Europlanet Science Congress 2020
Virtual meeting
21 September – 9 October 2020
Europlanet Science Congress 2020
Virtual meeting
21 September – 9 October 2020

Oral presentations and abstracts

TP11

This session welcomes presentations on all aspect of the Venus system including interior, surface, atmosphere and ionosphere. We welcome presentations based on past or current observations, theory and modelling, as well as presentations related to future instruments and missions including the ESA-NASA proposed EnVision Venus orbiter and NASA Discovery Venus missions.

Share:
Convener: Thomas Widemann | Co-conveners: Richard Ghail, Colin Wilson

Session assets

Session summary

EPSC2020-303
Takeshi Horinouchi, Yoshi-Yuki Hayashi, Shigeto Watanabe, Manabu Yamada, Atsushi Yamazaki, Toru Kouyama, Makoto Taguchi, Tetsuya Fukuhara, Masahiro Takagi, Kazunori Ogohara, Shin-ya Murakami, Javier Peralta, Sanjay S. Limaye, Takeshi Imamura, Masato Nakamura, Takao M. Sato, and Takehiko Satoh

How the super-rotation of the Venusian atmosphere is maintained is an outstanding question of the Venus science and geophysical fluid dynamics. We tackled it by using data from Akatsuki. Prior to that, we revisited the meridional circulation by using past observational data: downward solar flux from entry probe and satellite-based radiation observation. With a very simple assumption, we obtained a meridional circulation consistent with the earlier studies based on radiative transfer computation. The result allowed us to order-estimate the eddy angular-momentum forcing needed to maintain the present super-rotation. We derived the eddy forcing by using cloud-tracking winds and thermal infrared data from Akatsuki. In particular, we focused on the pivotal question on the maintenance of the presentation, which is how the angular momentum (per unit mass) is supplied at its peak around the equatorial cloud top to compensate the deceleration by the meridional circulation. It was revealed that the thermal tides provide it, acting to accelerate the super-rotation, through both the horizontal and the vertical angular-momentum transport. Other waves and large-scale horizontal turbulence are found to counteract it to a weaker degree, in contrast to the earlier expectation from the classical Gierasch-Rossow-Williams mechanism. This study provided a number of by-products, such as the detection of turbulent motion and spectra of wind disturbances.

 

This study was published recently as Horinouchi et al. 2020, Science, 368 (6489), 405-409 and its online supplementary material.

How to cite: Horinouchi, T., Hayashi, Y.-Y., Watanabe, S., Yamada, M., Yamazaki, A., Kouyama, T., Taguchi, M., Fukuhara, T., Takagi, M., Ogohara, K., Murakami, S., Peralta, J., Limaye, S. S., Imamura, T., Nakamura, M., Sato, T. M., and Satoh, T.: How waves and turbulence maintain the super-rotation of Venus' atmosphere – results from Akatsuki, Europlanet Science Congress 2020, online, 21 September–9 Oct 2020, EPSC2020-303, https://doi.org/10.5194/epsc2020-303, 2020

EPSC2020-281ECP
José Silva, Pedro Machado, Javier Peralta, and Francisco Brasil
  • An atmospheric internal gravity wave is an oscillatory disturbance on an atmospheric layer in which the buoyancy of the displaced air parcels acts as the restoring force. As such, it can only exist in a continuously stably stratified atmosphere, that is, a fluid in which the static stability is positive and horizontal variations (within the atmospheric layer) in pressure are negligible when compared to the vertical variations (in altitude) [Gilli et al. 2020; Peralta et al. 2008].
  • These waves represent an efficient transport mechanism of energy and momentum through the atmosphere which can dissipate at different altitudes, influencing the atmospheric circulation of several layers in the atmosphere. This dissipation or wave breaking can dump the transported momentum and energy to the mean flow, contributing to an acceleration, thus significantly altering the thermal and dynamical regime of the atmosphere [Alexander et al. 2010].
  • We present here results on the detection and characterisation of mesoscale waves on the lower clouds of Venus using data from the Visible Infrared Thermal Imaging Spectrometer (VIRTIS-M) onboard the European Venus Express space mission and from the IR2 instrument onboard the Venus Climate Orbiter (Akatsuki) japanese space mission. We used image navigation and processing techniques based on contrast enhancement and geometrical projections to characterise morphological properties of the detected waves such as horizontal wavelength, packet length and width, orientation and relative optical thickness drop between crests and troughs, as further described in [Peralta et al. 2018]. Additionally, phase velocity and trajectory tracking of wave-packets was also performed. We combined these observations to derive other properties of the waves such as vertical wavelength of detected packets. Our observations include 13 months worth of data from August 2007 to October 2008, when the VIRTIS-IR channel became unable to provide data, and all the available data set of IR2 which comprises images from January to November of 2016. Each image was analysed "by eye" and characterisation was manually performed with tools from the same software described in [Peralta et al. 2018].
  • We characterised almost 300 wave-packets across more than 5500 images over a broad region of Venus' globe and our results show a wide range of properties and are not only consistent with previous observations [Peralta et al. 2008] but also expand upon them, taking advantage of two instruments that target the same cloud layer of Venus across multiple time periods.

Acknowledgements

This research is supported by the University of Lisbon through the BD2017 program based on the regulation of investigation grants of the University of Lisbon, approved by law 89/2014, the Faculty of Sciences of the University of Lisbon and the Portuguese Foundation for Science and Technology FCT through the project P TUGA PTDC/FIS-AST/29942/2017. We also acknowledge the support of the European Space Agency and the associated funding bodies Centre National d’Etudes Spatiales (France) and Agenzia Spaziale Italiana (Italy) as well as the full team behind the VIRTIS instrument, Venus Express space mission and the PSA archives. Additionally, we acknowledge the support and work of the entire Akatsuki team. The first author also acknowledges the full support of Japan Aerosapce Exploration Agency (JAXA) for enabling a short internship in their facilities which greatly contributed to this work.

References

[1] M.J. Alexander et al. Recent developments in gravity-wave effects in climate models and the global distribution of gravity-wave momentum flux from observations and models. Royal Meteorological Society, 2010.

[2] G. Gilli et al., Impact of gravity waves on the middle atmosphere of mars: a non-orographic gravity wave parameterization based on global climate modeling and MCS observations. Journal of Geophysical Research - Planets, 2020.

[3] J. Peralta et al. Characterization of mesoscale gravity waves in the upper and lower clouds of venus from vex-virtis images. Journal of Geophysical Research, 113, 2008. doi: 10.1029/2008JE003185.

[4] J. Peralta et al. Analytical solution for waves in planets with atmospheric superrotation - I: acoustic and inertia-gravity waves. The Astrophysical journal, supplement series, 517 213:17, 2014. doi: 10.1088/0067-0049/213/1/17.

[5] J. Peralta et al. Nightime winds at the lower clouds of venus with akatsuki/ir2: Longitudinal, local time and decadal variations from comparison with previous measurements. Astrophysical Journal Supplement Series, 2018. URL: arXiv:1810.05418v2.

How to cite: Silva, J., Machado, P., Peralta, J., and Brasil, F.: Characterising atmospheric gravity waves on the lower cloud of Venus - A systematic study, Europlanet Science Congress 2020, online, 21 September–9 Oct 2020, EPSC2020-281, https://doi.org/10.5194/epsc2020-281, 2020

EPSC2020-142
Alejandro Cardesin-Moinelo, Giuseppe Piccioni, Alessandra Migliorini, Davide Grassi, Valeria Cottini, Dmitri Titov, Romolo Politi, Fabrizio Nuccilli, and Pierre Drossart

In this work we have produced global maps of Venus nightside atmosphere using the complete infrared dataset of VIRTIS mapping channel onboard Venus Express between 2006 and 2008. Despite the local variability and high dynamics of the clouds, the accumulation of data over several years allowed us to obtain a global mean state of the atmosphere, where we can observe the average structure of the clouds from equator to the polar regions with a high symmetry north/south even for the local time dependencies.

We have first obtained a global view of the nightside cloud opacity in the lower clouds mapping the integrated radiance in the infrared atmospheric windows around 1.74 μm and 2.3 μm (left maps in Figure 1). The radiance measured around these wavelengths originate below the cloud layer and both bands reflect the opacity of the lower cloud layer (44-48 km altitude), with common trends and high symmetry between the north and south hemispheres. Despite the common elements, the bands 1.74 and 2.3μm behave very differently with respect to the particle size, therefore the ratio between them provides an indirect estimation of the particle size distribution for these clouds, which is especially evident near the polar regions and also around the mid-latitude cloud belt (middle maps in Figure 1). We have then produced maps of the brightness temperatures in the thermal region around 3.8 μm and 5.0 μm, which provide a direct indication of the temperatures at the top of the clouds (60–70 km altitude) and the cooling with local time visible in both hemispheres (right maps in Figure 1).



Figure 1: Maps of Venus nightside atmosphere. Top maps represent latitude and local time (evening on the right, midnight in the center, morning on the left). Bottom maps are centered at the south pole and distributed with longitude. Left: Cloud opacity (inverse of the integrated radiance at 1.74μm, high opacity regions in both poles are dark due to the low radiance, mid-latitude clouds have highest radiance and lowest opacity). Middle: Particle size (ratio of the integrated radiance at 1.74 and 2.3μm, bright areas in both poles indicate larger particle sizes, mid-latitude cloud belt has smallest particle sizes). Right: Cloud top temperature (thermal brightness measured at 3.8μm, cold collar evening-morning cooling is visible and symmetric in both hemispheres).

These maps provide a global view of the global atmospheric dynamics at various altitudes, showing the main regions of the planet and the main characteristics in line with the latest general circulation models of Venus. The equatorial region shows a uniform cloud opacity and particle size, with no significant local time variations throughout the night except for the gradual temperature cooling of the cloud tops from evening to morning. The mid-latitude cloud belt extends uniformly over the night with the lowest opacity and lowest particle size distribution for both hemispheres, with an interesting asymmetry as the Northern hemisphere seems to have lower opacity and relative particle sizes. Towards the polar regions, the cold-collar appears with highest opacity and particle sizes, with a clear evening-to-morning cooling that had already been reported separately for the North and South hemispheres, and is now shown simultaneously providing a more global view of the atmospheric symmetry.
 
Reference publication: "Global maps of Venus nightside mean infrared thermal emissions obtained by VIRTIS on Venus Express". ICARUS, Volume 343, June 2020, 113683, https://doi.org/10.1016/j.icarus.2020.113683

How to cite: Cardesin-Moinelo, A., Piccioni, G., Migliorini, A., Grassi, D., Cottini, V., Titov, D., Politi, R., Nuccilli, F., and Drossart, P.: Venus nightside atmosphere maps: cloud opacity, particle size and cloud top temperature seen by VIRTIS/Venus Express, Europlanet Science Congress 2020, online, 21 September–9 Oct 2020, EPSC2020-142, https://doi.org/10.5194/epsc2020-142, 2020

EPSC2020-558
Takehiko Satoh, Choon Wei Vun, Takeshi Horinouchi, and Takao M. Sato

The spatial and temporal structures of "Enormous Cloud Cover" (ECC), seen in 2.26- and 1.735-µm Venus' night-side images acquired by Akatsuki/IR2, are investigated. The data were acquired on 18th and 27th August 2016 and have been processed newly-developed "Restoration by Deconvolution" (RD) method that effectively removes contaminating light spread from the intense day crescent. Spectral radiances are compared between ECC and "seemingly normal" area (BC = Background Clouds). Attenuation by ECC is stronger at 2.26 µm (~70 to 80 %) than at 1.735 µm (~50 %) due primarily to lower single-scattering albedo of cloud particles at 2.26 µm. Detailed radiative-transfer analyses suggest the followings:

A possible scenario to explain these observational characteristics, strong upwelling region near the western end (front of propagating feature), pushing H2SO4 vapor to condensate in high altitudes. After the region of strongest upwelling propagates away, the cloud particles gradually sediment or are pulled back by downwelling motion of atmosphere.

Details of data analysis, interpretation of phenomena with comarison to numerical simulations will be presented.

How to cite: Satoh, T., Vun, C. W., Horinouchi, T., and Sato, T. M.: Structure of enormous cloud cover seen in Venus' night-side by Akatsuki/IR2, Europlanet Science Congress 2020, online, 21 September–9 Oct 2020, EPSC2020-558, https://doi.org/10.5194/epsc2020-558, 2020

EPSC2020-483ECP
Richard Hart, Christopher Russell, Jayesh Pabari, and Tielong Zhang

Lightning produces an extremely low frequency (ELF) radio wave that propagates along magnetic field lines to higher altitudes in the ionosphere. Venus lacks an intrinsic magnetic dipole, so the interplanetary magnetic field (IMF) drapes around the planet forming a comet-like tail. The IMF induces currents in the ionosphere that generate an opposing field. The field lines tend to be nearly horizontal to the surface around much of the planet, except in the tail where it is more radial. There must be a dip to the field in order for waves to be guided to higher altitudes on the dayside. Therefore, a wave on the dayside is less likely to enter the ionosphere at the zenith of its source and more likely to enter at angles towards the horizon, where the field lines and wave path are more aligned.

The dual fluxgate magnetometer onboard Venus Express (VEX) was able to detect ELF signals up to 64 Hz at various altitudes throughout the mission. We searched all available data within the ionosphere for lightning-generated whistler-mode waves. These waves are right-handed, circularly-polarized waves and propagate along the magnetic field. With a complete set of whistler observations, we can then calculate the Poynting flux of the waves. The Poynting flux requires the three components of both the wave electric field and magnetic field. Unfortunately, VEX did not have a means of measuring the electric field, but we can infer it if we know the phase velocity of the wave. In order to calculate the phase velocity, we need to employ the Venus International Reference Atmosphere model of electron density since VEX did not have any measurements coincident with whistler observations .

The mission was in orbit from 2006-2014 and in that time there were nearly 7 cumulative hours of whistler observations below 400 km. In some cases, there was continuous activity for over a minute, implying a connection to an electrical storm below. These signals were most frequently seen when the spacecraft was at ~250 km altitude. Most signals were observed within 200-350 km altitude with a rate of ~3% of the time the spacecraft spent at these altitudes. It should be noted that due to the polar orbit of Venus Express, the lowest latitude of a detection was ~50°.

The VEX mission spanned almost one solar cycle, so we can compare observations during the solar minimum and maximum periods. Because the ionosphere becomes strongly magnetized during solar minimum, detection rates are about twice as high compared to solar maximum. The Poynting flux during solar maximum shows a decrease with increasing altitude, providing further evidence that the waves were generated below the ionosphere. This conclusion is less clear during solar minimum. A large sample of case studies are left for future work to highlight features that might be lost to statistical averaging.

Pioneer Venus (PVO) was able to detect the electric component of lightning-generated waves at 100 and 700 Hz, but on the nightside and at lower latitudes in contrast to the North polar orbit of VEX. The improved capability of VEX over PVO has greatly increased our knowledge of Venus lightning. The Indian Space Agency (IRSO) has announced plans for a future Venus orbiter at low latitudes. If a lightning oriented investigation were included, their data would be very complementary to previous studies.

How to cite: Hart, R., Russell, C., Pabari, J., and Zhang, T.: The Strength of Lightning on Venus Inferred from Ionospheric Whistler-Mode Waves, Europlanet Science Congress 2020, online, 21 September–9 Oct 2020, EPSC2020-483, https://doi.org/10.5194/epsc2020-483, 2020

EPSC2020-52ECP
Anna Gülcher, Taras Gerya, Laurent Montési, and Jessica Munch

In the absence of global plate tectonics, mantle convection and plume-lithosphere interaction are the main drivers of surface deformation on Venus. Whether Venus is geologically active today remains in question: the apparent young surface age and random distribution of impact craters on the planet, initially ascribed as resulting from a global resurfacing event 500-700 Myr ago1,2,3, can also be explained by equilibrium processes, suggestive of ongoing regional resurfacing4,5. Moreover, recent studies have identified active hotspots6,7,8,9 and young individual lava flows10 on the planet.

Among documented tectonic structures, circular volcano-tectonic features known as coronae are perhaps the clearest surface manifestations of mantle plumes and may hold clues to the global Venusian tectonic regime. Coronae are characteristic quasi-circular volcano-tectonic features that are abundant on the Venusian surface and generally associated with volcanism, topographic relief, and concentric or radial faulted patterns9,11,12 (left panels of Fig. 1). They feature a wide range of sizes and morphology but typically display an annulus of closely spaced concentric fractures and/or ridges superimposed on a raised rim, with a central relief ranging from domes to depressions12. The exact processes underlying their development and the reasons for their diverse morphologies remain controversial.

We conducted a systematic 3D numerical study of plume-lithosphere interaction that links the morphological diversity of large coronae to lithospheric structure and provide guidance for identifying which coronae are currently active. The morphology of at least thirty-seven coronae, dominantly located in a region covering Themis Regio, Lada Terra, and Alpha Regio, is consistent with present-day activity. We thereby provide evidence for widespread plume activity on the planet. The work presented here has just been published in Nature Geoscience13.    


Fig 1. Venusian coronae (left), their topographic signatures (middle) and comparison with numerical models (right)13


3D numerical experiments of coronae formation
We ran 3D high-resolution thermomechanical numerical simulations of impingement of a thermal mantle plume into the Venusian lithosphere to assess the origin and diversity of large Venusian coronae. We systematically varied plume size and temperature, the lithospheric strength and crustal thickness in the models. Our results reveal four regimes of plume-lithosphere interactions underlying corona development at the surface (Figure 2): (1) lithospheric dripping, (2) short-lived subduction, (3) embedded plume, and (4) plume underplating. The ratio of plume buoyancy over lithospheric strength majorly controls these dynamic regimes. This found dependency of plume-lithosphere dynamics on plume buoyancy and lithospheric configuration is key for future studies on plume-lithosphere interactions on Venus or (early) Earth. 

During the first three plume-lithosphere interaction scenarios (regimes (1)-(3)), plume penetration and spreading induce crustal thickness variations that eventually lead to a final topographic isostasy-driven topographic inversion that turns circular trenches surrounding elevated interiors into raised rims surrounding inner depressions.

Reasons behind the morphological diversity of coronae
The temporal evolution of the topographic profiles of the modelled coronae show that different corona morphologies represent no­­­t only different styles of plume-lithosphere interactions, but also different stages in evolution. Coronae with rims and/or trenches are only produced by mantle plumes that (partially) penetrate into the Venusian lithosphere. The common occurrence of coronae displaying rims on Venus suggests that most plumes that formed coronae were able to penetrate at least partially into the lithosphere. In addition, for coronae formed by a penetrative mantle plume, we are able to distinguish active from inactive structures: active coronae feature an outer trench and rise that imply ongoing suction above downwards-moving lithospheric material, as well as elevated interior supported by plume buoyancy­­­­. By contrast, inactive coronae show an inverted topographic profile with an outer rim and an inner depression linked to a thinned lithosphere.

Observational evidence for coronae activity and implications for Venus' geodynamics
We evaluated the possibility of present-day corona activity by systematically analysing the surface topography of large coronae on Venus. Each corona is labelled as currently “active” if it features a clear outer rise and trench, “inactive” if no outer rise but a rim and inner depression is evident, or“unclassified” if the presence of these features is ambiguous. We found expressions of current activity on thirty-seven coronae on Venus (including Artemis Corona, Fig. 1a), whereas thirty-five other coronae were marked “inactive” (including Thouris Corona, Fig. 1b). The remaining coronae are marked “inconclusive”, either because their topography was not well resolved by the dataset, presented ambiguous features, or was markedly different from that obtained in our models. 


Fig 2. Global distribution of coronae identified as inactive (white circles) or showing ongoing plume activity (red circles)13

Our study presents new evidence for recent tectonic and magmatic activity in the lithosphere Venus, complementing other indications of such activity6,8,10,15,16. Coronae activity spanning a variety of surface ages implies a gradual resurfacing behavior of Venus, akin to Earth-like volcanic and interior processes4,5. Moreover, the global arrangement of active coronae (Fig. 2) suggests a large-scale organization of tectono-magmatic activity on the planet, with a broad active region covering Themis Regio, Lada terra, and Alpha Regio, as well as Eistla Regio, in contrast to regions where large active coronae are absent (around Beta and Phoebe Regiones). Finally, our suggested regions of extensive recent corona activity may serve as interesting targets for detailed investigation by future spacecraft missions.

References

1. Turcotte, D.L. (1993) J. Geophys. Res. 98, 17061-17068

2. Strom, R.G. et al. (1994) J. Geophys. Res. 99, 10899-10926

3. Romeo, L. (2013) Planetary and Space Science 87, 157-172

4. Herrick, R.R., & Rumpf, M. E. (2011) J. Geophys. Res. 116, E2

5. Bjonnes, E.E. et al. (2012) Icarus 217, 451-461

6. Smrekar, S.E. et al. (2010) Science 30, 605-608

7. Phillips, R.J. et al. (1991) Science 252, 651-658

8. Stofan, E.R. et al. (1995) J. Geophys. Res. 100, 23317-23327

9. Stofan, E.R. et al. (1992) J. Geophys. Res. 97, 13347-13378

10. Filiberto J. et al. (2020) Science Adv. 6, eaax7445

11. Stofan, E.R. et al. (1991) J. Geophys. Res. 96, 20933-20946

12. Roberts, K. and Head, J. W. (1993) Geophys. Res. Let. 20, 1111-1114

13. Gülcher, A.J.P. et al. (2020) Nat. Geosci., https://doi.org/10.1038/s41561-020-0606-1

14. Gerya, T.V. (2014) Earth Planet. Sci. Lett. 391, 183-192

15. Sandwell, D.T., & Schubert, G. (1992) Science 5071, 766-770

16. Zampa, L.S. et al. (2018) Planetary and Space Science 157, 48-62

 

How to cite: Gülcher, A., Gerya, T., Montési, L., and Munch, J.: Widespread ongoing plume activity on Venus revealed by variations in the morphology of large coronae, Europlanet Science Congress 2020, online, 21 September–9 Oct 2020, EPSC2020-52, https://doi.org/10.5194/epsc2020-52, 2020

EPSC2020-386
Anne Davaille and Suzanne Smrekar

Venus today presents no large-scale network of subduction and accretion ridges, which is the signature of plate tectonics on Earth. On the other hand, Venus relatively young surface points towards either a quite recent catastrophic renewal of the whole planet surface (« episodic subduction regime »), or the continuous renewal of small areas of the planet for exemple by volcanism.

Unique to Venus, coronae are circular features from 50 to 2600 km in diameter. The largest ones have been attributed to mantle plumes. Close inspection of Magellan’s data revealed that subduction features are also encountered on part of their rim (McKenzie et al, 1992 ; Sandwell and Schubert, 1992, 1995).  Recent modeling has shown that plumes could indeed induce roll-back subduction around segments of an expanding coronae. Artemis coronae is the largest coronae on Venus and shows both plume and subduction features that are well explained by the plume-induced subduction mechanism (Davaille et al, 2017). Scaling laws then predict a slab roll-back (and therefore a coronae expansion) velocity between 1 and 10 cm/yr.  If the coronae has been expanding, then we should expect the existence of an accreting ridge system  inside the coronae, equivalent to the Earth’s mid-ocean ridges developing in back-arc basins. Artemis interior indeed also presents a prominent ridge system (Sandwell and Schubert, 1992 ; Brown and Grimm, 1996 ; Spencer, 2001 ; Hansen, 2002), but its lateral tortuosity is much more prononced than on Earth (fig.1).   

Using laboratory experiments, we recently showed that the shape of an accretion ridge is governed primarily by the axial failure parameter ΠF, which depends on the spreading velocity, the mechanical strength of the lithospheric material and the axial elastic lithosphere thickness (Sibrant et al, 2018). Experiments with the largest ΠF presented quite unstable ridge axis with a large lateral sinuosity,  long transform faults, and the formation of numerous microplates. These microplates rotate along the transforms before getting incorporated in the main plate on one side of the ridge axis or the other. There, they appear as blocks whose main fabric is either concentric or rotated compared to the main plate’s. 

On a planet, this regime occurs for high spreading velocity and/or low axial elastic thickness. For the Earth, it would require spreading velocities greater  than 30 cm/yr. But on Venus, where the surface temperature is about 500°C higher, and therefore the elastic thickness on the ridge axis is smaller than on Earth, spreading velocities between 1 and 10 cm/yr would suffice. The scaling laws derived from the laboratory experiments further predict a tortuosity of the ridge axis comparable to what is observed inside Artemis coronae (fig.1). Furthermore, guided by the experiments, we are tempted to identify two long transform faults on each side of Britomartis, as well as a number of rotated blocks or microplates. However, the resolution of Magellan data is not sufficient to be sure of our interpretation. There is an urgent need for better resolution and better coverage of Venus topography, that a mission such as VERITAS could provide.

 

How to cite: Davaille, A. and Smrekar, S.: Ridge Dynamics in the expanding Artemis Coronae: axis sinuosity, transform faults, and microplates., Europlanet Science Congress 2020, online, 21 September–9 Oct 2020, EPSC2020-386, https://doi.org/10.5194/epsc2020-386, 2020

EPSC2020-534
Walter S. Kiefer, James Garvin, Giada Arney, Sushil Atreya, Bruce Campbell, Valeria Cottini, Justin Filiberto, Stephanie Getty, Martha Gilmore, David Grinspoon, Noam Izenberg, Natasha Johnson, Ralph Lorenz, Charles Malespin, Michael Ravine, Christopher Webster, and Kevin Zahnle

Understanding the divergent evolution of Venus and Earth is a fundamental problem in planetary science. Although Venus today has a hot, dry atmosphere, recent modeling suggests that Venus may have had a clement surface with liquid water until less than 1 billion years ago [1]. Venus today has a nearly stagnant lithosphere. However, Ishtar Terra’s folded mountain belts, 8-11 km high, morphologically resemble Tibet and the Himalaya mountains on Earth and apparently require several thousand kilometers of surface motion at some time in Venus’s past. Loss of liquid surface water increases the coefficient of friction in fault zones, favoring a transition from an early mobile lithosphere to a present-day stagnant lithosphere [2]. Solar-driven climate evolution could contribute to a prolonged epoch of water loss on Venus and may be the ultimate cause of the divergent evolution of both the climate history and the interior dynamics of Venus and Earth.

In addition to being a problem of first-order importance for Solar System evolution, understanding the divergent evolution of Venus and Earth is also important for understanding the temporal and spatial distribution of habitable environments in the Solar System. Understanding the evolution of Venus is also a key test for models that interpret Earth-sized exoplanets. Testing evolutionary hypotheses requires interpreting clues that were left behind in both the isotopic composition of the Venus atmosphere and in the rock record of the Venus surface. Although several mission concepts are currently competing for possible flights to Venus, only the Deep Atmosphere Venus Investigation of Noble gases, Chemistry, and Imaging Plus (DAVINCI+) mission [3] can examine both the atmospheric isotopic record and the rock record of Venus. DAVINCI+ is therefore a compelling choice for selection in the current NASA Discovery Program Phase A competition.

DAVINCI+ includes an atmospheric entry probe and a carrier spacecraft (Figure 1). The probe measures atmospheric composition using a mass spectrometer and tunable laser spectrometer, performs descent imaging, and measures atmospheric structure. Following completion of the probe mission, the carrier spacecraft enters Venus orbit and images the Venus surface in the 1 micron atmospheric window. This payload is ideally suited for testing models of Venus evolution.

Figure 1: The DAVINCI+ entry probe studies the atmosphere while imaging the Alpha Regio landing site. Afterward, the carrier probe performs infrared imaging of selected targets from orbit.

The History of Water: Isotopic Record

Pioneer Venus measured the D/H value of an H2SO4 cloud droplet at ~55 km as 157±30 times the terrestrial value, which was interpreted as the signature of escape of water from the Venus atmosphere [4]. Terrestrial spectroscopy produced a similar range, whereas Venus Express measured a value up to three times larger between 70-90 km [5]. The large value relative to Earth shows that Venus lost a substantial amount of water, but the large uncertainty and the lack of data below the clouds makes it difficult to quantitatively model the history of water loss [6]. DAVINCI+ will measure D/H to high precision from above the clouds down to the surface, greatly improving our ability to interpret the history of water loss on Venus. In addition, the abundance and isotopic ratios of Xe and Kr, together with the Kr/Ar and Xe/Ar ratios, which DAVINCI+ will measure with high precision, will be instrumental in revealing whether Venus and Earth formed in the same way and how their climates diverged. 

The History of Water: Rock Record

 A key but poorly answered question is the extent to which Venus has produced granitic or felsic (SiO2-rich) volcanism. Small amounts of felsic magma can be generated by lithospheric processes [7], but large amounts of felsic material requires the presence of water in the melting zone [8], as in terrestrial subduction zones. Tessera, which are regions of old, thick, highly tectonized crust, are widely accepted as the most likely location for felsic material on Venus. Venus Express observations suggest that tessera in Alpha Regio has a felsic composition [9].

DAVINCI+ will explore the presence and distribution of felsic rock in two ways. Comparison of the reflectivity at 1 micron and in panchromatic descent images at the Alpha Regio landing site will test the presence of felsic rock at patch sizes much smaller than can be observed from orbit. Descent imaging will also explore the landing zone geomorphology, and stereo topography will enable quantitative modelling of faulting and folding. Orbital imaging in the 1 micron atmospheric window will test for the presence of felsic rock in other tessera, including Tellus Regio, Fortuna Tessera, Maxwell Montes, Ovda Regio, and Thetis Regio. Our approach is similar to VIRTIS on Venus Express [9] but focuses on regions in the northern hemisphere and near the equator that were not imaged by VIRTIS.

The History of Volcanism: Isotopic Record

Volcanic outgassing releases radioactive decay products such as 40Ar and 4He to the atmosphere. DAVINCI+ measurements of their atmospheric abundance can be used to estimate volcanic outgassing over time. 40Ar provides an integrated record of volcanism over Venus history. Because 4He escapes from the atmosphere to space, its atmospheric abundance constrains geologically recent (last billion years) volcanism. Existing measurements of 40Ar and 4He are too imprecise to strongly constrain the volcanic history of Venus [10] but will be measured with much greater accuracy by DAVINCI+. Because DAVINCI+ will constrain the history of both water and volcanism on Venus, it will provide new insights into the feedbacks that shaped the divergent evolution of Venus and Earth.

References

[1] Way and Del Genio, JGR 125, e2019JE006276, 2020. [2] Weller and Kiefer, JGR 125, e2019JE005960, 2020. [3] Garvin et al., LPSC 51, abstract 2599, 2020. [4] Donahue et al., Science 216, 630-633, 1982. [5] Bertaux et al., Nature 450, 646-649, 2007. [6] Donahue et al., Venus II, 385-414, 1997. [7] Elkins-Tanton et al., JGR 112, E04S06, 2007. [8] Campbell and Taylor, GRL 10, 1061-1064, 1983. [9] Gilmore et al., Icarus 254, 350-361, 2015. [10] Namiki and Solomon, JGR 103, 3655-3677, 1998. 

 

 

How to cite: Kiefer, W. S., Garvin, J., Arney, G., Atreya, S., Campbell, B., Cottini, V., Filiberto, J., Getty, S., Gilmore, M., Grinspoon, D., Izenberg, N., Johnson, N., Lorenz, R., Malespin, C., Ravine, M., Webster, C., and Zahnle, K.: Venus, Earth's divergent twin?: Testing evolutionary models for Venus with the DAVINCI+ mission, Europlanet Science Congress 2020, online, 21 September–9 Oct 2020, EPSC2020-534, https://doi.org/10.5194/epsc2020-534, 2020

EPSC2020-447
| MI
Sue Smrekar, Darby Dyar, Jörn Helbert, Scott Hensley, Daniel Nunes, and Jennifer Whitten

VERITAS is a proposed Discovery mission concept, currently in Step 2 (Phase A), and would launch in 2026. VERITAS addresses one of the most fundamental questions in rocky planetary evolution: why did twin planets follow different evolutionary paths? Venus’ hot lithosphere may be a good analog for early Earth, and could be responsible for the apparent lack of plate tectonics.  Determining the factors that lead to the initiation of plate tectonics would inform our predictions for rocky Earth-sized exoplanets.  VERITAS answers key questions about Venus’ geologic evolution and searches for current activity and evidence for past or present water.

Payload: VERITAS carries two instruments and conducts gravity science. The VISAR X-band [Hensley et al., this meeting] measurements include: 1) a global digital elevation model (DEM) with 250 m postings, 5 m height accuracy, 2) Synthetic aperture radar (SAR) imaging at 30 m horizontal resolution globally, 3) SAR imaging at 15 m resolution > 20% of the surface and 4) surface deformation from RPI at 2 mm precision for at least 12 targeted, potentially active areas. VEM [Helbert et al., this meeting] would produce surface coverage of most of the surface in 6 NIR bands located within 5 atmospheric windows and of 8 atmospheric bands for calibration and water vapor measurements. VERITAS would use Ka-band uplink and downlink to create a global gravity field with 3 mgal accuracy / 160 km resolution.

Science: VERITAS looks for the chemical fingerprint of past water in the form of low Fe, high Si rock in the tessera plateaus [Dyar et al. submitted, 2020; Helbert et al., submitted, 2020] and for present day volcanic outgassing of volatiles in the form of near surface water outgassing due to recent or active volcanism. 

VERITAS uses a variety of approaches to search for present day activity, including 1) tectonic and volcanic cm-scale surface deformation, 2) chemical weathering, 3) thermal emission from recent or active volcanism, 4) topographic or surface roughness changes, and 5) comparisons to past mission data sets.

VERITAS constrains rocky planet evolution via: 1) examining the origin of tesserae plateaus -possible continent-like features, 2) assessing the history of volcanism, 3) looking for evidence of prior tectonic or impact features buried by volcanism, and 4) determining the origin of tectonic features such as huge arcuate troughs that have been compared to Earth’s subduction zones.

VERITAS gravity data (resolution 160 km, 3x better than avg. Magellan resolution), would enable estimation of elastic thickness (a proxy for thermal gradient) and determination of core size [Mazerico et al. Fall AGU 2019].

 

Conclusions: VERITAS would create a rich data set of high-resolution topography, imaging, spectroscopy, and gravity. These co-registered data would be on par with those acquired for Mercury, Mars and the Moon that have revolutionized our understanding of these bodies. In addition to answering fundamental science questions, VERITAS’ data would motivate further Venus missions.  Active surface deformation would promote a seismic mission. Accurate topography plus surface rock type would optimize targeting of surface or areal missions.

Acknowledgements: A portion of this research was conducted at the Jet Propulsion Laboratory, California Institute of Technology, under contract with NASA. The information presented to about the VERITAS mission concept is pre-decisional and is provided for planning and discussion purposes only.

How to cite: Smrekar, S., Dyar, D., Helbert, J., Hensley, S., Nunes, D., and Whitten, J.: VERITAS (Venus Emissivity, Radio Science, InSAR, Topography And Spectroscopy): A Proposed Discovery Mission , Europlanet Science Congress 2020, online, 21 September–9 Oct 2020, EPSC2020-447, https://doi.org/10.5194/epsc2020-447, 2020