate coastal flood risk, saltwater intrusion, erosion and loss of wetlands and damage to infrastructure.

Here, we present the first analysis of pan-European coastal subsidence based on the European Ground Motion Service (EGMS) Ortho product. First, we perform a comparison between EGMS Ortho (Level 3) vertical velocity estimates and GNSS stations vertical velocity. This comparison reveals that the geodetic reference frame used to calibrate EGMS affects the vertical land velocity estimates and needs to be accounted for carefully, especially for the vertical land motions – including sub-millimetric/year velocities – that could affect local SLR estimates. After adjusting the EGMS calibrated product to the International Terrestrial Reference Frame (ITRF2014), we performed an assessment of VLM in European coastal flood plains. Our results show that half of the European area located in coastal flood plain is, on average, experiencing subsidence at a rate stronger than -1 mm/yr. More importantly, we find that urban area and population experience almost a -1 mm/yr subsidence on average (if we discard the uplifting regions due to Glacial Isostatic Adjustment) and for coastal airports and for harbours, the average land motion drops is even larger with -1.5 mm/yr subsidence rate. Finally, while our analysis allows identifying already well-known coastal subsidence hot-spots (e.g. Northern Italian coastal plain, Netherlands), we demonstrate with few examples that EGMS analysis also paves the way toward the identification of subsiding local scale coastal zones that have been ignored so far and for which flooding risk may become a major concern.

How to cite: Thiéblemont, R., Le Cozannet, G., Nicholls, R. J., Rohmer, J., Wöppelmann, G., Raucoules, D., de Michele, M., Toimil, A., and Lincke, D.: Current State of Coastal Subsidence in Europe Derived from the European Ground Motion Service, EGU General Assembly 2024, Vienna, Austria, 14–19 Apr 2024, EGU24-15983, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu24-15983, 2024.

11:00–11:10
|
EGU24-8067
|
ECS
|
On-site presentation
Gergino Chounna Yemele, Pietro Teatini, and Philip Minderhoud

The coast of Cameroon, which is approximately 590 km in length, is situated in the Gulf of Guinea and is characterized by its low elevation above sea level and sedimentary geology, making it particularly susceptible to erosion, subsidence, and sea level rise. The coast of Cameroon and its extensive mangrove forests are facing numerous economic pressures, including encroachment from urban expansion, agro-industrial development, port activities, oil and gas exploration and exploitation, and the increased pollution associated with these activities. Additionally, many rapidly growing cities located along the coast (Douala, Kribi, Tiko, Limbe) and neighbouring the mangroves (Duala estuary, Rio Del Rey estuary, and Ntem estuary) are currently experiencing alarming rates of coastal erosion, frequent flooding, complete loss of land, and evidence of subsidence from regional and continental research. Unfortunately, there have been no detailed investigations of the combined effects of land subsidence and sea-level rise, known as relative sea-level rise, and their present and future impacts on Cameroon's emerging coastal cities and mangroves under climate change. Therefore, this research aims to fill this knowledge gap by investigating, understanding, and projecting the causes, consequences, and coastal vulnerability related to land subsidence and sea-level rise to enable the development of information-based mitigation strategies and policies. We will use remote sensing data, InSAR analysis, hydrogeological investigations, and modelling tools to assess the real coastal elevation of Cameroon, determine the actual land subsidence rate, determine the actual local relative sea-level rise from tide gauge data, determine the factors influencing land subsidence, project future elevation evolution, and establish an integrated vulnerability assessment of the coastal areas of Cameroon. This research will contribute to a proper understanding of Cameroon's mangrove landscape dynamics, the vulnerability of coastal infrastructure, and its biodiversity to relative sea-level rise, subsidence, coastal retreat, and future flooding events. The outcome can be used to develop sustainable management strategies for Cameroon's coastal zone.

How to cite: Chounna Yemele, G., Teatini, P., and Minderhoud, P.: Vulnerability of coastal cities and mangroves to the combined effects of Land subsidence, relative sea-level rise, and groundwater extraction along the low-lying coastland of Cameroon, EGU General Assembly 2024, Vienna, Austria, 14–19 Apr 2024, EGU24-8067, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu24-8067, 2024.

11:10–11:20
|
EGU24-15568
|
On-site presentation
Khaled Zahran

Rosetta is a port city of the Nile Delta, 65 km east of Alexandria. The village is distinguished by its geographical location as the estuary of the Nile River and on the shore of the Mediterranean Sea. It is also historically distinguished as the original site for the discovery of one of the greatest heritage pieces in the world, the Rosetta stone at the village of Burj Rashid, which is currently in the British Museum. The construction of the High Dam reduces the natural mud deposits cause of the sinking and erosion of the crust there and the city experience variable high rates of erosion with accelerated coastal area lost on the last two decades.  This makes this city is very sensitive to any sea level rise.    Thus, Rashid is one of the most vulnerable coastal cities to the effects of climate change. 

The present study provides the contribution of the modernized geodetic and satellite techniques to take part into determination the effect of Mediterranean Sea level rise and land subsidence on the city of Rosetta. To reach the proposed objective the study utilizes   Global Navigation Satellite System (GNSS), tide gauges and satellite altimetry and gravity data. GNSS data has been used to determine the rates of the horizontal and vertical movements of the studied region   and linking the rates of vertical movement of the Delta to the temporal change of the sea level variation of the Mediterranean Sea by tying GPS measurements to tide gauge data. On the other hand, determination of temporal local and regional sea level variation of the southern part of the Mediterranean Sea using tide gauge and satellite altimetry data. Finally, total mass variation and the tectonic settings of the shore line features has been figured out using recent satellite gravity data. 

 Permanent GNSS network along the Nile Delta shows variable rates of land subsidence, with the subsidence rate of the studied area of about 6mm/y. Satellite altimeter data together with tide gauge data confirm the Sea level rise acceleration on this region with an acceleration of about 7mm/y.  On the other hand, the selected region shows complicated pattern of mass variation, land subsidence and Sea Level Rise. Therefore, impact of climate change may be the biggest challenge in this region. On this context, accurate monitoring on the land subsidence and the sea level rise is of great importance to the climate change mitigation and the protection of this city.

How to cite: Zahran, K.: Land Subsidence and Coastal Changes in Vicinity of the City of Rosetta, Nile Delta, Egypt Using Integrated Satellite and Ground-Based Techniques., EGU General Assembly 2024, Vienna, Austria, 14–19 Apr 2024, EGU24-15568, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu24-15568, 2024.

11:20–11:30
|
EGU24-2120
|
ECS
|
On-site presentation
Manon Verberne, Kay Koster, Hans de Bresser, and Peter Fokker

Subsidence research in the Netherlands primarily focusses on anthropogenic processes, specifically in the shallow and deep subsurface, resulting from land use, water management, and resource extraction. However, the 'intermediate' depth range, spanning hundreds of meters, has been relatively underexplored due to limited economic activities within this range. To accurately disentangle the overall human-induced subsidence, however, understanding the contribution from intermediate depth processes is essential.

We analyzed data from 20 extensometers monitoring subsurface movements between 1970 and 2021, at depth intervals ranging from ~10 to 400 meters. The extensometers were located in the hydrocarbon extraction areas operated by NAM (Nederlandse Aardolie Maatschappij) in Groningen, Friesland and Rotterdam.

Our findings highlight that secondary compaction, or creep, induced by overburden weight is the main driver of subsidence at intermediate depths. We found that subsidence rates of up to 0.6 mm/year in Groningen and 0.8 mm/year in Rotterdam account for over 10% of total measured subsidence in these regions. In Groningen, creep is attributed to Tertiary marine and Pleistocene eolian/fluvial deposits, whereas in Rotterdam, it is associated with Pleistocene shallow marine deposits. In all locations, the overburden weight of the Holocene deposits also affects the compaction at intermediate depth range.

Moreover, our analysis reveals cyclic responses in the extensometer data, including seasonal and tidal patterns. The strength of the seasonal signal corresponds to the inland salt-brackish groundwater boundary, while the tidal response is prominent near the coastline. Unexplained trend breaks, potentially linked to phreatic groundwater management, were observed in both regions.

Our analysis emphasizes the crucial role of intermediate depth contributions in obtaining a comprehensive understanding of the overall subsidence signal. Neglecting these contributions can lead to an incomplete interpretation subsidence, potentially overestimating the impact of mitigation measures. The intricate interplay of cyclic trends, salinity, water management measures, and secondary compaction emphasizes the necessity to expand monitoring efforts in the intermediate depth range.

 In response to the complexities identified in intermediate depth compaction analysis, we propose a monitoring setup with supplementary data sources, which maximizes the utility of the extensometer data. This setup is applicable to coastal plains and deltas worldwide, where a thorough understanding of subsurface processes is crucial for maintaining a sustainable living environment. Only with this comprehensive understanding can the total subsidence signal be accurately interpreted, ensuring that mitigation measures achieve their full effectiveness and avoid overestimation of other contributing sources.

How to cite: Verberne, M., Koster, K., de Bresser, H., and Fokker, P.: Unveiling the Hidden Depths: Insights in Intermediate Depth Compaction from 50 years of Extensometer Data in the Netherlands, EGU General Assembly 2024, Vienna, Austria, 14–19 Apr 2024, EGU24-2120, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu24-2120, 2024.

11:30–11:40
|
EGU24-1335
|
On-site presentation
Cheng-Yu Ku and Chih-Yu Liu

In light of the increasing frequency of severe droughts linked to climate change in central and southern Taiwan, the Choshui delta in central Taiwan has witnessed a notable surge in land subsidence. Consequently, the pace of land subsidence has peaked at 7.8 cm per year as of 2021 in the Choshui delta, Taiwan. The process of soil compaction in the Choshui delta primarily unfolds as a time-dependent geological phenomenon. A comprehensive understanding and characterization of this process are essential for the formulation of effective mitigation and adaptation strategies. This study presents a pioneering approach to characterize land subsidence in the Choshui delta, utilizing a random forest algorithm (RFA).

The random forest is an ensemble machine learning algorithm known for its versatility and effectiveness in various predictive modeling tasks. It is widely used due to its ability to handle complex relationships for tasks such as classification, regression, and feature selection in land subsidence. By leveraging this advanced modeling technique, we aim to identify and analyze the underlying causes of land subsidence, providing valuable insights into the dynamic interplay of environmental factors. This research contributes to a more comprehensive understanding of land subsidence patterns by incorporating a multi-factorial perspective in the face of changing climatic conditions. Using the RFA, we may identify and analyze the dominant factors affecting land subsidence. Subsequently, a land subsidence prediction model is established based on the RFA, considering the multi-factorial perspective, include cumulative compaction, groundwater levels, electricity consumption for pumping, and rainfall.

The RFA is utilized to identify the temporal patterns from historical time-series data spanning from 2008 to 2021, which is specifically associated with the land subsidence site in the study area. To validate the proposed model, we compare its predictions to the historical time-series data, utilizing metrics such as root mean square error, correlation coefficient, and coefficient of determination. Results demonstrate that, the optimal RMSE, R, and R2 values during the prediction phase. The RFA in the context of land subsidence prediction performs exceptionally well, exhibiting high accuracy in predicting land subsidence patterns in the rapidly subsiding areas of the Choshui delta.

Keywords: land subsidence; climate change; random forest algorithm; groundwater; Choshui delta.

How to cite: Ku, C.-Y. and Liu, C.-Y.: Characterizing Land Subsidence Using Random Forest Algorithm in Taiwan, EGU General Assembly 2024, Vienna, Austria, 14–19 Apr 2024, EGU24-1335, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu24-1335, 2024.

11:40–11:50
|
EGU24-6841
|
ECS
|
Highlight
|
On-site presentation
Bhaskar Khatiwada, Sanjeev Rana, Anoj Khanal, Bibek Khatiwada, Nabin Tiwari, and Bhogendra Mishra

Land subsidence in Kathmandu Valley has been recorded since 2003. The major cause of the Kathmandu valley subsidence is still unidentified and the subsiding depth or layer is not clear yet. Published research work has revealed the positive correlation between subsidence and sediment thickness of the valley. Kathmandu Valley, with a heterogeneous sediment thickness and different depths of bedrock, creates favorable conditions for differential settlement.

This study is focused on understanding and analyzing the early evidence of land subsidence in different parts of Kathmandu Valley, with direct field observations. Developing empirical relationships to better understand the underlying causes of land subsidence, primarily, multiple deep tubewells (DTW) sites across the valley were observed with the aim of analyzing changes in tubewell head and the impact of subsurface geology and tubewell lithology being studied. 

Tubewell constructed over bedrock shows the upheaval of the tubewell head in UN Office, Pulchowk, Jagdal Gulma, Chhauni, Prime Hotel, Thamel, where depth to bedrock is 126, 100, and 210 meters respectively. Tubewell upheaval has been recorded since 2017 in Pulchowk and Chhauni and since 2020 in Thamel with the rate of tubewell upheaval is similar to land subsidence recorded from InSAR and DGPS surveys. A similar pattern of tube well upheaval is visualized in and around the surrounding area, where tubewells are constructed over bedrock. In the same area, tubewells constructed on soil subsurface with relatively shallow depth remain the same. A 550 meter long horizontal surface crack around the Manbhawan area indicates the differential settlement of ground surface due to land subsidence. However, no strong evidence is recorded around the central part of the valley floor, where the depth of bedrock is deep.

The evidence recorded by tubewell upheaval at Pulchowk, Chhauni and Thamel validates the regional compaction of sediment layers deposited over the bedrock and the surface crack around the Manbhawan area validates the differential settlement due to change of subsidence rate over the same area. No change of tubewell head in shallow tubewell in the same area validates the deep aquifer compaction due to groundwater extraction and sediment load.

How to cite: Khatiwada, B., Rana, S., Khanal, A., Khatiwada, B., Tiwari, N., and Mishra, B.: Early evidence of land subsidence in Kathmandu Valley, EGU General Assembly 2024, Vienna, Austria, 14–19 Apr 2024, EGU24-6841, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu24-6841, 2024.

11:50–12:00
|
EGU24-3252
|
ECS
|
On-site presentation
Bente Lexmond, Chayenne Janssen, Gilles Erkens, Jasper Griffioen, and Esther Stouthamer

Normal seasonal variations in wet and dry conditions cause vertical land movement, due to shrinkage and swelling, particularly in deposits rich in expansive clay minerals or organic matter. This land movement can be up to decimeters depending on the characteristics of the deposit, causing damage to infrastructure and buildings. Furthermore, the increase in drought duration and intensity results in a lowering of the groundwater table to unprecedented levels in shallow deltaic and coastal subsurface deposits. Exposure to resulting low water contents in the unsaturated zone induces irreversible shrinkage and densification of the soil structure, contributing to land subsidence.

Understanding the relation between water content and bulk volume over time is crucial for predicting the land movement and assessing the potential for land subsidence and associated structural damage. The shrinkage behaviour is commonly characterized using soil shrinkage characteristic curves, which relate the water content to bulk volume.

In this study, we characterized the soil shrinkage characteristic curves (SSCCs) of undisturbed natural samples extracted from the capillary fringe zone of shallow, marine clay-rich deposits in the Netherlands. The sample site was selected based on the presence of an extensometer, constantly monitoring the water content and thickness of the soil layer. The SSCCs were created by measuring the water content and sample volume during air drying of the samples. The sample volume was measured with optical distance sensors. The water content decreased from 0.97 to 0.08 during the experiment and the void ratio from 0.97 to 0.34.  The SSCCs of the samples show a linear relation between water content and void ratio, for a water content between 0.97 and 0.34.

By applying the established linear relation to the monitored in-situ soil moisture content at the sample site, we predicted the change in thickness of the soil layer. The prediction overestimates the measured changes in land movement, indicating the importance of in-situ conditions. The measured land movement seems to be more responsive to the groundwater level than the water content. The and the coming results underscore the importance of measuring land movement in-situ.

How to cite: Lexmond, B., Janssen, C., Erkens, G., Griffioen, J., and Stouthamer, E.: Applicability of measured soil shrinkage characteristic curves to in-situ land movement monitoring data for expansive soils, EGU General Assembly 2024, Vienna, Austria, 14–19 Apr 2024, EGU24-3252, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu24-3252, 2024.

12:00–12:10
|
EGU24-21064
|
ECS
|
On-site presentation
Weijiang Yu, Domenico Baù, Vasileios Christelis, and Mohammadali Geranmehr

We introduce a novel groundwater flow model designed for the rapid estimation of seawater intrusion (SWI) in coastal aquifers. Drawing on Girinskii's potential theory (1947) for 2D aquifer flow, the model extends Strack's (1976) adaptation to coastal aquifers under transient state conditions. Key features include applicability to heterogeneous unconfined aquifer systems under time-dependent pumping and spatially distributed groundwater recharge. Assumptions include a sharp seawater-freshwater interface, prevailing horizontal flow, and neglect of flow rates within the saltwater wedge.

Built upon a finite-element 2D saturated groundwater simulator, the model derives a solution for the potential using a non-linear formulation of the classic flow equation and can accommodate prescribed-head or prescribed-flux boundary conditions at inland boundaries, as well as time-varying head conditions at the shore boundaries, which is crucial for addressing long-term sea-level rise (SLR). Noteworthy modifications enable the model to estimate land subsidence through a 1D vertical consolidation model directly in terms of potential, providing a holistic view of aquifer dynamics. The model is successfully tested against analytically based solutions and can facilitate swift calculations of aquifer vulnerability indicators, such as SWI toe location, increase in dissolved salt mass, and apparent land subsidence due to compounded effects of SLR, groundwater pumping, and long-term variable recharge conditions. Our presentation will showcase the model's features, preliminary results focusing on the effects of aquifer heterogeneities on the intensity of SWI and land subsidence patterns, model strengths and limitations. Emphasis will be placed on the model computational efficiency, enabling rapid estimation of crucial SWI indicators. Furthermore, the discussion will outline future steps, highlighting the need to balance the simplicity of working hypotheses with the computational demands of more intricate variable density models in assessing complex coastal aquifer dynamics.

How to cite: Yu, W., Baù, D., Christelis, V., and Geranmehr, M.: A Model for Fast Estimation of Seawater Intrusion in Coastal Aquifers: Simulating Flow and Land Subsidence, EGU General Assembly 2024, Vienna, Austria, 14–19 Apr 2024, EGU24-21064, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu24-21064, 2024.

12:10–12:20
|
EGU24-6862
|
On-site presentation
Kazunori Tabe and Masaatsu Aichi

Visualization methods using transparent synthetic soils (TSS) have been developed as a physical model of macroscopic soil behavior from a geotechnical engineering perspective. Transparent surrogates containing transparent porous media and pore fluids have been used to simulate the geotechnical properties of natural soils. Studies to experimentally verify local deformation in subsidence phenomena require the use of inexpensive laboratory industrial materials to understand the macroscopic scale of larger test models. TSS made of polymeric polymers used in this experiment are one of those employed to accomplish this need and are easy to handle.

In the present study, a larger-scale pumping test than previously reported was conducted using a 300 mm wide x 250 mm long x 249 mm high acrylic tank filled with transparent hydrated polymer to represent an aquitard (clay layer) over an aquifer (saturated silica sand). Settlement within the synthetic clay layer due to pumping of pore water from the silica sand was constantly monitored by the target racking method using 100 particles of 3 mm diameter immersed in the synthetic clay layer. This experiment successfully visualized the deformation inside TSS due to vertical propagation of pore water pressure in the TSS during pumping and after pumping, in more detail than in the previous experiment. The experimental results showed good agreement with the numerical results of the three-dimensional pore-plastic deformation theory.

How to cite: Tabe, K. and Aichi, M.: Visualization technique in a laboratory experiment for the deformation distributions of subsidence of aquitard over aquifer due to excess pumping, EGU General Assembly 2024, Vienna, Austria, 14–19 Apr 2024, EGU24-6862, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu24-6862, 2024.

12:20–12:30
|
EGU24-8379
|
ECS
|
On-site presentation
Pepijn van Elderen, Gilles Erkens, Cor Zwanenburg, Henk Kooi, and Esther Stouthamer

Peat soils typically have a high void ratio and compressibility. As a result, land subsidence is a common threat to peatlands. Geotechnical models are used to predict subsidence and the spatial variation therein to assess the potential for land subsidence and the effect of mitigation measures. In these models compaction is often calculated using parameters describing the consolidation and creep behaviour of the soil. Consolidation, a result of excess pore pressure dissipation, is calculated using the compression (CR) and recompression ratios (RR) together with the effective stress and preconsolidation stress. Creep, viscous compression unrelated to dissipation of excess pore pressure, is calculated using an independent secondary compression parameter (Cα) and the preconsolidation stress which are derived from laboratory compression tests. Pristine peat soils have a much higher high organic content (OC), a higher compressibility and are more susceptible to creep than clay soils. This study explores the relation between compressibility and OC by looking at the OC end members, peat and clay, and specifically looking for patterns in mixtures of the two.

A large collection of compression test data is used to evaluate the relation between the compressibility of peat and its organic content. Holocene peat and fluvial and marine clay samples from the Netherlands are analysed. The composition of the samples is described by parameters such as wet unit weight, water content and organic content. A relation between water content and loss-on-ignition was determined by fitting a trend to a different extensive collection of Holocene and lake-infill peat samples from the Netherlands. This relation was used to acquire OC for all compression test samples. Analysis results show that for low OC (<30%) samples values of CR, RR as well as Cα increase with increasing OC following a significant trend. The high OC (>30%) samples show relatively high values for all three parameters compared low OC, about twice as high on average, but due to high variability in these values no trend can be discerned.

These differences between the low and high OC results point out that compressibility is related to the OC for clay rich samples, whereas the compressibility of organic rich samples is not dictated solely by the OC. Using this outcome a distinction was made between clay-dominated and peat-dominated compaction behaviour. This analysis enables an estimation of the three compaction model parameters for clay-rich samples based on the OC. Hence, for example, an OC-dependent Cα can improve subsidence modelling compared to a static Cα which does not incorporate changes in soil composition over time: loss of OC of peat soils and organic clays via oxidation or anoxic decomposition will influence the compressibility of the soil rather than or besides the volume loss directly linked to the loss of organic content. This will alter the way we calculate not only compaction but might also impact the calculation of greenhouse gas emission as a result of decomposition, which is a current topic within land subsidence.

How to cite: van Elderen, P., Erkens, G., Zwanenburg, C., Kooi, H., and Stouthamer, E.: The relationship between organic content and compressibility of peat and clay soils, EGU General Assembly 2024, Vienna, Austria, 14–19 Apr 2024, EGU24-8379, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu24-8379, 2024.

Posters on site: Tue, 16 Apr, 16:15–18:00 | Hall X3

Display time: Tue, 16 Apr, 14:00–Tue, 16 Apr, 18:00
Chairpersons: Makan Karegar, Roberta Bonì
X3.75
|
EGU24-16286
|
ECS
Jenny Soonthornrangsan, Mark Bakker, and Femke C. Vossepoel

Accurate and precise subsidence simulation is greatly influenced by limited availability of data, specifically input forcings/drivers and calibration data. In this study, an ensemble-based data-assimilation method is used to improve the estimates of land subsidence in Bangkok, Thailand, which is simulated by a linked data-driven and physics-based modeling approach. The approach models land subsidence caused by groundwater pumping at observation well nests and deals with limited data availability. A data-driven time series analysis method is first utilized to model groundwater heads in aquifers, which then serves as boundary conditions to a one-dimensional land subsidence model.  Simulated land subsidence near an observation well nest is a compaction-based, vertical estimate that assumes elastoplasticity. The assimilation of uncertain head observation data results in an estimate of the probability distributions of various state and parameter values based on the model, data, and their uncertainties. Results consist of an improved land subsidence estimation and uncertainty quantification. In Bangkok, the approach is applied with limited groundwater and subsidence observations and only an estimate of basin-wide pumping. Prior to data assimilation, groundwater and subsidence dynamics are successfully captured at 23 well nest locations. The application of the data assimilation method provides an improved understanding of these dynamics in Bangkok through uncertainty quantification of heads and subsidence as well as related parameters. Ultimately, this study demonstrates the applicability of data assimilation to improve land subsidence estimates when dealing with data scarcity.  Risk assessments of relative sea-level rise of Bangkok and other deltaic regions depend on improving land subsidence estimates and associated uncertainty, which is essential for future flood mitigation efforts.

How to cite: Soonthornrangsan, J., Bakker, M., and Vossepoel, F. C.: Using data assimilation to improve land subsidence prediction from a data-driven and physics-based modeling approach: An application to Bangkok, Thailand, EGU General Assembly 2024, Vienna, Austria, 14–19 Apr 2024, EGU24-16286, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu24-16286, 2024.

X3.76
|
EGU24-7108
Asahi Makino and Masaatsu Aichi

. Due to the limited availability of core sample test data, the land subsidence modeling is often highly uncertain. On the other hand, the electrical logging data are frequently accessible and might give some information to constrain the spatial distribution of physical properties in land subsidence modeling. Therefore, this study tried to constrain land subsidence model using electrical logging data. The estimated physical properties, based on the combination of existing empirical relations between the resistivity and physical properties, were used as initial values for the model inversion. A calibration process was then conducted by adjusting the physical parameters to reproduce the observed land subsidence. As a result, the obtained sets of physical properties were within the range of typical values in the existing literatures and satisfactorily reproduced the observed subsidence. Furthermore, numerous possible parameter realizations were generated using the Null Space Monte Carlo method to analyze the uncertainty in both physical properties and future subsidence predictions. The results also suggested the potential to reduce the uncertainty of land subsidence predictions by easily available geophysical logging data.

How to cite: Makino, A. and Aichi, M.: One-dimensional land subsidence modelling constrained by electrical logging and its uncertainty analysis, EGU General Assembly 2024, Vienna, Austria, 14–19 Apr 2024, EGU24-7108, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu24-7108, 2024.

X3.77
|
EGU24-17366
|
ECS
Deniz Kılıç, Gilles Erkens, Kim M. Cohen, and Esther Stouthamer

The Netherlands confronts significant land subsidence challenges, primarily in the low-lying, densely populated soft soil regions. Land subsidence results from drainage or loading of the clayey and peaty shallow subsurface, extraction of groundwater or hydrocarbons, and local salt mining at deeper levels. These activities are compounded by natural subsidence processes such as local to regional tectonics, glacial isostatic adjustment, and autocompaction. The impacts of land subsidence are further exacerbated by global warming and rising sea levels. While Dutch institutions acknowledge the escalating economic costs of land subsidence (e.g. Van den Born et al., 2016), the prevailing land management practices, essential for current economic activities, contribute to a policy lock-in (Seijger et al., 2017), necessitating sustainable alternatives.

Our research aims to quantify explicitly the individual shallow processes of land subsidence (i.e. compression, peat oxidation) and establish their relative contributions using Atlantis, a process-based 3D land subsidence model integrated with the GeoTOP geological framework that represents the subsurface build-up and properties. This model serves as a tool for developing regional land subsidence projections up to 2100 across the Netherlands. By leveraging a combination of advanced local and regional observation data, including novel processed InSAR products, and recent findings from key national research initiatives like NWA-LOSS, NOBV, DeepNL, and Regiodeal Groene Hart, we gain a more refined understanding of subsidence processes which will be implemented in the model. Here we present the initial results of our approach by calculating the extent of human-induced shallow subsidence in the Netherlands for different future land subsidence scenarios. These scenarios were developed via a back casting method, encompassing extremes like no subsidence, minimal damage, and cessation of shallow drainage. We highlight the importance of combining numerical modelling with policy development methods such as back casting to test and evaluate optimal management pathways.

Building on previous land subsidence projections (Erkens et al., 2017), our approach integrates novel data and improved process understanding. A significant advancement of our study is the incorporation of an impact quantification module. This module translates the land subsidence projections (mm.yr-1) and greenhouse gas emissions from peatlands (tonnes.yr-1) into economic terms (EUR.yr-1). This approach enables us to link the regional land subsidence to economic implications under various future projections. This tool could also help policymakers to gain insights via societal cost-benefit analyses to assess the socio-economic impacts of different adaptation and mitigation strategies.  This research is pivotal in exploring and finding alternative pathways on managing land subsidence in the Netherlands, therefore providing new perspectives on how to break the current policy lock-in. 

References

Erkens, G., Stafleu, J., and Van den Akker, J. J. H. (2017). Bodemdalingvoorspellingskaarten van Nederland, versie 2017, Deltares rapport klimaateffectatlas, 2017. 

Seijger, C., Ellen, G. J., Janssen, S., Verheijen, E., & Erkens, G. (2017). Sinking deltas: trapped in a dual lock-in of technology and institutions. Prometheus, 35(3), 193-213.

Van den Born, G. J., Kragt, F., Henkens, D., Rijken, B., Van Bemmel, B., and Van der Sluis, S. (2016). Dalende bodems, Stijgende kosten, Report Planning Agency for the Environment (PBL), report nr. 1064, 93 pp., 2016

How to cite: Kılıç, D., Erkens, G., Cohen, K. M., and Stouthamer, E.: Managing Land Subsidence in the Netherlands: A Process-Based Modelling Approach to Evaluate Alternative Sustainable Pathways, EGU General Assembly 2024, Vienna, Austria, 14–19 Apr 2024, EGU24-17366, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu24-17366, 2024.

X3.78
|
EGU24-13137
|
ECS
|
Highlight
Valentina Maoret, Thibault Candela, Ylona van Dinther, Kay Koster, Pietro Teatini, Jan Diederik van Wees, and Claudia Zoccarato

Here, the outline of a new research project focused on predicting land subsidence in urban areas in the Netherlands is presented. The need for subsidence predictions at a scale comparable to building size and the potential additional effect due to the presence of building are the key points of the present contribution. The final objective is to disentangle the relative subsidence contribution of the presence of building in one selected urban area in the Netherlands.

Land subsidence induced by human activities is a well-known issue. In the Netherlands, as well as worldwide, multiple subsurface activities covering a wide spectrum of depths (such as hydrocarbon extraction, salt mining, groundwater withdrawal) can lead to subsidence. In urban areas this inflicts damage to buildings and infrastructure, leading to high costs and hazardous situations. A complicating factor in urban areas  is that the presence of the built environment also itself influences the processes of subsidence. To address these challenges, we intend to fill out two big knowledge gaps.

The first challenge in predicting subsidence in urban areas is the relatively small spatial-scale of the subsidence processes, i.e. scale smaller than buildings. This requires the spatial downscaling of existing modelling approaches. Since damages to buildings are driven by small-scale spatial subsidence fluctuations, our current large-scale subsidence predictions are almost meaningless for urban areas.

The second one consists of assessing the effect of urbanization itself on land subsidence. Our current subsidence models disregard the presence of the build environment and thus this potential additional effect in urban areas, like the presence of buildings, needs to be implemented. To achieve our goal we plan to combine multiple data sources (building locations/weights/years of construction, InSAR, LiDAR, and Cone Penetration Tests) with physics-based and ML-based models.

How to cite: Maoret, V., Candela, T., van Dinther, Y., Koster, K., Teatini, P., van Wees, J. D., and Zoccarato, C.: Land subsidence induced by urbanization: towards building damage predictions, EGU General Assembly 2024, Vienna, Austria, 14–19 Apr 2024, EGU24-13137, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu24-13137, 2024.

X3.79
|
EGU24-15985
Cristina Da Lio, Marta Cosma, Sandra Donnici, Massimiliano Ferronato, Annamaria Mazzia, Pietro Teatini, Luigi Tosi, and Claudia Zoccarato

Coastal transitional environments (CTE) are among the most productive ecosystems in the world, supporting various natural functions and providing important ecosystem services to human societies. Because of their low elevation, CTE are expected to be severely threatened by the accelerated sea-level rise (SLR) and their resilience will depend on the capability to keep pace with SLR. Recent field studies and modelling analyses suggests that Holocene events in terms of sedimentation rates and distribution of lithology could significantly influence the evolution and resilience of CTE with expected climate changes. Using the Venice Lagoon (Italy) as a case study, the RESTORE (i.e. REconstruct subsurface heterogeneities and quantify sediment needs TO improve the REsilience of Venice saltmarshes) project proposes a new multidisciplinary approach that combines geological conceptualizations, numerical modelling and vulnerability assessment to quantify the amount of sediment that CTE need to keep pace with the relative SLR. Specific attention is paid to the type of deposits and shallow subsurface architecture that play a key role in the process of land subsidence and autocompaction, i.e., the natural compaction caused by sediment self-weight. Specifically, the RESTORE workflow includes developing a detailed 3D reconstruction of the Holocene stratigraphic architecture and associated geomechanical properties, developing a numerical model that can simulate the evolution of elevations and natural subsidence over the Holocene, and developing a vulnerability assessment able to highlight the areas of the lagoon most threatened by SLR. Expected results include the evaluation of quantitative data on the sediments needed to keep pace with IPCC projected sea-level rise and the production of  vulnerability maps of tidal morphologies to different sea-level rise scenarios to assist policymakers in developing restoration, conservation, and mitigation plans.

How to cite: Da Lio, C., Cosma, M., Donnici, S., Ferronato, M., Mazzia, A., Teatini, P., Tosi, L., and Zoccarato, C.: Rethinking the resilience of salt marshes to land subsidence and sea-level rise: The RESTORE project approach, EGU General Assembly 2024, Vienna, Austria, 14–19 Apr 2024, EGU24-15985, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu24-15985, 2024.

X3.80
|
EGU24-21780
|
ECS
A Multiscale Evaluation of Soil Consolidation Concerning Land Subsidence and Integrated Mechanism Analysis in Typical Reclamation Areas
(withdrawn after no-show)
Qingbo Yu, Qing Wang, Jianping Chen, Fengyan Wang, Huie Chen, Boxin Wang, and Meng Yao
X3.81
|
EGU24-8808
Masaatsu Aichi

The recent progresses in the monitoring techniques for land subsidence such as InSAR or GNSS provide the huge datasets available for the calibration of numerical models. However, the observed land surface displacement possibly includes the structural noise caused by the tectonic motion or land subsidence caused by unknown groundwater abstraction while the land subsidence model usually considers the effect only from the known groundwater abstraction. Then, the land subsidence model inversion is not straightforward because such structural noises may affect the inversion results if the observed land surface displacement is directly used for the calibration target.

The author proposes a new evaluation function based on the rotation energy of the estimated structural noise to avoid the interference from the structural noise in the inversion procedure. By replacing the typical evaluation function such as root mean square error with the proposed evaluation function, the inversion procedure can focus only on the reproducibility of the land subsidence caused by the known groundwater abstraction.

The performance of the proposed method was tested by the several synthetic land subsidence data composed of the displacement caused by the known and unknown groundwater abstraction calculated by the numerical model with the assumed physical parameter distribution, the typical tectonic motion, and the random noise. The proposed method successfully separated the land subsidence caused by the known groundwater abstraction and other components, and successfully reproduced the model parameters used in the numerical model to make synthetic land subsidence data.

How to cite: Aichi, M.: Land subsidence model inversion with the structural noise of tectonic motion and unknown groundwater abstraction, EGU General Assembly 2024, Vienna, Austria, 14–19 Apr 2024, EGU24-8808, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu24-8808, 2024.

X3.82
|
EGU24-21787
|
ECS
Land subsidence monitoring based on SBAS-InSAR and prediction using ARIMA-BP model in typical oil exploitation areas
(withdrawn after no-show)
Fengyan Wang, Xiang Wu, Kai Zhou, Qingbo Yu, Jianping Chen, and Qing Wang
X3.83
|
EGU24-15465
Sree Ram Radha Krishnan, Makan A. Karegar, Jürgen Kusche, Simon E. Engelhart, Andrew C. Kemp, and Juliet P. Sefton

Relative sea level (RSL) reconstructions using radiocarbon-dated mangrove sediment from Pohnpei Island, Federated States of Micronesia, in Remote Oceania reveal that RSL rose at an average rate of 0.7 mm/yr since 5,700 years BP. This is contrary to the predictions of Glacial Isostatic Adjustment (GIA) models that suggest a RSL fall. This RSL rise was attributed to ongoing subsidence supported by GPS CORS (Continuously Operating Reference Station) on the coastal plain of the island directly measuring subsidence at 1.0 ± 0.2 mm/yr over 2003-2021 (Sefton et al., 2022, PNAS). The availability of Sentinel-1 SAR data for Pohnpei presents a unique opportunity to further investigate subsidence and independently evaluate the trends inferred from proxy RSL records and GPS CORS.

To create a robust vertical land motion (VLM) map of the island, we employed the coherence-based Small Baseline Subset (SBAS) method for InSAR analysis of Sentinel-1 data. This generated a high-resolution VLM map that provides detailed insights into deformation patterns across the island from 2016 to 2021. Application of corrections for tropical atmospheric condition and tidal loading significantly improved the results. We found an average subsidence rate of 0.89 mm/yr with a Root Mean Square Error (RMSE) of 2.47 mm/yr. The InSAR findings validate the previous results indicating island-scale subsidence of Pohnpei.

How to cite: Radha Krishnan, S. R., A. Karegar, M., Kusche, J., E. Engelhart, S., C. Kemp, A., and P. Sefton, J.: InSAR illuminates Pohnpei island's subsidence, validating GNSS and late Holocene seal-level data, EGU General Assembly 2024, Vienna, Austria, 14–19 Apr 2024, EGU24-15465, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu24-15465, 2024.

X3.84
|
EGU24-18690
|
ECS
Miao Ye, Lin Zhu, Pietro Teatini, Andrea Franceschini, and Jie Yu

Land subsidence and earth fissures are geological hazards caused by groundwater withdrawal and influenced by a variety of factors, including complex geological structures and heterogeneous lithological sequences. These settings characterize the mechanism and evolution of these processes, whose understanding is important for both risk management and sustainable development of subsurface resources.

To model the progression of land subsidence into earth fissures presents a notable challenge when applying classic continuum mechanics theory based on differential equations. This challenge arises from the intrinsic contradiction between the continuous nature of the theoretical framework and the actual discontinuous reality observed in earth fissures. Conversely, peridynamics offers a solution by employing equilibrium equation based on an integral formulation that is mathematically compatible with any discontinuity.

This study develops an efficient procedure based on ordinary state-based peridynamics theory to simulate the evolution of land subsidence into earth fissures. The modified Coulomb failure criterion is applied to identify the locations and timing of fissure development, as well as their geometric characteristics, such as length, depth, offset, and opening. This approach is applied to the Chaobai River alluvial fan in Beijing, China, an area where numerous earth fissures have emerged over the past decades, posing threats to structures and infrastructures. The Gaoliying earth fissures are the most severe in Beijing and are distributed along the pre-existing Huangzhuang-Gaoliying normal fault system. InSAR has revealed an uneven land subsidence on the hanging wall and footwall of the fault, with more severe subsidence occurring on the latter. This complex deformation pattern has contributed to a poor understanding of the mechanism governing the formation and evolution of these earth fissures. This study provides an effective approach toward comprehending the generation and propagation of earth fissures induced by aquifer exploitation in this area and in other faulted basins worldwide.

How to cite: Ye, M., Zhu, L., Teatini, P., Franceschini, A., and Yu, J.: Peridynamics modelling of earth fissures associated to aquifer exploitation and pre-existing normal faults with applications to Beijing, China, EGU General Assembly 2024, Vienna, Austria, 14–19 Apr 2024, EGU24-18690, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu24-18690, 2024.

X3.85
|
EGU24-10558
|
Highlight
Roberta Bonì, Francesca Cigna, Pietro Teatini, Roberta Paranunzio, and Claudia Zoccarato

High to very high susceptibility and hazard levels of land subsidence have been identified in several Italian regions: Emilia-Romagna and Veneto regions, where loss of land elevation up to 7 cm/year in the Po River Plain impacts 30% of the Italian population since the 1950s; Puglia, e.g. at Tavoliere Plain, with land subsidence up to 2 cm/year; the Florence-Prato-Pistoia Plain in Tuscany and the Volturno Plain in Campania, with more 2 cm/year; the Gioia Tauro Plain in Calabria with more than 1 cm/year.

Assessing the contribution of urbanization and the growth in urban population to this process is still a challenging task.

The SubRISK+ project is aimed to provide new Earth observation-derived products and tools to improve the comprehension of current and future land subsidence in major urbanized areas of Italy. The project is funded by the European Union – Next Generation EU, in the framework of the Research Projects of Significant National Interest (PRIN) - National Recovery and Resilience Plan (PNRR) call 2022, and it is led by the National Research Council of Italy in Rome with the collaboration of the University School for Advanced Studies of Pavia and the University of Padua.

In particular, the risk associated to land subsidence will be investigated for the 15 metropolitan cities of Italy and the Emilia Romagna region by exploiting Copernicus’ European Ground Motion Service (EGMS) data.

Satellite-based Interferometric Synthetic Aperture Radar (InSAR) observations will be employed to map the current land subsidence and assess the potential induced damages to urban infrastructures.

Then, a multidisciplinary approach incorporating geological, hydrogeological, geotechnical, land use data, and ground displacement observations will be implemented to disentangle the contribution of various processes and evaluate the associated triggers.

The activities will be performed across national, regional, and local scales. The use of advanced groundwater flow and geomechanics model for a “hotspot city” case study will allow to quantify the effects of groundwater exploitation and estimate uncertainties in land subsidence.

Market and non-market direct/indirect losses will be assessed at national, regional, and local scales via a newly developed socio-economic impact analysis, based on the exposure, vulnerability, and resilience of the investigated urbanized areas. Finally, future land subsidence risk scenarios will be estimated in the medium (2050) and long term (2100).

How to cite: Bonì, R., Cigna, F., Teatini, P., Paranunzio, R., and Zoccarato, C.: Assessing and mapping of land subsidence risk at different scales in major urban areas in Italy , EGU General Assembly 2024, Vienna, Austria, 14–19 Apr 2024, EGU24-10558, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu24-10558, 2024.

X3.86
|
EGU24-20524
|
ECS
Muhannad Hammad, Esther Stouthamer, and Gilles Erkens

Land subsidence is a major challenge in many parts of the Netherlands, and in order to develop practically plausible scenarios and pathways of possible mitigation and adaptation measures under inclusive governance, it is necessary to study and analyse historical land subsidence data in the Netherlands.

This study leverages the estimated ground-surface displacement amount from "Bodemdalingskaart.nl" based on remote sensing data from Sentinel-1 processed data every twelve days for five consecutive years from October 2017 to October 2022. The main goal of this study is to identify places that have significant land subsidence values, which is a critical stage in determining which and where mitigation and adaptation measures might be implemented.

More than 4 million land subsidence scatterer points throughout the whole Netherlands were analysed to identify locations with high subsidence values, and the results were then interpolated with administrative and elevation maps of the Netherlands, allowing for the extraction of high-resolution data that provides detailed insights into land subsidence patterns across the entire Netherlands. In total, 155 locations were recognized as having significant land subsidence values; in our analysis, the significant value was set as 3 mm/year. The 155 identified locations were distributed among all twelve provinces. Moreover, 60 of the 155 locations were located in areas below sea level, mainly in the six western provinces from Groningen in the north to Zeeland in the south, indicating a high risk of flooding in these places in the future if relative sea level rise (RSLR) is taken into consideration.

The identified places that exhibit significant land subsidence values should be subjected in the next stage to further assessment and evaluation through 3D modelling,  damage assessment, and Social Cost Benefit Analysis (SCBA) to allow the stakeholders to effectively prioritize all possible mitigation and adaptation measures through an appropriate governance framework. By pinpointing the specific locations where land subsidence has relatively significant values, different scenarios and pathways for different mitigation and adaptation measures could be developed to address the adverse effects of land subsidence on all affected parties in the Netherlands, both in urban and rural areas.

In summary, this study uses the extensive land subsidence point data supplied by "Bodemdalingskaart.nl" to investigate the patterns and features of land subsidence across the Netherlands. Leveraging land subsidence point data provided a more meaningful knowledge of the spatial distribution of significant land subsidence values in the Netherlands, allowing for the identification of places where more attention and further investigation are required.

How to cite: Hammad, M., Stouthamer, E., and Erkens, G.: An analysis of remote sensing land subsidence data in the Netherlands, EGU General Assembly 2024, Vienna, Austria, 14–19 Apr 2024, EGU24-20524, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu24-20524, 2024.