Safe exploitation of high-enthalpy geothermal fields for energy production requires knowledge of the mechanical behavior of faults and the seismic cycle in the presence of hot, pressurized fluids. In geothermal reservoirs, fluids can exist in the liquid, liquid-vapor mixture, vapor, or supercritical fluid state. Here we investigate the frictional properties of simulated fault gouges derived from the main stratigraphic units present in Krafla Geothermal Field (Iceland) under realistic water temperature (Tf=100-400˚C) and pressure (Pf=10-30 MPa) conditions. These conditions correspond to water in the liquid, vapor, and supercritical state.
Laboratory rotary shear, slide-hold-slide (SHS) experiments at a constant effective normal stress of 10 MPa are performed on gouges prepared from non-altered basalt (Krafla Fires eruptions, 1975-1984), chlorite-altered basalt (borehole KH-6, 708.5 m borehole depth), amphibole-altered basalt (borehole IDDP-01, 1686 m borehole depth), fine-grained basaltic dyke with scarce alteration (borehole IDDP-01, 1970 m borehole depth), and rhyolite (borehole KJ-39, 1637-1646 m borehole depth). All experiments are initiated with a 5 mm run-in slip at a loading point slip rate V of 10 μm/s followed by the SHS sequence with a hold time thold increased from 3 s to 10,000 s, separated by a slip interval of 1 mm.
The frictional strength μss (friction coefficient during run-in) slightly increases with Tf in non-altered and amphibole-altered basalt and slightly decreases with Tf in chlorite-altered basalt, basaltic dyke, and rhyolite. However, for all rock types, μss is higher (μss_vap> μss_sup and μss_liq) when vapor is present (only exception, non-altered basalt with μss_sup>μss_vap> μss_liq).
The frictional healing Δμ (frictional strength recovery during holds), is highest at Tf=400˚C in vapor and supercritical water. Still, the effect of Tf and the physical states of water on frictional healing rate (β=Δμ/log(1+thold/tcutoff)) depends on rock type. In non-altered basalt, β increases with Tf but decreases in vapor water; in chlorite-altered basalt and basaltic dyke, β increases with Tf and is independent of the physical state of water; in amphibole-altered basalt and rhyolite, β is independent of both Tf and the physical state of water. However, systematic microanalysis of the deformed gouges is required to understand the underlying mechanisms.
Lastly, for measured constant machine stiffness in this Tf-Pf range, all tested gouges show stable sliding (creep) at Tf=100˚C but become unstable (stick-slip) at Tf=200˚C (basaltic dyke) and Tf=300˚C (other rock types) regardless of the physical states of water. The highest stress drops during stick-slip are measured in supercritical water (non-altered basalt) or vapor (all the other gouges). Consistent with the seismological observations, our laboratory data show that the fault/fracture network in Krafla reservoir is less prone to nucleate earthquakes in the shallow hydrothermal system (Tf~170˚C, < 1 km depth), with most earthquakes located in the deep hydrothermal system (Tf≥300˚C, 1-2 km depth).
In conclusion, both temperature and the physical states of water should be considered when interpreting the seismicity in geothermal fields.