AS3.32 | Remote Sensing of Carbon Dioxide and Methane from Space
Remote Sensing of Carbon Dioxide and Methane from Space
Convener: Matthaeus Kiel | Co-conveners: Dietrich G. Feist, Maximilian Reuter, Sander Houweling, Neil Humpage
Orals
| Thu, 18 Apr, 16:15–18:00 (CEST)
 
Room M1
Posters on site
| Attendance Thu, 18 Apr, 10:45–12:30 (CEST) | Display Thu, 18 Apr, 08:30–12:30
 
Hall X5
Posters virtual
| Attendance Thu, 18 Apr, 14:00–15:45 (CEST) | Display Thu, 18 Apr, 08:30–18:00
 
vHall X5
Orals |
Thu, 16:15
Thu, 10:45
Thu, 14:00
Significant uncertainties exist in our understanding of Carbon Dioxide (CO2) and Methane (CH4) fluxes between land, ocean, and the terrestrial atmosphere on regional and global scales. Remotely-sensed CO2 and CH4 observations provide a significant potential for improving our understanding of the natural carbon cycle and for monitoring anthropogenic emissions. Over the last few years, remote sensing technologies for measuring CO2 and CH4 from space, aircraft, and from the ground made great advances offering unprecedented accuracy and coverage. Additionally, upcoming and planned next-generation platforms such as CO2M, MicroCarb, GOSAT-GW, and MethaneSAT are set to substantially improve observational capabilities. When integrated with data from ground-based observation networks and modeling tools, these space-based observations have the potential to significantly enhance our understanding of the carbon cycle on both local and global scales.

This session is open to contributions related to all aspects of remote sensing of the greenhouse gases CO2 and CH4 from current missions (e.g. GOSAT/2, OCO-2/3, S5P, GHGSat, etc.), upcoming and planned satellite missions (e.g. CO2M, MicroCarb, Merlin, GOSAT-GW, MethaneSAT, etc.), as well as ground-based (e.g., TCCON, COCCON), aircraft, and other remote sensing instruments. This includes advances in retrieval techniques, instrumental concepts, and validation activities, but we specifically encourage contributions that focus on the interpretation of observations with respect to natural fluxes or anthropogenic emissions.

Orals: Thu, 18 Apr | Room M1

Chairpersons: Matthaeus Kiel, Dietrich G. Feist, Maximilian Reuter
16:15–16:20
16:20–16:30
|
EGU24-21273
|
solicited
|
Virtual presentation
Andrew Thorpe, Robert Green, David Thompson, Philip Brodrick, Adam Chlus, Jay Fahlen, Red Willow Coleman, Katherine Dana Chadwick, and Michael Eastwood

Imaging spectrometers like NASA’s Earth Surface Mineral Dust Source Investigation (EMIT) and the Airborne Visible/Infrared Imaging Spectrometer 3 (AVIRIS-3) have similar instrument parameters and methane and CO2 mapping capability that enables direct attribution of observed plumes to the oil and gas, waste, and agriculture sectors. Onboard the International Space Station, EMIT can constrain methane and CO2 emissions over a significant portion of the Earth’s surface. With improved spatial resolution, the airborne AVIRIS-3 instrument enables quantification of smaller emissions sources that compliment EMIT observations from space.

We provide an update of EMIT methane and CO2 observations to date and highlight examples from the oil and gas, waste, and agriculture sectors. For the first time, we present AVIRIS-3 methane and CO2 results. The fine spatial resolution of these instruments allows pinpointing of multiple emission sources in close proximity from different sectors, which is not possible with coarser spatial resolution instruments. These instruments offer the potential to improve understanding of greenhouse gas budgets, inform mitigation strategies, and in some cases lead to voluntary mitigation.

In support of NASA’s Open Source Science Initiative, all EMIT data and greenhouse gas data products are available through the Land Processes Distributed Active Archive Center (LP DAAC) and code is open source. EMIT results are also available through the greenhouse gas applications online mapping tool (https://earth.jpl.nasa.gov/emit/data/data-portal/Greenhouse-Gfases/) and U.S. Greenhouse Gas Center (https://earth.gov/ghgcenter/).

Figure 1: Over 900 methane plume complexes observed by NASA’s Earth Surface Mineral Dust Source Investigation (EMIT) are available through the EMIT greenhouse gas applications online mapping tool (https://earth.jpl.nasa.gov/emit/data/data-portal/Greenhouse-Gfases/) and U.S. Greenhouse Gas Center (https://earth.gov/ghgcenter/).

How to cite: Thorpe, A., Green, R., Thompson, D., Brodrick, P., Chlus, A., Fahlen, J., Coleman, R. W., Chadwick, K. D., and Eastwood, M.: Attributing methane and carbon dioxide plumes by emission sector with the EMIT and AVIRIS-3 imaging spectrometers, EGU General Assembly 2024, Vienna, Austria, 14–19 Apr 2024, EGU24-21273, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu24-21273, 2024.

16:30–16:40
|
EGU24-11680
|
On-site presentation
Michal Galkowski, Julia Marshall, Blanca Fuentes Andrade, and Christoph Gerbig

Greenhouse gases have been extensively studied due to their key role in of Earth’s climate. Their anthropogenic fluxes are of particular interest for policies targeting the mitigation of climate change, as their long lifetimes, especially in case of most abundant CO2, will have an impact over several centuries. Monitoring of emissions is a critical part of climate mitigation, as without timely, accurate and precise information on the implementation progress, any potential diversions from the plan cannot be identified and acted upon in sufficient time. The scientific community has developed multiple observation-based emission estimation methods, among which application of space- and airborne state-of-the-art instrumentation hold much promise out thanks to their ability to provide relevant data on a global scale. Modern remote-sensing instruments have already demonstrated the ability to estimate emission from the strongest sources of greenhouse gases, like coal power plants, megacities or industrial sites. However, due to inherent technical difficulties as well as basic atmospheric physics, the accuracy of any single measurement is limited.

Here, using the high-resolution atmospheric model WRF-GHG set over the largest point-like CO2 emitter in Europe, namely the Bełchatów Power plant, we demonstrate how atmospheric dynamics limit the potential accuracy of emission estimation using the cross-sectional mass-flux method. We show how atmospheric turbulence affects the plume structure, and how that translates into emission estimates. We demonstrate how assumptions about well-mixedness can cause inaccuracies in emission estimates. Furthermore, through a novel application of temporally-tagged tracers, we also show that part of the CO2 plume variability is projected from the emission point across distances considerably longer than PBL turbulent scales, larger than was previously assumed.

Unless the discussed effects can be taken into the account when planning, executing and interpreting measurements, the discussed effects can have potentially detrimental consequences for the accuracy of estimated flux values. It is worth noting that the presented results are of general nature and will affect attempts to quantify emissions of any pollutant for which similar estimation techniques are applied, including CO2 and CH4, NOx and others.

How to cite: Galkowski, M., Marshall, J., Fuentes Andrade, B., and Gerbig, C.: Impact of atmospheric turbulence on the accuracy of point source emission estimates, EGU General Assembly 2024, Vienna, Austria, 14–19 Apr 2024, EGU24-11680, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu24-11680, 2024.

16:40–16:50
|
EGU24-6681
|
ECS
|
On-site presentation
Bertrand Rouet-Leduc and Claudia Hulbert

Methane is one of the most potent greenhouse gases, and its short atmospheric half-life makes it a prime target to rapidly curb global warming. However, current methane emission monitoring techniques primarily rely on approximate emission factors or self-reporting, which have been shown to often dramatically underestimate emissions.

Although initially designed to monitor surface properties, satellite multispectral data has recently emerged as a powerful method to analyze atmospheric content. However, the spectral resolution of multispectral instruments is poor, and methane measurements are typically very noisy. Methane data products are also sensitive to absorption by the surface and other atmospheric gases (water vapor in particular) and therefore provide noisy maps of potential methane plumes, that typically require extensive human analysis.

Here we show that the image recognition capabilities of deep learning methods can be leveraged to automatize the detection of methane leaks in Sentinel-2 satellite multispectral data, with dramatically reduced false positive rates compared with state-of-the-art multispectral methane data products, and without the need for a priori knowledge of potential leak sites.

Our proposed approach is validated on thousands of catalogued leaks from AVIRIS-NG and GAO airborne detection campaigns, and paves the way for the automated, high-definition and high-frequency monitoring of point-source methane emissions across the world.

How to cite: Rouet-Leduc, B. and Hulbert, C.: Global automatic detection of methane emissions in Sentinel 2 data using deep learning, EGU General Assembly 2024, Vienna, Austria, 14–19 Apr 2024, EGU24-6681, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu24-6681, 2024.

16:50–17:00
|
EGU24-17625
|
On-site presentation
Jochen Landgraf, Pepijn Veefkind, Ryan Cooney, Manu Goudar, Raul Laasner, Zeger de Groot, and Nurcan Alpay Koc

The Twin Anthropogenic Greenhouse Gas Observers (TANGO) mission is a pioneering Cubsat satellite mission comprising two satellites, TANGO-Carbon and TNAGO-Nitro. Secured by national funding Tango will be launched in the year 2027 and envisages a unique European contribution to monitoring globally and independently the emission of anthropogenic greenhouse gases CO2 and CH4 over the period 2027-2031. To this end, breakthrough technology will be used to quantify emissions of the greenhouse gases methane (CH4) and carbon dioxide (CO2) at the level of individual industrial facilities and power plants. The mission will demonstrate a distributed monitoring system that will pave the way for future larger constellations of Cubsats allowing for enhanced coverage and temporal resolution. The TANGO mission consists of two agile satellite buses flying in formation, each carrying one spectrometer. The first satellite measures spectral radiances in the shortwave infrared part of the solar spectrum (1.6 µm) to detect moderate to strong emissions of CH4 (≥ 5 kt/yr) and CO2 (≥ 2 Mt/yr). The instrument has a field of view of 30 x 30 km2 at spatial resolutions small enough to monitor individual large industrial facilities (300 x 300 m2), with accuracy to determine emissions based on a single observation. Using the same strategy, the second satellite yields collocated NO2 observations from radiance measurements in the visible spectral range, supporting plume detection and exploiting the use of CO2/NO2 ratio. TANGO will provide surface fluxes of specific emission types based on the combination of CH4, CO2, and NO2 observations at a high spatial resolution following a strictly open data policy. Mission operation will be open for input from the science community on target selection. In doing so, TANGO aims to uniquely complement the large, planned Copernicus monitoring missions like Sentinel-5 and the CO2M mission by providing unrivaled high-resolution monitoring of the major anthropogenic greenhouse gas emissions regularly. In this presentation, we will discuss the TANGO mission concept and its synergy with future Copernicus missions.

How to cite: Landgraf, J., Veefkind, P., Cooney, R., Goudar, M., Laasner, R., de Groot, Z., and Alpay Koc, N.: It Takes Two to Tango: The Twin Anthropogenic Greenhouse Gas Observers , EGU General Assembly 2024, Vienna, Austria, 14–19 Apr 2024, EGU24-17625, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu24-17625, 2024.

17:00–17:10
|
EGU24-5182
|
ECS
|
On-site presentation
Tobias A. de Jong, Joannes D. Maasakkers, Shubham Sharma, Berend Schuit, Matthieu Dogniaux, Paul Tol, Itziar Irakulis-Loitxate, Cynthia A. Randles, and Ilse Aben

Anthropogenic methane emissions play an important role in exacerbating climate change, and thus there is a need for accurate and timely monitoring and mitigation of these emissions. With daily global coverage, TROPOMI, onboard Sentinel-5P, maps methane concentrations at 5.5 x 7 km2 resolution and can detect methane super-emitters (>~8 t hr-1) globally [1,2]. Here, we show how we detect, attribute, and quantify methane emissions from super-emitters using TROPOMI in combination with information from high-resolution satellite instruments to support the UNEP IMEO Methane Alert Response System (MARS). To determine optimal targets for high-resolution hyperspectral observations (e.g. PRISMA, EnMAP), we combine longer term TROPOMI data over persistent emitters. When emissions are transient, we combine TROPOMI with data from non-targeted high-resolution band imagers (also known as multispectral sensors) such as Sentinel-2 and Sentinel-3 to trace emissions to facility-level emission sources, in particular oil and gas infrastructure [3]. We illustrate how the combination of satellites with different overpass times and different spatial resolutions gives a comprehensive picture of these emissions. To evaluate the detections, we compare methane enhancements retrieved from band imagers with values from TROPOMI. Even when overpass times do not match, we achieve this by using transient emissions that result in methane plumes with a constant total mass, once detached from the source. Finally, we show how combining information from multiple satellites enables critical evaluation of the winds taken from global reanalysis products that underlie almost all high-resolution emission quantifications based on mass-balance methods.

 

References

[1]        Maasakkers JD, Varon DJ, Elfarsdóttir A, McKeever J, Jervis D, Mahapatra G, et al. Using satellites to uncover large methane emissions from landfills. Sci Adv 2022;8:eabn9683. https://doi.org/10.1126/sciadv.abn9683.

[2]       Irakulis-Loitxate I, Guanter L, Maasakkers JD, Zavala-Araiza D, Aben I. Satellites Detect Abatable Super-Emissions in One of the World’s Largest Methane Hotspot Regions. Environ Sci Technol 2022;56:2143–52. https://doi.org/10.1021/acs.est.1c04873.

[3]       Pandey, Sudhanshu, et al. "Daily detection and quantification of methane leaks using Sentinel-3: a tiered satellite observation approach with Sentinel-2 and Sentinel-5p." Remote Sensing of Environment 296 (2023): 113716. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.rse.2023.113716

How to cite: de Jong, T. A., Maasakkers, J. D., Sharma, S., Schuit, B., Dogniaux, M., Tol, P., Irakulis-Loitxate, I., Randles, C. A., and Aben, I.: Combining TROPOMI with high-resolution satellites to detect, attribute, and monitor large methane emission events., EGU General Assembly 2024, Vienna, Austria, 14–19 Apr 2024, EGU24-5182, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu24-5182, 2024.

17:10–17:20
|
EGU24-9264
|
On-site presentation
Christoph Kiemle, Christian Fruck, Andreas Fix, Gerhard Ehret, Mathieu Quatrevalet, Michal Galkowski, and Christoph Gerbig

Airborne and satellite based lidar remote sensing combines the advantages of high measurement accuracy, large-area coverage and low-ambient-light measurement capability. The Merlin airborne demonstrator CHARM-F is an Integrated-Path Differential-Absorption (IPDA) lidar providing vertical column concentrations of carbon dioxide and methane up to the flight altitude along the flight track. It operated onboard the German HALO (high-altitude long-range) research aircraft during the CoMet 2.0 Arctic campaign in August and September 2022 over natural and anthropogenic sources of CO2 and CH4 in Canada. Natural methane fluxes from wetlands generally produce weak atmospheric concentration enhancements of the measured atmospheric column (<1%). To address this challenge, we initially use methane profiles from CAMS (Copernicus Atmosphere Monitoring Service) reanalyses to discard cases where long-range transport of methane within the free troposphere causes large gradients over the measurement area. We then use in-situ measurements of the Jena Instrument for Greenhouse gases (JIG) operating onboard the same aircraft to identify methane enhancements above wetlands during low-level flight segments within the boundary layer. Correlation analyses with lidar-detected enhancements above the same wetlands allow us to characterize the lidar detection limit. Aircraft in-situ wind measurements in the boundary layer provide plume drift and dilution information necessary for lidar-informed methane emission flux estimations using either the integrated mass enhancement (IME) approach or an upwind-downwind gradient analysis. Comparisons of the in-situ wind measurements with the CAMS wind fields reveal how well the fluxes can be assessed from solely remote sensing methane and model wind data in the absence of in-situ measurements. Measurement examples and preliminary results will be shown.

How to cite: Kiemle, C., Fruck, C., Fix, A., Ehret, G., Quatrevalet, M., Galkowski, M., and Gerbig, C.: Towards the Estimation of Canadian Wetland Methane Fluxes with Airborne Lidar, EGU General Assembly 2024, Vienna, Austria, 14–19 Apr 2024, EGU24-9264, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu24-9264, 2024.

17:20–17:30
|
EGU24-4484
|
ECS
|
On-site presentation
Beata Bukosa, Sara Mikaloff-Fletcher, Alex Geddes, Dave Pollard, Stuart Moore, Richard Law, Dave Noone, Maryann Sargent, Joshua Benmergui, and Steve Wofsy

MethaneSAT is a joint American and New Zealand satellite mission, which involves partnership between the Environmental Defense Fund (EDF), MethaneSAT LLC and New Zealand government. MethaneSAT’s primary mission is to detect and quantify methane (CH4) emissions from both point and area sources from the global oil and gas production industry in support of emissions reductions. MethaneSAT will target specific 200 km x 200 km regions and map CH4 within those regions at 100 m x 400 m resolution with unprecedented precision. The Aotearoa New Zealand team’s aim is to develop and test the ability of the satellite to detect agricultural CH4 emissions. New Zealand is an ideal place to develop this capability due to its large CH4 emissions, 85% of which are from agricultural sources. We will present results of modelled atmospheric CH4 concentrations for agricultural targets in New Zealand, emission estimates from the agricultural targets and CH4 measurements collected during a shakedown field campaign, in preparation for the MethaneSAT launch in 2024.

We use 1.5 km spatial resolution, New Zealand specific bottom-up CH4 fluxes and the Numerical Atmospheric dispersion Modelling Environment (NAME III), driven by meteorological input from the New Zealand Convective Scale Model (NZCSM, 1.5 km spatial resolution) Numerical Weather Prediction (NWP) model to create modelled agricultural XCH4 (column averaged) enhancements. The MethaneSAT-like targets are created for different scenarios to assess the changes in the XCH4 enhancements relative to meteorological conditions and bottom-up fluxes. We use the modelled agricultural XCH4 fields to test operational methods that are being developed for Level 4 products (i.e., emissions) in an Observing System Simulation Experiments (OSSE) framework and adapt them for diffuse agricultural sources. We will present results of modelled XCH4 scans for the main agricultural targets across New Zealand and the application of the MethaneSAT Level 4 methods (i.e., Geostatistical Inversion Framework, Divergence Integral Method) for agricultural sources.

The 2023 New Zealand MethaneSAT pre-launch shakedown field campaign took place over ten days in Waikato, a region with New Zealand’s strongest agricultural CH4 emissions. The campaign involved the deployment of two EM27/SUN portable spectrometers and in situ CH4 samplers. One EM27/SUN was at a fixed location for the duration of the campaign, while the second instrument was positioned up or downwind to measure enhancements of XCH4. Four remote sites were used, with measurements collected on multiple occasions and under different meteorological conditions. Typical XCH4 enhancements of between 3 and 8 ppb were observed while side-by-side measurements with the two spectrometers yielded a minimum detection limit of 0.3 ppb. Ground based and airborne in situ measurements were also collected to provide additional context to the measured enhancements. The measured XCH4 enhancements aligned with agricultural XCH4 estimates from the modelling framework. 

How to cite: Bukosa, B., Mikaloff-Fletcher, S., Geddes, A., Pollard, D., Moore, S., Law, R., Noone, D., Sargent, M., Benmergui, J., and Wofsy, S.: How well can MethaneSAT detect and quantify pastoral agricultural emissions?, EGU General Assembly 2024, Vienna, Austria, 14–19 Apr 2024, EGU24-4484, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu24-4484, 2024.

17:30–17:40
|
EGU24-14174
|
ECS
|
On-site presentation
kanwal Shahzadi, Matthias Schnider, Nga Ying Lo, Jörg Mayer, Cayoglu Ugur, Frank Hase, Peter Braesicke, Tobias Borsdorff, and Mari Martinez Velarte

Data products of atmospheric methane with improved vertical sensitivity in the lower troposphere are crucial for gaining a more comprehensive understanding of the impact of anthropogenic emissions. This study presents a methane data product derived from the synergistic combination of TROPOMI (Tropospheric Monitoring Instrument) total column and IASI (Infrared Atmospheric Sounding Interferometer) profiles, utilizing level 2 data spanning the period from 2018 to 2021. IASI enables high-quality retrievals in the upper troposphere-lower stratosphere, while TROPOMI observations excel in providing sensitivity to total-column-averaged CH4. The combined product retains the information from individual datasets and therefore enhances sensitivity to lower tropospheric signals independently of the upper troposphere, which is not achievable by using IASI or TROPOMI data alone.

We present a method for optimally combining the IASI and TROPOMI level 2 data. Firstly, the products from the individual satellites are collocated in time and space (geomatching). Subsequently, the collocated data are optimally merged by fully considering the individual data characteristics (uncertainties and sensitivities) by the application of a Kalman filter. We show that the procedure is robust and computationally cheap, which allows the efficient combination of billions of IASI and TROPOMI observations, and the combined product offers good global coverage.

The combined product is validated by comparison to reference datasets such as 14 globally distributed TCCON (Total Carbon Column Observing Network) stations, CH4 profile measurements made by 36 individual AirCore soundings, and tropospheric CH4 data derived from continuous ground-based in situ observations made at two nearby Global Atmospheric Watch (GAW) mountain stations. These comparisons confirm the theoretically predicted quality of the combined data product, in particular the increased quality of the tropospheric CH4 data.

Following the procedure outlined above, the final data product will consist of CH4 partial columns below and above 6000 m a.s.l. together with their respective averaging kernels and uncertainties and it will be made available as netCDF files that are compliant with version 1.7 of the CF metadata convention.

 

How to cite: Shahzadi, K., Schnider, M., Ying Lo, N., Mayer, J., Ugur, C., Hase, F., Braesicke, P., Borsdorff, T., and Velarte, M. M.: A multiannual and global synergetic satellite product of tropospheric CH4, EGU General Assembly 2024, Vienna, Austria, 14–19 Apr 2024, EGU24-14174, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu24-14174, 2024.

17:40–17:50
|
EGU24-13412
|
On-site presentation
Hiroshi Suto, Nobuhiro Kikuchi, Kei Shiomi, Tomohiro Oda, Tomoko Tashima, Fumie Kataoka, Kenji Kowata, and Akihiko Kuze

Space-based Greenhouse Gas (GHG) observations done by Japan’s Greenhouse Gas Observing Satellite (GOSAT) and NASA’s Orbiting Carbon Observatory (OCO) missions have collected long term and spatially dense CO2 data globally. The satellite GHG data have contributed to the monitoring of global CO2 concentrations and the detection of their regional and local changes. Given the high stake of the climate and environment applications, the evaluation of the space-based GHG data is a critical task. Space-based GHG data are often compared to data collected at ~ 30 Total Carbon Column Observing Network (TCCON) sites for examining potential biases and errors. Bias-correction methods are often developed based on the comparison to the TCCON data. While satellite GHG data products often show good agreement with TCCON data, we still see regional disagreements among different GHG data. We argue that the TCCON-based evaluation is powerful, but limited, and thus further evaluations of satellite GHG products are necessary. Recently, JAXA developed a new GOSAT GHG product named JAXA/GHG product. Our retrieval product includes total and partial column concentration values of CO2, CH4, H2O as well as solar-induced chlorophyll fluorescence (SIF). The JAXA/GHG GOSAT CO2 product is compared to NASA’s Atmospheric Carbon Observations from Space (ACOS)-GOSAT L2 full physics retrieval data, NASA’s OCO-2 satellite-based L2 full physics retrieval data, as well as simulated CO2 from the Carbon Tracker global atmospheric inversion system developed by NOAA Global Monitoring Laboratory. Our XCO2 comparisons with other satellite products show regional discrepancies over the Pacific Ocean, central Africa, south-east Asia (land), and Amazon areas. The results suggest that these discrepancies could be attributable to retrieved surface pressure and aerosol properties. We also compare near surface and upper tropospheric partial CO2 retrieved values to Carbon Tracker simulated values. These comparisons show the systematic positive discrepancy (~2-3 ppm) in JAXA’s near surface (surface to ~ 4km) CO2 concentration over the oceans against Carbon Tracker.

How to cite: Suto, H., Kikuchi, N., Shiomi, K., Oda, T., Tashima, T., Kataoka, F., Kowata, K., and Kuze, A.: Evaluating the JAXA GOSAT CO2 retrieval product using NASA CO2 retrieval products and NOAA Carbon Tracker, EGU General Assembly 2024, Vienna, Austria, 14–19 Apr 2024, EGU24-13412, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu24-13412, 2024.

17:50–18:00
|
EGU24-5350
|
ECS
|
On-site presentation
Benedikt Herkommer, Frank Hase, Jochen Groß, Carlos Alberti, Paolo Castracane, Angelika Dehn, Jia Chen, Florian Dietrich, Isamu Morino, Matthias Max Frey, Lawson Gillespie, Nasrin Mostafavi Pak, Debra Wunch, Nicholas Deutscher, Brittany Walker, and Omaira Elena García

The precise knowledge of the global atmospheric concentrations of green-house gases (GHG) are crucial for understanding and monitoring climate change.
Satellites for measuring GHGs are offering a global coverage, however, they need precise ground-based reference data for validation.
This reference data is provided by ground-based measurements, foremost the Total Column Carbon Observing Network (TCCON).
The TCCON measures column averages of GHG abundances at about 25 stations around the globe using Fourier Transform Infrared (FTIR) spectrometer.

For achieving the high data quality needed for the validation of current and upcoming GHG measuring satellite missions the control of site-by-site biases across the network is of utmost importance. So far, the verification of the individual TCCON sites mainly depends on the collection of collocated in situ measurements of GHG profiles, using airplane overflights or balloon air-core measurements, the use of calibrated HCl gas cells and on the evaluation of XAIR.
 
In this work we present a new supplemental approach by using the portable EM27/SUN FTIR spectrometer, which is the standard instrument of the Collaborative Carbon Column Observing Network (COCCON). This instrument type has proven its high stability in various field campaigns and long-term studies. In the framework of the ESA project “Fiducial Reference Measurements for Green-House Gases II” we are exploiting the stability of the instrument to use it as a Travel Standard (TS) for the TCCON. We visited sites in Japan, Canada, Germany, Australia, France and the Canary Islands to perform side-by-side measurements with the local TCCON spectrometers. Between the visits, the stability of the TS was monitored using the Karlsruhe TCCON site and the COCCON reference spectrometer.
This allows to compare the different TCCON sites to a common reference and hence, to verify the level of station-to-station consistency currently achieved by the TCCON and support further improvements. Here, we present the results of the TS visit at the TCCON site Tsukuba(Japan), Wollongong(Australia) and Izana(Canary Islands).

How to cite: Herkommer, B., Hase, F., Groß, J., Alberti, C., Castracane, P., Dehn, A., Chen, J., Dietrich, F., Morino, I., Frey, M. M., Gillespie, L., Pak, N. M., Wunch, D., Deutscher, N., Walker, B., and García, O. E.: Using a portable EM27/SUN FTIR-spectrometer for validating the TCCON site-to-site consistency: The COCCON Travel Standard, EGU General Assembly 2024, Vienna, Austria, 14–19 Apr 2024, EGU24-5350, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu24-5350, 2024.

Posters on site: Thu, 18 Apr, 10:45–12:30 | Hall X5

Display time: Thu, 18 Apr, 08:30–Thu, 18 Apr, 12:30
Chairpersons: Matthaeus Kiel, Dietrich G. Feist, Neil Humpage
X5.98
|
EGU24-8815
|
ECS
Carlos Alberti, Frank Hase, Darko Dubravica, Angelika Dehn, and Paolo Castracane

Year after year, the effects of climate change are more dramatic and evident, and it is no longer possible to hide them, which requires immediate action against anthropogenic emissions of greenhouse gases (GHGs) in Earth’s atmosphere, mainly carbon dioxide (CO2) and methane (CH4). The scientific community plays an important role in continuously developing and improving current instrumentation and methods, which enable high-resolution measurements to monitor, track, quantify, and verify the concentration and emissions of GHGs in the atmosphere.

Measuring GHGs with high accuracy in the atmosphere is challenging, but achieving measurements with global coverage is even more demanding, and only satellites can provide such data sets. However, they require ground-based column-integrating measurements for validation. For this purpose, the Total Carbon Column Observing Network (TCCON) was created; however, due to its high operational costs and the need for trained expertise on-site, the number of sites is limited (~ 26). Moreover, these stations are stationary, so performing observations of selected GHG source regions with several spectrometers is impossible. The COllaborative Carbon Column Observing Network (COCCON) was initiated to overcome these limitations and to supplement the existing TCCON stations. The standard instrument used by COCCON is the portable FTIR spectrometer EM27/SUN, developed by KIT in cooperation with Bruker Optics from 2011 onwards. Although this instrument has a lower spectral resolution (0.5 cm-1) in comparison to the TCCON instrument (0.002 cm-1), it delivers XCO2, XCH4, XH2O, and XCO with sufficient quality to complement TCCON satellite validation efforts.

COCCON data are tied to the trace gas scale as realized by the TCCON reference. COCOON ensures a high degree of internal consistency across the participating spectrometers, defines common standards for data processing, and performs quality assurance checks on individual spectrometers to ensure the quality of the network. The services of COCCON are enabled by ESA support. Meanwhile, one hundred twenty spectrometers have been optimized and characterized by the centralized testing facility operated at KIT, and many more units are expected to be commissioned in the months ahead. This contribution presents the current status of the activities of the central QA/QC facility: methods, results, and foreseen improvements.

How to cite: Alberti, C., Hase, F., Dubravica, D., Dehn, A., and Castracane, P.: The COllaborative Carbon Column Observing Network (COCCON) quality management., EGU General Assembly 2024, Vienna, Austria, 14–19 Apr 2024, EGU24-8815, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu24-8815, 2024.

X5.99
|
EGU24-20456
|
ECS
Hajar El Habchi El Fenniri and the MAGIC initiative group

Measuring the concentration of greenhouse gases (GHGs) has become a major concern in modern society because of the growing impact of human activity on the global climate system (Hui et al. 2022). Satellite observations give an unique opportunity to observe the GHGs total columns at a global scale, but these space missions need to be validated from ground-based measurements.

In order to enhance cal/val activities of current and future space missions and to better understand the spatial and vertical distributions of GHGs in different key regions for carbon and methane cycles, the MAGIC (Monitroing of Atmospheric composition and Greenhouse gases through multi-Instrument Campaigns) initiative was launched in 2018 by CNRS and CNES, brining now together more than fifteen international teams (https://magic.aeris-data.fr). Various instruments, including research aircrafts, balloons and ground-based measurements, have been used yearly over intensive measurement campaigns. The EM27/SUN Fourier Transform Spectrometer is one of the ground-based measurement instruments used as part of this initiative. This device offers the practical advantages of portability and access to  column mole fractions of dry air  of CO2, CH4, CO and H2O from solar spectra

The main objective of this study is to carry out a statistical evaluation of the EM27/SUN data collected during the MAGIC measurement campaigns. The EM27/SUN devices (LERMA, LSCE, GSMA, CNES and KIT) have been deployed at various measurement sites since 2018. For the last two years, 2022 and 2023, measurements of CO2 and CH4 total column have been carried out in the city of Reims as a pilot site representative of medium-sized cities on a European scale, with the aim of estimating emissions of the main greenhouse gases on a city scale. The results obtained can also be compared with data from current satellite missions (S5P, IASI, GOSAT-2) for cal/val purposes.

 

Keywords: Climate change, Greenhouse gases, Ground-based FTIR, EM27/SUN, Reims broadcasts, Comparison

 

[Hui et al. 2022]: Hui, D., Deng, Q., Tian, H., & Luo, Y. (2022). Global climate change and greenhouse gases emissions in terrestrial ecosystems. In Handbook of climate change mitigation and adaptation (pp. 23-76). Cham: Springer International Publishing.

 

Magic initiative group : Bruno GROUIEZ, Lilian JOLY, Abdelhamid HAMDOUNI, Yao TE, Pascal JESECK, Christel GUY, Caroline BES, Denis JOUGLET, Hervé HERBIN, Morgan LOPEZ, Josselin DOC, Simona LATCHABADY, Michel RAMONET, Christof JANSSEN, Marc DELMOTTE, Deniel CAROLE, Corinne BOURSIER, Nicole MONTENEGRO VARELA, Hao FU, Neil HUMPAGE, Carlos ALBERTI, Vincent CASSÉ, Bruna SILVEIRA, Frank HASE, Cyril CREVOISIER

How to cite: El Habchi El Fenniri, H. and the MAGIC initiative group: Statistical evaluation of the performance of EM27/SUN measurements as part of the MAGIC initiative, EGU General Assembly 2024, Vienna, Austria, 14–19 Apr 2024, EGU24-20456, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu24-20456, 2024.

X5.100
|
EGU24-9567
|
ECS
|
Benedikt A. Löw, Ralph Kleinschek, Vincent Enders, Stanley P. Sander, Thomas J. Pongetti, Tobias D. Schmitt, Frank Hase, and André Butz

Mapping the greenhouse gases carbon dioxide (CO2) and methane (CH4) above source regions, such as urban areas, can deliver insights into the distribution and dynamics of local emission patterns. To this end, we conduct ground-based measurements in the reflected-sun geometry, where a NIR spectrometer in an elevated position points downward at shallow viewing angles and observes reflected sunlight from a target area. From the spectra, we infer CO2 and CH4 concentrations integrated along a long (>10 km) horizontal path. Measurements in this viewing geometry are particularly sensitive to concentrations in the planetary boundary layer.

We deployed our portable reflected-sun prototype instrument (termed EM27/SCA) [1] during one month in April/May 2022 on Mt. Wilson above the Los Angeles basin to perform side-by-side measurements with the stationary CLARS-FTS [2]. We find a relative precision of 0.36%–0.55% for CO2 and CH4 slant column densities and good consistency with simultaneous CLARS-FTS measurements. However, we also identify the necessity to account for radiation scattered into the ray path when performing the quantitative analysis of recorded spectra.

Here, we present the instrument performance as well as our approach to account for atmospheric scattering effects. Our retrieval algorithm is based on the RemoTeC radiative transfer and retrieval algorithm, previously employed for solar backscatter satellite measurements. We showcase its performance by simultaneously inferring aerosol optical thickness, CO2 and CH4 from EM27/SCA observations.

 

References:
[1] Löw, B. A., et al.: A portable reflected-sunlight spectrometer for CO2 and CH4, Atmos. Meas. Tech., 16, 5125–5144, https://doi.org/10.5194/amt-16-5125-2023, 2023.
[2] Fu, D., et al.: Near-infrared remote sensing of Los Angeles trace gas distributions from a mountaintop site, Atmos. Meas. Tech., 7, 713–729, https://doi.org/10.5194/amt-7-713-2014, 2014.

How to cite: Löw, B. A., Kleinschek, R., Enders, V., Sander, S. P., Pongetti, T. J., Schmitt, T. D., Hase, F., and Butz, A.: A portable reflected-sunlight spectrometer for measuring atmospheric CO2 and CH4: Accounting for aerosols, EGU General Assembly 2024, Vienna, Austria, 14–19 Apr 2024, EGU24-9567, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu24-9567, 2024.

X5.101
|
EGU24-15956
Neil Humpage, Paul Palmer, Liang Feng, Alex Kurganskiy, Jerome Woodwark, Stamatia Doniki, Robbie Ramsay, and Hartmut Boesch

As part of the UK Greenhouse gas Emissions Measurement Modelling Advancement programme, the National Centre for Earth Observation are establishing the Greenhouse gas Emissions Monitoring network to Inform Net-zero Initiatives for the UK (GEMINI-UK). The primary aim of the GEMINI-UK network, comprising ten Bruker EM27/SUN shortwave infrared spectrometers, is to help quantify regional net GHG emissions across the UK, complementing in situ measurements collected by the existing tall tower network. Collectively, these data will eventually form the backbone of a pre-operational GHG emissions monitoring framework. The GEMINI-UK instruments observe column concentrations of carbon dioxide, methane, and carbon monoxide in cloud-free conditions, which we are using in the context of Bayesian inverse methods to constrain regional flux estimates of these gases. We have designed the measurement network to deliver the biggest error reductions in carbon dioxide flux estimates, working closely with host partners that include UK universities and schools and NERC facilities to promote the open access and transparency of the collected data. Continuous and autonomous operation of these instruments at each site is achieved by an automated weatherproof enclosure, based on a design developed by University of Edinburgh researchers, which previously enabled year-round measurements to be collected during the UK DARE-UK experiment in central London. In this presentation we describe the status and longer-term goals of GEMINI-UK, which is coming online through the first half of 2024, including an ongoing evaluation of EM27/SUN with a higher specification TCCON spectrometer at Harwell. We will also report data from the DARE-UK London deployment, which demonstrates the value in using all-weather enclosures and allows comparison with coincident measurements collected by the NASA OCO-2 and OCO-3 Earth orbiting instruments.

How to cite: Humpage, N., Palmer, P., Feng, L., Kurganskiy, A., Woodwark, J., Doniki, S., Ramsay, R., and Boesch, H.: GEMINI-UK: a new UK network of ground-based greenhouse gas observing spectrometers to help track progress towards net-zero targets, EGU General Assembly 2024, Vienna, Austria, 14–19 Apr 2024, EGU24-15956, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu24-15956, 2024.

X5.102
|
EGU24-16659
SeyedehNasrin Mostafavipak, Sussmann Ralf, and Rettinger Markus

To adhere to the Paris Agreement and restrict the rise in global temperatures to 1.5 degrees, it is imperative to significantly decrease anthropogenic greenhouse gas emissions, ultimately achieving net-zero emissions by the year 2050. To evaluate the reductions in CO2 emissions, it is essential to assess the related changes in CO2 mixing ratios in the atmosphere. An appropriate quantity to be used for this assessment in the years to come is the global annual growth rate of atmospheric CO2. As a data basis for this, in-situ measurement station networks can be used, and annual growth rates are being inferred, e.g., from the Mauna Loa station. On the other hand, TCCON, operating 30 stations worldwide, is committed to measuring greenhouse gas total column mixing ratios through the use of ground-based solar viewing FTIR instruments. The advantage of TCCON column observations is that they are less sensitive to local emissions close to the measurement site and are more representative of regional and global scale emissions and trends in greenhouse gas mixing ratios. TCCON data, therefore, represent a potent alternative data source. A recent algorithmic approach to infer annual growth rates from TCCON data by Sussmann and Rettinger (2020) considers the temporal sampling of TCCON, accounting for data gaps due to sun-viewing geometry, and has been successfully demonstrated for selected TCCON sites. The goal of our ongoing work, presented here, is to extend the retrieval of annual growth rates to more TCCON stations and compare our TCCON results with results from the in-situ networks.

Reference: Sussmann, R., and Rettinger, M.: Can We Measure a COVID-19-Related Slowdown in Atmospheric CO2 Growth? Sensitivity of Total Carbon Column Observations, Remote Sens., 12, 2387, https://doi.org/10.3390/rs12152387, 2020.

How to cite: Mostafavipak, S., Ralf, S., and Markus, R.: Annual Growth Rates of Column-Averaged CO2 on Global Scale Inferred from Long-Term TCCON Observations, EGU General Assembly 2024, Vienna, Austria, 14–19 Apr 2024, EGU24-16659, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu24-16659, 2024.

X5.103
|
EGU24-9147
|
ECS
Harikrishnan Charuvil Asokan, Jochen Landgraf, Leon Scheidweiler, and André Butz

In addressing the challenges caused by climate change, it is crucial to understand the impact of anthropogenic carbon dioxide (CO2) and methane (CH4) emissions. Therefore, it is essential to collect accurate and precise information on the sources of these greenhouse gases to develop effective mitigation strategies. Here, we present a simulation study for quantifying the emission hotspot targets using next-generation satellite sensors. A satellite end-to-end simulator will be used to identify and prioritize targets of CH4 and CO2 sources around the globe.

The current study will follow the orbit and satellite parameters of the proposed Twin Anthropogenic Greenhouse Gas Observers (TANGO) mission, representing an innovative CubeSat satellite initiative consisting of two satellites. TANGO-Carbon (1) will measure CO2 and CH4 in the 1.6 μm range, while TANGO-Nitro (2) will detect NO2 and cloud-related data. These satellites offer a spatial resolution of 300x300 m2, covering target areas spanning 30x30 km2. The TANGO mission aims to quantify point sources with CO2 emission rates of at least 2 Mt/yr and CH4 emissions of at least 5 kt/yr. Supported by national Dutch funding, the TANGO mission is scheduled for launch in 2027.

After identifying localized point sources through the simulation study, we present performance analyses for these future-generation satellites. From an identified target tile, a simulated measurement study will also be conducted. Expected concentration fields will be used to create synthetic measurements from spectrometer parameters. These synthetic measurements will be used in a physics-based radiative transfer model to estimate emission rates. Additionally, we will examine different performance metrics and potential error sources, such as errors due to aerosol scattering, to understand how they might affect our emissions estimates.

How to cite: Charuvil Asokan, H., Landgraf, J., Scheidweiler, L., and Butz, A.: Quantifying Carbon Dioxide and Methane Hotspots: A Simulation Study with the TANGO Satellite Initiative, EGU General Assembly 2024, Vienna, Austria, 14–19 Apr 2024, EGU24-9147, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu24-9147, 2024.

X5.104
|
EGU24-1841
|
ECS
Xiaojuan Lin, Ronald van der A, Jos de Laat, Henk Eskes, Vincent Huijnen, Bas Mijling, Jieying Ding, and Zhu Liu

Since anthropogenic NOx (NOx=NO+NO2) and CO2 are co-emitted species for anthropogenic sources, some studies have used the NOx emissions retrieved from satellite observations to infer the anthropogenic CO2 emissions. However, these studies did not consider the fact that satellites measure total NO2 concentrations and their inferred emissions encompass both biogenic and anthropogenic sources. In this study, we introduce a method to distinguish soil NOx emissions from satellite-based total NOx emissions. The total NOx emissions are derived by the state-of-the-art inverse algorithm DECSO (Daily Emission estimation Constrained by Satellite Observations, Mijling and van der A, 2012; Ding et al., 2017a) from TROPOMI observations. Using the characteristic seasonal cycle of soil emissions we derive these emissions for representative regions with only biogenic emissions, which are then applied to nearby regions according land-use fractions. To evaluate this approach, we compared the deviation between the tropospheric NO2 concentration observed by satellite and two atmospheric composition model simulations: one using the satellite-derived soil NOx emissions and another with the Copernicus Atmosphere Monitoring Service (CAMS) global soil emissions inventory (CAMS-GLOB-SOIL). Once the soil NOx emissions are derived, they can be subtracted from the total emissions to get anthropogenic NOx emissions. Subsequently anthropogenic CO2 emissions can be estimated using known CO2/NOx factors from bottom-up inventories. The annual CO2 emissions derived from DECSO (called DECSO-CO2) in our study area (large part of Europe) is 3.7 Gt in 2019, which is comparable with the 3.2 Gt of the CAMS CO2 inventory (called CAMS-CO2). The DECSO-CO2 and CAMS-CO2 are comparable for most large sources and cities, but the DECSO-CO2 show a larger number of low emission spots than the CAMS-CO2. The results demonstrate the potential for DECSO to expand its application to other regions in the world with less information on anthropogenic CO2 emissions.

How to cite: Lin, X., van der A, R., de Laat, J., Eskes, H., Huijnen, V., Mijling, B., Ding, J., and Liu, Z.: Using space-based NO2 observations to indirectly estimate anthropogenic CO2 emissions, EGU General Assembly 2024, Vienna, Austria, 14–19 Apr 2024, EGU24-1841, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu24-1841, 2024.

X5.105
|
EGU24-11087
|
ECS
Michael Weimer, Michael Hilker, Blanca Fuentes Andrade, Stefan Noël, Maximilian Reuter, Michael Buchwitz, Heinrich Bovensmann, John P. Burrows, and Hartmut Bösch

Anthropogenic emissions of carbon dioxide (CO2) are the main driver of the change in climate since the industrial revolution. Policy mitigation strategies include reduction of these emissions. The Paris Agreement from 2015 requires the states to report their greenhouse gas emissions on a regular basis. Space-borne remote-sensing measurements of CO2 are considered potentially of great value  to monitor CO2 emissions, due to their better coverage in comparison to in-situ instruments. Measuring CO2  from space of an adequate quality is a challenge because of the stringent requirements related to the accuracy and precision of the data products and thus the instruments. In this study, we use the Fast atmospheric traCe gAs retrievaL (FOCAL) algorithm to retrieve maps of the column-averaged dry-air CO2 mole fraction (XCO2) with the goal of quantifying CO2 emissions for specific emission targets using Orbiting Carbon Observatory 3 (OCO-3) snapshot area maps. This data product is planned to  be used in the German national Integrated Greenhouse Gas Monitoring System (ITMS), for which an operational data assimilation system for greenhouse gases is being set up for Germany.

How to cite: Weimer, M., Hilker, M., Fuentes Andrade, B., Noël, S., Reuter, M., Buchwitz, M., Bovensmann, H., Burrows, J. P., and Bösch, H.: Towards CO2 emission monitoring from space using FOCAL XCO2 retrievals of OCO-3 satellite measurements, EGU General Assembly 2024, Vienna, Austria, 14–19 Apr 2024, EGU24-11087, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu24-11087, 2024.

X5.106
|
EGU24-11787
Mathias Strupler, Marianne Girard, Dylan Jervis, Jean-Philippe W MacLean, David Marshall, Jason McKeever, Antoine Ramier, Ewan Tarrant, and David Young

GHGSat operates a growing constellation of small satellites tailored for high-resolution imaging and quantification of methane emissions, achieving ~25 m spatial resolution and a sensitivity down to ~100 kg/hr. In 2023, the constellation expanded to 12 satellites with the launch of three additional satellites, including the introduction of the first CO2 sensing instrument. 

Land operations: We present a comprehensive analysis of the performance across the constellation, demonstrating consistent column precision levels (interquartile range: 1% to 3%) influenced primarily by ground reflectance. To assess the detection threshold, a series of controlled releases were self-organized and performed on a single-blind basis. Fitting our results to a probability-of-detection model we obtain a 50% probability of detection at 3 m/s wind of 102 kg/h. 

Offshore operations: Detecting and quantifying methane emissions from offshore platforms, which constitutes 30% of oil & gas production, is crucial for providing actionable feedback to industrial operators. Utilizing glint mode for offshore measurements, we capture the direct specular reflection of the sun, enabling quantification of atmospheric methane emissions over water. Our findings reveal a median column precision of 2.1%. Through analytical modeling and orbital simulations, we estimate detection limits ranging from 160 kg/h to 600 kg/h, depending on latitude and season.  

CO2 satellite: We provide the status of the recently launched CO2 satellite – with the same swath and spatial resolution as our methane satellites. This unit will bring a new dimension to our knowledge of global greenhouses gases emissions.  

Our presentation underscores the advancements made and insights gained from land and offshore operations, emphasizing the constellation's growing capabilities and the critical role it plays in monitoring and mitigating CH4 and CO2 emissions. 

How to cite: Strupler, M., Girard, M., Jervis, D., MacLean, J.-P. W., Marshall, D., McKeever, J., Ramier, A., Tarrant, E., and Young, D.: GHGSat’s constellation: Land and offshore greenhouse gases detection and quantification , EGU General Assembly 2024, Vienna, Austria, 14–19 Apr 2024, EGU24-11787, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu24-11787, 2024.

X5.107
|
EGU24-20565
Catherine Hayer, Ruediger Lang, Rasmus Lindstrot, Bernd Sierk, and Bojan Bojkov

As part of the Copernicus Programme of the European Commission, the European Space Agency (ESA) and the European Organisation for the Exploitation of Meteorological Satellites (EUMETSAT) are expanding the Copernicus Space Component to include additional measurements of atmospheric composition. To support the evaluation of greenhouse gas emission reductions decided during the COP21 meeting in Paris in 2015, new measurements are required with improved accuracy. Measurements from space-borne instruments are a key component of this effort – requiring improvements in both spatial and spectral resolution.

The Copernicus missions are Europe’s primary contribution to this effort. The CO2M mission – a constellation of initially 2 platforms – is due to launch at the end of 2026 and will be available to contribute to the global stocktake in 2028 and those beyond. Data from the three instruments on board each platform – CO2I/NO2I, MAP, and CLIM – will be combined to act as a single “hyper-instrument”. NO2 is often co-emitted with CO2 & CH4, so the spectrometer (NO2I) will be used to detect near-surface NO2 plumes; the impact of aerosol pollution on the XCO2 columns will be calculated using the Multi-Angle Polarimeter (MAP); and cloud contamination will be observed and removed via data from the Cloud Imager (CLIM). These data will be used within the CO2 and CH4 retrievals from the CO2I spectrometer to improve the retrievals and allow for a precision of 0.7 ppm and an error of 0.5 ppm for XCO2, and an uncertainty of ~10 ppb for CH4.

Sentinel-5 will fly on the EUMETSAT Polar System – Second Generation (EPS-SG) platform, due for launch in 2025. S-5 will be a push-broom hyperspectral UVN spectrometer, with a 7.5 km2 spatial resolution and global daily coverage via a 2670 km wide swath. It will monitor various trace gases, including CH4.

Comprehensive calibration and validation analysis during the satellite’s commissioning will be undertaken to ensure they meet the specified requirements, and ongoing monitoring will ensure the instruments continue to comply with the challenging requirements. External data from ground-, airborne-, and satellite-based instruments will be required, covering the whole globe and multiple parts of the EM spectrum. Calibration and Validation techniques are being developed across CO2M and S-5, as well as Sentinel-4 which is also due for launch in 2025. This inter-mission collaboration has been undertaken to reduce duplication of effort and ensure lessons are learned from the commissioning of each mission.

Here, we give an update on the current state of planning for the Calibration and Validation operations, and identify gaps in the current provision of external networks, ground-based in particular, so that alternative and additional data sources can be procured.

How to cite: Hayer, C., Lang, R., Lindstrot, R., Sierk, B., and Bojkov, B.: A harmonised approach to Calibration and Validation for upcoming Sentinel missions: updates for CO2M and Sentinel-5, EGU General Assembly 2024, Vienna, Austria, 14–19 Apr 2024, EGU24-20565, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu24-20565, 2024.

X5.108
|
EGU24-4762
|
ECS
Daria Stepanova, Errico Armandillo, Mariana Adam, and Ivan Ramirez

In the context of growing climate change concerns, accurate and real-time monitoring of greenhouse gases (GHGs) such as carbon dioxide (CO2) and methane (CH4) is imperative. AIRMO's innovative GHG emissions monitoring service is at the forefront of addressing this need, offering high-resolution and high-sensitivity emissions data. Local winds, along with presence of aerosol and thin clouds significantly impacts the accuracy of GHG flux measurements, hence the output data quality.

The Airmo service, under development,  is powered by a small satellite constellation equipped with 3 co-located instruments including a pushbroom SWIR spectrometer, micro LiDAR, and an RGB camera. In this context, the LiDAR emerges as a pivotal tool due to its unique capability to characterise both winds and aerosols. The major difference and mission impact brought by AIRMO relies on complementing and supplementing the column Radiance data produced by the Spectrometer with atmospheric data from the LiDAR, including data about aerosol layers and cirrus cloud’s optical properties.

This approach enables precise localization of GHG sources with spatial resolution capabilities down to 30 meters. Temporal resolution with a revisit rate of 4 hours with complete deployment ensures timely data for tracking emission changes. High spectral sensitivity in the SWIR range guarantees retrieval accuracy and spectral line characterization. The expe4cted accuracy of methane measurements lies within ±5 ppb and CO2 within ±2 ppm, offering unprecedented precision in GHG quantification.

The upcoming In-Orbit Demonstration (IoD) mission will showcase AIRMO's capability to meet stringent observation requirements and validate its operational framework in alignment with mission objectives. Two airborne campaigns are  planned for 1st and 3rd   Q 2024.

The paper will provide an overview of the status of the Mission and critical payload development and performance.

How to cite: Stepanova, D., Armandillo, E., Adam, M., and Ramirez, I.: GHG monitoring from microsatellite using compact micro-LiDAR and Push-broom spectrometer, EGU General Assembly 2024, Vienna, Austria, 14–19 Apr 2024, EGU24-4762, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu24-4762, 2024.

X5.109
|
EGU24-15743
|
ECS
Léa Khater, Laurence Croizé, Isabelle Pison, and Antoine Berchet

CH4 is the second anthropogenic contributor to global warming after CO2. Monitoring methane emissions is therefore essential in order to mitigate climate change. Satellite missions have the potential to offer more spatial coverage than ground stations, however their coverage is currently insufficient. This leads to the development of satellite missions that can be envisaged as constellations. For this purpose a concept currently studied is Nanocarb, relying  on the patent  WO2018002558A1 (ImSPOC). This instrument is a compact and robust spectral imaging concept relying on a static array of Fabry-Perrot interferometers to retrieve partial interferograms of the incident radiance. This study is focused on developing and using the appropriate tools and models to simulate the flux restitution performances of a methane focused Nanocarb instrument with two intertwined inverse approaches.

We have developed an end-to-end simulation chain of the flux restitution by the instrument Nanocarb. First an atmospheric situation is simulated from an inventory such as TNO's by the chemistry transport model Chimere. Then this atmospheric situation is used to simulate Nanocarb measurements, with a direct and backward ImSPOC conception and processing software called MEDOC which relies on the radiative transfer code 4A-OP. Those simulated measurements have realistic noise added and are used to recover atmospheric methane columns. Eventually this new atmospheric situation allows for the retrieval of atmospheric methane fluxes, thanks to the Community Inversion Framework (CIF), coupled with Chimere. Those fluxes can be compared to the initial situation to quantify the introduced biases.

We present this simulation chain, and specifically developments made on Medoc and columns obtained for an atmospheric simulation in the north of France. This simulation chain aims to model the flux retrieval ability of the instrument Nanocarb for point sources and area sources of methane.

How to cite: Khater, L., Croizé, L., Pison, I., and Berchet, A.: End to end simulation chain for flux restitution of the spectral imaging concept Nanocarb, EGU General Assembly 2024, Vienna, Austria, 14–19 Apr 2024, EGU24-15743, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu24-15743, 2024.

X5.110
|
EGU24-1768
|
ECS
David Ho, Michael Steiner, Erik Koene, Michał Gałkowski, Julia Marshall, and Christoph Gerbig

Inversion modeling is a top-down technique to infer greenhouse gas (GHG) emissions using atmospheric observations. In particular, the use of satellite retrievals have been attractive due to their advantage in dense spatial coverage compared to typically sparse surface networks.
The goal of this study is to assimilate satellite data at high spatial resolution to independently locate and quantify GHG sources and sinks, which can be used as a reference for carbon budget studies and policy makers. The findings also contribute as groundwork for the development of the Integrated GHG Monitoring System for Germany (ITMS).
For this purpose, we coupled the numerical weather prediction and atmospheric transport model ICON-ART with an Ensemble Kalman Filter (EnKF) based inversion system, using the CarbonTracker Data Assimilation Shell (CTDAS). We use column data (XCH4) measured by the TROPOspheric Monitoring Instrument (TROPOMI) onboard the Sentinel-5 Precursor satellite, targeting anthropogenic CH4 fluxes over Europe. Prior anthropogenic emissions are taken from the EDGARv4.3.2 inventory, while natural fluxes were derived from peatlands, mineral soils, lakes, oceans, biofuels, biomass burning, termites, and geology. 
We first present a synthetic study of our system by performing an ensemble simulation forward in time with randomly perturbed emission fields. CH4 fluxes were retrieved at 0.25° x 0.25° resolution, and prior emissions are scaled to optimally fit the measured values. With this idealized experiment, we demonstrate that the system is capable of capturing the prescribed spatial pattern applied onto the emission field, using pseudo-observations of satellite retrievals with realistic coverage. In addition, we report on the results of assimilating real observations into the system, including emission estimates and their associated uncertainties. 
This study demonstrates the potential of incorporating satellite retrievals into inverse modeling, enabling us to extend its application to other GHG species. It also serve as a preparation work for the planned Copernicus Anthropogenic Carbon Dioxide Monitoring (CO2M) satellite mission.

How to cite: Ho, D., Steiner, M., Koene, E., Gałkowski, M., Marshall, J., and Gerbig, C.: Towards regional CH4 inversions with ICON-ART assimilating satellite TROPOMI data over Europe, EGU General Assembly 2024, Vienna, Austria, 14–19 Apr 2024, EGU24-1768, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu24-1768, 2024.

X5.111
|
EGU24-10179
Maximilian Reuter, Michael Hilker, Stefan Noël, Antonio Di Noia, Michael Weimer, Michael Buchwitz, Heinrich Bovensmann, Hartmut Bösch, and John P. Burrows

Carbon dioxide (CO2) and methane (CH4) are the most important anthropogenic greenhouse gases because they are the main drivers of climate change. Monitoring their concentrations from space can help to detect and quantify anthropogenic emissions, supporting the mitigation efforts urgently needed to fulfill the Paris Agreement. Additionally, it can help to better understand the processes of the carbon cycle and thus allow better climate projections.

These are key objectives of the European Copernicus CO2 Monitoring Mission CO2M, scheduled for launch in 2026, for which three retrieval algorithms are currently being developed and implemented in the EUMETSAT ground segment. These are so called conventional retrieval techniques that base on radiative transfer calculations. Despite shortcuts and approximations, the vast amount of satellite data makes them computationally expensive, requiring thousands of CPU cores. Although conventional retrieval methods base on physical principles, they typically require empirical data-driven methods to correct for biases in order to meet the demanding accuracy and precision requirements. The biases arise, e.g., from inaccuracies of the radiative transfer computations or unknown instrumental issues. Machine learning methods have the potential to combine both steps into a single data-driven retrieval algorithm, reducing the computational cost by several orders of magnitude.

We used the radiative transfer model SCIATRAN to simulate two years (2015 and 2020) of sub-sampled realistic radiances of three instruments on board CO2M: the main instrument CO2I (CO2 imager), MAP (multi angle polarimeter), and CLIM (cloud imager). We use data from the first year of this data set to train artificial neural networks (ANNs) to retrieve XCO2 and XCH4 (the column-average dry-air mole fraction of atmospheric CO2 and CH4, respectively) plus related uncertainties and column averaging kernels. We will introduce a method which allows us to modify the training data making it representative for a wider range of atmospheric states. This ensures that the ANNs learn from the spectral signatures of CO2 and CH4 and that learning from spurious correlations is minimized. Despite the annual growth of CO2 and CH4, we will show that the ANNs trained with data from 2015 have almost the same quality when applied to data from 2020. We will analyze and compare the performance of different input vector settings, e.g., with and without MAP data and will discuss potential advantages or disadvantages of our ANN approach.

How to cite: Reuter, M., Hilker, M., Noël, S., Di Noia, A., Weimer, M., Buchwitz, M., Bovensmann, H., Bösch, H., and Burrows, J. P.: A data-driven method to retrieve XCO2 and XCH4 using artificial neural networks in preparation for the European Copernicus CO2 Monitoring Mission CO2M, EGU General Assembly 2024, Vienna, Austria, 14–19 Apr 2024, EGU24-10179, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu24-10179, 2024.

X5.112
|
EGU24-12350
Sean Crowell, Berrien Moore III, Eric Burgh, Mate Adamkovicz, Timothy Miller, Peter Somkuti, Alex Webb, Gary Spiers, Eric Mentzell, Chris O'Dell, and Greg McGarragh

After selection as the second Earth Venture Mission in 2016, the Geostationary Carbon Observatory (GeoCarb), led by the University of Oklahoma PI Dr. Berrien Moore III, was developed until its cancellation during Phase C in November 2022. The GeoCarb PI was directed by NASA to complete as much of the instrument as remaining funding permitted.  The GeoCarb team successfully completed alignment and focus of the spectrograph before verification through a sequence of thermal vacuum campaigns, during which other characteristics of the instrument were determined (e.g., SNR, spectral range, stray light). These measurements suggested that the GeoCarb integrated instrument would have sufficient performance to deliver on the promise of the originally proposed greenhouse gas observing mission.  As a result, the project continued with integration of the optical subassemblies and electronics into a fully integrated instrument as of August 2023.  The instrument underwent a final thermal vacuum campaign during the fall of 2023 and was shipped to NASA for storage in November 2023.  Since that time, the GeoCarb science team has been analyzing the test data to determine the capabilities of the integrated instrument with positive results.  All indications are that the GeoCarb instrument will meet its key performance requirements.

 

In this presentation, we will discuss the spectral, radiometric, and polarimetric performance of the GeoCarb instrument from the measurement campaigns, including the spectral and spatial image quality, polarization response, and SNR.  We will address the implications for the scientific capabilities of the fully characterized and calibrated observatory should NASA restart the program.

How to cite: Crowell, S., Moore III, B., Burgh, E., Adamkovicz, M., Miller, T., Somkuti, P., Webb, A., Spiers, G., Mentzell, E., O'Dell, C., and McGarragh, G.: Expected Performance of the GeoCarb Integrated Instrument from Thermal Vacuum Measurements During a Limited Performance Test, EGU General Assembly 2024, Vienna, Austria, 14–19 Apr 2024, EGU24-12350, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu24-12350, 2024.

X5.113
|
EGU24-14028
|
ECS
Chengxin Zhang, Xinhua Hong, and Cheng Liu

The world is facing a serious warming crisis, highlighting the need for monitoring greenhouse gases such as carbon dioxide (CO2). In 2016, China launched its first satellite mission for measuring atmospheric CO2, i.e., TanSat. Previous TanSat retrievals of the column-averaged dry air mole fraction of CO2 (XCO2) have a moderate precision of 1.47–2.45 ppm, with only limited spatial coverage over the land surface by using TanSat nadir-mode (ND) spectroscopy. These existing gaps are affected by the poor signal-to-noise ratio of glint mode (GL) or over the oceanic surface. However, CO2 measurements over the ocean, a major source of global carbon sinks, are often lacking and subject to significant uncertainties but are nevertheless quite important. To increase the spatial coverage and retrieval accuracy and precision of TanSat CO2, we further improve XCO2 retrieval by introducing spectral recalibration, spectral window optimization, and explicit radiative transfer simulation. Thus, universal CO2 retrieval with high precision over land and ocean is realized by using both ND and GL spectra. Ground-based comparisons using the total carbon column observing network (TCCON) indicate that the standard deviations of the bias-corrected XCO2 retrievals from the ND and GL modes were 1.28 and 1.19 ppm, respectively. Consistent spatial and temporal distributions of satellite XCO2 retrievals can also be found among TanSat, the Greenhouse gases Observing SATellite (GOSAT), and the Orbiting Carbon Observatory-2 (OCO-2) satellites. The updated TanSat XCO2 retrievals have ~3.5 times the seasonal spatial coverage of GOSAT, while the highest difference between TanSat and OCO-2 is only +0.63 ppm. In addition, TanSat XCO2 retrievals over the ocean successfully captured enhanced CO2 plumes from the neighboring Yasur volcano, with an estimated emission flux of 32.1 kilotons per day. These results indicate that the improved TanSat XCO2 retrieval is useful for understanding and quantifying global land and ocean carbon emissions.

How to cite: Zhang, C., Hong, X., and Liu, C.: First TanSat CO2 retrieval over land and ocean using both nadir and glint spectroscopy, EGU General Assembly 2024, Vienna, Austria, 14–19 Apr 2024, EGU24-14028, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu24-14028, 2024.

X5.114
|
EGU24-19932
Dietrich G. Feist, Sabrina Zechlau, Gerhard Ehret, and Philippe Bousquet

Methane is known to be the second largest contributor to greenhouse gas induced warming after carbon dioxide. However, we know much less about its sources and sinks on global to regional scales and their sensitivity to climate change. Emissions of methane from permafrost and from the abundant number of wetlands, lakes, and rivers located in arctic and tropic regions are expected to substantially increase during this century due to the rapid climate warming. Therefore, disentangling natural and anthropogenic methane fluxes is a key scientific task.

The French-German Methane Remote Sensing LIDAR Mission MERLIN is designed to measure highly accurate atmospheric columns of methane to identify natural fluxes and emissions to better quantify global and regional sources and sinks, aiming at - reducing uncertainties on the global methane budget. To accomplish this, MERLIN will be relying on its Integrated Path Differential Absorption (IPDA) lidar to access methane atmospheric concentration at all latitudes and in all seasons. Especially, MERLIN will be able to provide spaceborne methane observations also in regions with high cloud cover and at high latitudes in winter time and in the so-called shoulder seasons. The IPDA measurements are insensitive to ground albedo variations and atmospheric aerosol load and will therefore achieve a level of accuracy not possible with the current available passive measurement techniques in space but will provide highly valuable information for closing knowledge gaps concerning global to regional methane distributions. The launch date of the MERLIN satellite is expected in 2029. Here we want to provide an overview of the MERLIN mission together with some discussion on the validation needs.

How to cite: Feist, D. G., Zechlau, S., Ehret, G., and Bousquet, P.: MERLIN – Measuring methane with lidar from space, EGU General Assembly 2024, Vienna, Austria, 14–19 Apr 2024, EGU24-19932, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu24-19932, 2024.

X5.115
|
EGU24-12720
Charles Robert, Sophie Vandenbusshe, Ann Carine Vandaele, Justin Erwin, and Martine De Mazière

Atmospheric methane (CH₄) is measured continuously from space, providing valuable information at global scales for atmospheric monitoring. CH₄ measurements from space can be based on observations in the shortwave infrared (SWIR), leading to a more uniform sensitivity to the atmospheric column, as well as thermal infrared observations (TIR) which provide useful information on the CH₄ content in the upper troposphere and lower stratosphere.

Among the various instruments measuring in the TIR, the Infrared Atmospheric Sounding Interferometer (IASI) series of instruments onboard the METOP satellites have been observing the Earth’s atmosphere for more than 15 years. Also, the Thermal And Near infrared Sensor for carbon Observation Fourier-Transform Spectrometer (TANSO-FTS) on-board the GOSAT 1 and 2 satellites monitor the atmosphere in the SWIR and TIR since 2009. Both instruments provide valuable information for the retrieval atmospheric CH₄.

CH4 retrievals in the TIR can be demanding in terms of computational time. The large number of species in the CH4 region, and the high radiometric accuracy of current and upcoming instruments (e.g. IASI, IASI-NG) demand highly accurate radiative transfer modelling (RTM), to be carried out on a fine spectral and vertical grid. These constraints usually lead to long processing time when using full-physics RTMs (e.g. ASIMUT-ALVL). Other fast RTMs exists (e.g. RTTOV), but they often cannot be easily modified to include a specific species or spectroscopy, and do not support all instruments.

To allow for faster processing of the already large datasets available, we developed a model based on the Principal Component-based Radiative Transfer Model (PCRTM) approach (Liu et al., 2006) to perform CH4 inversion in the TIR with IASI and TANSO-FTS. Instead of predicting channel radiance directly, the Principal Component-based Radiative Transfer Model (PCRTM) predicts the Principal Component (PC) scores of these quantities parameterized by a relatively small number of monochromatic RT simulations, leading to significant savings in computational time. The model returns the channel radiances and the jacobians for all species of interest.

In this work, we will detail the approach that was taken for the development of the fast RTM and will compare the results with a full-physics RTM. The impact of some internal parameters on the current model will also be discussed, as well as possible improvements in the future.

 

Reference:

Xu Liu, William L. Smith, Daniel K. Zhou, and Allen Larar, "Principal component-based radiative transfer model for hyperspectral sensors: theoretical concept," Appl. Opt. 45, 201-209 (2006)

How to cite: Robert, C., Vandenbusshe, S., Vandaele, A. C., Erwin, J., and De Mazière, M.: A fast forward model for IASI and TANSO-FTS CH4 retrievals , EGU General Assembly 2024, Vienna, Austria, 14–19 Apr 2024, EGU24-12720, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu24-12720, 2024.

X5.116
|
EGU24-17815
Nicolas Meilhac, Cyril Crevoisier, Rémy Orset, Raymond Armante, Rigel Kivi, and Huilin Chen

Thanks to its continuous spectral coverage of the whole thermal infrared domain, the IASI sounder offers the possibility to monitor on the long term several essential climate variables, including mid-tropospheric columns of the 3 major greenhouse gases influenced by human activitie: carbon dioxide (CO2), methane (CH4) and nitrous oxide (N2O).

To tackle the very small seasonal variability of these gases compared to their background values, combined to the strong dependence of IR radiances to atmospheric temperature and the simultaneous sensitivity of the channels to several gases, a non-linear inference scheme has been developed at LMD. Since 2007, mid-tropospheric columns of methane have been derived for both day and night conditions, over land and over sea. The retrieval scheme strongly relies on careful validation of level1c spectra, characterization of systematic radiative biases and severe cloud and aerosol screening. CH4 fields are delivered on ‘near real time’ (D-1) basis to the Copernicus Atmosphere Monitoring Service (CAMS) and are assimilated in ECMWF C-IFS system, along with total columns from GOSAT, to produce forecast of vertical profiles of atmospheric concentration. Owing to its 20 year-program, IASI also participates to the establishment of long time series in the Copernicus Climate Change Service (C3S). The retrievals are thus used for a variety of purpose: assimilation to produce CH4/CO2 profile forecasts; estimation of surface fluxes using “top-down” atmospheric inversions; characterization of specific emissions such as biomass burnings.

In this talk we will present the latest development of the retrieval and application of methane. In particular, we will present the extension and validation of the retrieval to the high latitude regions achieved during the ESA MethaneCAMP project. By using AirCore 0-30 km profiles of methane concentration acquired at Sodankylä and Kiruna and several stations of the French AirCore network, we will also highlight the crucial need to better understand the variation of stratospheric methane in order to combine satellite-derived methane columns with simulations from atmospheric transport models. Finally, we will present long-term and interannual variability of methane as seen by IASI, with a focus of 2020-2021 methane anomaly and the characterization of specific emissions such as biomass burnings or NordStream leakage.

How to cite: Meilhac, N., Crevoisier, C., Orset, R., Armante, R., Kivi, R., and Chen, H.: Global distribution of methane in the mid-troposphere as seen by IASI onboard three successive Metop platforms, EGU General Assembly 2024, Vienna, Austria, 14–19 Apr 2024, EGU24-17815, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu24-17815, 2024.

Posters virtual: Thu, 18 Apr, 14:00–15:45 | vHall X5

Display time: Thu, 18 Apr, 08:30–Thu, 18 Apr, 18:00
Chairpersons: Matthaeus Kiel, Dietrich G. Feist, Neil Humpage
vX5.8
|
EGU24-1267
|
ECS
Saswati Das, Matthäus Kiel, Joshua Laughner, and Gregory Osterman

Carbon dioxide (CO2) is the primary greenhouse gas emitted into the atmosphere due to anthropogenic activities. While it is naturally present as a part of Earth’s carbon cycle, human activities impact the ability of natural sinks to reduce CO2 from the atmosphere and thus alter the carbon cycle. It thus becomes pertinent to focus on the long-term monitoring of atmospheric CO2 and the ability to make precise, accurate, and continuous CO2 measurements.

The Orbiting Carbon Observatory-2 (OCO-2) was launched in 2014. It is NASA’s first Earth-orbiting satellite dedicated to making observations of CO2 in the atmosphere and measuring its column-averaged dry-air mole fraction (XCO2). The primary goal of the OCO-2 mission is to provide XCO2 measurements with sufficient precision and accuracy alongside quantifying its seasonal and interannual variability. While OCO-2 provides global coverage and consistently measures at high latitudes, the remote sensing measurement of CO2 from space can be challenging. This is because the goal is to resolve inter-annual CO2 deviations to subcontinental scales, alongside capturing the known seasonal cycle and trends. Further, the XCO2 data is susceptible to location- and surface-property-dependent biases that must be corrected. Thus, validation of the XCO2 data from OCO-2 becomes necessary to ensure a high degree of retrieval accuracy on a global scale.

This study uses the new and improved OCO-2 V11.1 dataset and compares coincident XCO2 measurements against three independent datasets. The Total Carbon Column Observing Network (TCCON) is a network of solar-viewing ground-based Fourier Transform Spectrometers and the primary validation source for XCO2 from OCO-2. TCCON measurements are unaffected by surface properties and are minimally sensitive to aerosols. The COllaborative Carbon Column Observing Network (COCCON) is a network of portable ground-based Fourier Transform Infrared spectrometers that are less expensive than full TCCON sites and have lower spectral resolution, but are similarly insensitive to surface properties and aerosols. Comparison of coincident OCO-2 measurements against selected TCCON and COCCON sites indicate that the absolute average bias values are close to 0 ppm for TCCON and less than 0.7 ppm for COCCON in the Land Nadir/Glint and Target mode observations.

Finally, we compare coincident OCO-2 measurements to the airborne Atmospheric Tomography Mission (ATom) when ATom conducted around-the-world flights in each of the four seasons between 2016 and 2018. This study bridges the gap between satellite, ground-based, and airborne XCO2 measurements and aids the improvement of the OCO-2 XCO2 data product. Further, it provides the latest validation analysis for OCO-2, providing the most up-to-date information on biases and uncertainty in the OCO-2 data.

How to cite: Das, S., Kiel, M., Laughner, J., and Osterman, G.: Three ways to validate the XCO2 product from the Orbiting Carbon Observatory-2 , EGU General Assembly 2024, Vienna, Austria, 14–19 Apr 2024, EGU24-1267, https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu24-1267, 2024.